gemini54 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#1
The complex Psyche of Dev. This is not in support of his actions/inaction's but just to view him as an individual with deep rooted want for acceptance only from his lady love why is it?

His Mother the person who literally molded him for who he was. We as parents always push our children to be the best they can, get good grades we say, succeed we say, be a good human being we say and a lot of other things.

Children want to please that is a common trait that all children possess so Dev wanted to please and how could he please by becoming successful.

He did not have a father figure or rather had a weak one ..I am not saying that single mothers or Dads cannot raise strong children but children do need strong role models whether it is Moms or Dads. That is why many young Men who are children of single mothers have idols that they worship like a Basketball player or someone else.

He was devoid of friends because Easwari never allowed him to have one , he was not close to his siblings because Easwari did not allow that..So what did he have? a mother who doted over him and in return wanted a son who worshiped her and so he did just that.

He lacked the Emotional Quotient because other than his mother he really did not have an emotional connect with anyone ; enter Sona like a breathe of fresh air in his life. The words he told Sona though look romantic in the surface was all about his need or obsession to be loved by the other person exclusively..This is where the first disconnect was Sona loved Dev but she came from a family where there was no exclusivity only inclusion and so the ideologies clashed the more Sona wanted to have an inclusive family the more Easwari position was threatened the more Easwari was threatened she threatened Dev in the end he was this person just swinging from one to another why because the only two person he had in his life was Easwari who expected him to be a certain way and Sona who wanted him to be a certain way ( this was unconscious) that is why he said he wanted to be a better man when he was with her..because he knew he really wasn't. Into this dynamics comes another Family who are inclusive too the Bose's they did not understand the Easwari dynamics because we only know what we are exposed too and they weren't. Under these circumstances any marriage will not succeed because Dev was being pulled in all directions and lacked the personal strength to balance and Sona really did not understand this lack of balance.

All the stalking the obsessive behavior the possessiveness, the anger all stemming from his lack of Emotional maturity and the root cause is his Mother..who never let him GROW UP

This Dev seemed to have woken up he is still doing all the things he should but wants to live for himself and Reenters Sona again a Sona who looks different, acts different and in essence really does not need him or anyone else Just like Easwari wants to be needed by Dev Dev wants to be needed by Sona it did not happen in season 1 and by the looks of it is not happening in season 2 . I do not know what the new entry is for or purpose but maybe in life if we had a chance to 'Do Over' things maybe all of us will rectify the things we did wrong..Maybe this is a time to rewrite the Rang ..the colors in permanent markers so it does not wash away when the going gets tough. And Easwari realizes that her Son has really Grown Up

Closing with this quote from a book which has an uncanny resemblance to what is happening now in the story

The sense that in his mother's view, he had let down his family just by being who he was... was a failure of acceptance that he was never going to get over. He just wanted to live, honestly and out front, with no apology. Like everyone else. To love who he loved, be who he was... but society had a different standard."


J.R. Ward, Lover at Last

P.S We can hate him , be appalled with his actions but seem to not ignore him and the makers have created that affect and for that they need to be commended for creating the character of Dev Dixit



Created

Last reply

Replies

18

Views

2k

Users

9

Likes

116

Frequent Posters

preethik thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#2
Sabita (may I call you that) you write beautifully!

Yes as dev himself said he is a very complex man. His upbringing by ish has been very skewed to the exclusion of all others. It took a very bitter lesson for this relationship to unravel. With ish & rest of the family he has kind of made his peace & truly moved on.

With sona he never got any closure. His hate has been simmering for 7yrs & we see that coming out in the initial S2 episodes. But unfortunately his immense love is hidden below all this hate. We can see it when he looks at her.

The new entry hopefully is not going to be like ritwick. Maybe his entry might be the key for sona to figure out her life - cannot live without dev or move ahead without him. The scenarios are so full of potential!
Jade0001 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 8 years ago
#3
An Excellent Analysis

Dev grew up on shaky grounds he had to mature and be the man of the house always trying his best to protect his mother
Ishwari on the other hand gave him the responsibility to take the family out of poverty which indeed is a good thing , where she went wrong was not allowing him to interact with his sisters or have friends making him fragile for the future
according to Ishwari all she needed was Dev and he needed his mother this made her happy as a parent that her child is obedient and she is on the right track in growing him up .
Dev loved his mother he still does , he respects her and devoted his time to her made sure she was happy but she did not really see that her son was happy with his wife she had thought that Dev can only be happy with his mother again she was wrong

Dev has learned the crueliest lesson about his family more importantly about his mother and his wife
he had always expected both to work through their problems but come together and make him happy which certainly didn't happen


Tia.0 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 8 years ago
#4
Excellent analysis Sabita. Yes, by now we have pretty much done the complete post-mortem on Dev Dixit's psyche. But still we have no solution in sight. Why? Because no matter how much you want to help someone, until they themselves want to be helped and take their own initiative, you can't help them.
The way this forum understands Dev, if he tries to look into himself really, without filters, and admit his issues, that will be half of battle won.

One thing I wrote in my comment that by now we all "understand" Dev as to why he is the way he is. But can we be understanding to his plight and situation? Well, can't talk about everyone. But I can't yet. Simply because I can't justify his actions even though I know why he is doing what he is doing.

That's my problem with this complex man called Dev Dixit.
gemini54 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#5
Thanks Yes you can call me Sabita😛

Originally posted by: preethik

Sabita (may I call you that) you write beautifully!

Yes as dev himself said he is a very complex man. His upbringing by ish has been very skewed to the exclusion of all others. It took a very bitter lesson for this relationship to unravel. With ish & rest of the family he has kind of made his peace & truly moved on.

With sona he never got any closure. His hate has been simmering for 7yrs & we see that coming out in the initial S2 episodes. But unfortunately his immense love is hidden below all this hate. We can see it when he looks at her.

The new entry hopefully is not going to be like ritwick. Maybe his entry might be the key for sona to figure out her life - cannot live without dev or move ahead without him. The scenarios are so full of potential!

gemini54 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#6
Tia I agree with what you wrote and that is why I wrote the Do Over comment..dont we all wish in life that we had a chance to Do Over something at least I do but seldom do we get chances. I am hoping that this show the characters will get the chances and that will be the growth that we are all wanting


Originally posted by: tia.o

Excellent analysis Sabita. Yes, by now we have pretty much done the complete post-mortem on Dev Dixit's psyche. But still we have no solution in sight. Why? Because no matter how much you want to help someone, until they themselves want to be helped and take their own initiative, you can't help them.

The way this forum understands Dev, if he tries to look into himself really, without filters, and admit his issues, that will be half of battle won.

One thing I wrote in my comment that by now we all "understand" Dev as to why he is the way he is. But can we be understanding to his plight and situation? Well, can't talk about everyone. But I can't yet. Simply because I can't justify his actions even though I know why he is doing what he is doing.

That's my problem with this complex man called Dev Dixit.

NeerajaGirish thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 8 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: gemini54

The complex Psyche of Dev. This is not in support of his actions/inaction's but just to view him as an individual with deep rooted want for acceptance only from his lady love why is it?

His Mother the person who literally molded him for who he was. We as parents always push our children to be the best they can, get good grades we say, succeed we say, be a good human being we say and a lot of other things.

Children want to please that is a common trait that all children possess so Dev wanted to please and how could he please by becoming successful.

He did not have a father figure or rather had a weak one ..I am not saying that single mothers or Dads cannot raise strong children but children do need strong role models whether it is Moms or Dads. That is why many young Men who are children of single mothers have idols that they worship like a Basketball player or someone else.

He was devoid of friends because Easwari never allowed him to have one , he was not close to his siblings because Easwari did not allow that..So what did he have? a mother who doted over him and in return wanted a son who worshiped her and so he did just that.

He lacked the Emotional Quotient because other than his mother he really did not have an emotional connect with anyone ; enter Sona like a breathe of fresh air in his life. The words he told Sona though look romantic in the surface was all about his need or obsession to be loved by the other person exclusively..This is where the first disconnect was Sona loved Dev but she came from a family where there was no exclusivity only inclusion and so the ideologies clashed the more Sona wanted to have an inclusive family the more Easwari position was threatened the more Easwari was threatened she threatened Dev in the end he was this person just swinging from one to another why because the only two person he had in his life was Easwari who expected him to be a certain way and Sona who wanted him to be a certain way ( this was unconscious) that is why he said he wanted to be a better man when he was with her..because he knew he really wasn't. Into this dynamics comes another Family who are inclusive too the Bose's they did not understand the Easwari dynamics because we only know what we are exposed too and they weren't. Under these circumstances any marriage will not succeed because Dev was being pulled in all directions and lacked the personal strength to balance and Sona really did not understand this lack of balance.

All the stalking the obsessive behavior the possessiveness, the anger all stemming from his lack of Emotional maturity and the root cause is his Mother..who never let him GROW UP

This Dev seemed to have woken up he is still doing all the things he should but wants to live for himself and Reenters Sona again a Sona who looks different, acts different and in essence really does not need him or anyone else Just like Easwari wants to be needed by Dev Dev wants to be needed by Sona it did not happen in season 1 and by the looks of it is not happening in season 2 . I do not know what the new entry is for or purpose but maybe in life if we had a chance to 'Do Over' things maybe all of us will rectify the things we did wrong..Maybe this is a time to rewrite the Rang ..the colors in permanent markers so it does not wash away when the going gets tough. And Easwari realizes that her Son has really Grown Up

Closing with this quote from a book which has an uncanny resemblance to what is happening now in the story

The sense that in his mother's view, he had let down his family just by being who he was... was a failure of acceptance that he was never going to get over. He just wanted to live, honestly and out front, with no apology. Like everyone else. To love who he loved, be who he was... but society had a different standard."


J.R. Ward, Lover at Last

P.S We can hate him , be appalled with his actions but seem to not ignore him and the makers have created that affect and for that they need to be commended for creating the character of Dev Dixit



You write beautifully but I don't agree that the everything about his behaviour to be blamed on Ishwari's upbringing. He was well read, self made and successful businessman but he couldn't be honest. He claimed he loved and worshipped his mother, he loved Sona but he couldn't be honest with either of them. I still remember one scene where he felt his mother forced Sona to fast he went to confort her, but when he needs to be open and communicate he took help of lies, hiding the truth. Ishwari is bad or however she is, Dev cannot be excused for his behaviour like a jerk.
gemini54 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#8
Thanks for reading and commenting. This post was not Pro or Anti Dev but just to show when you lack emotional quotient does not matter if you are well read, old young, successful ..You simply lack it and so act in impulse and so he acts in impulse ..dont children take the easy way out first.. I know from experience they do.. first they say something which will not cause the adult to react negatively then they say the truth regardless of consequences..but who teaches these consequences? that is my point when they are not taught consequences they have to learn the hard way and Dev hopefully is.. I agree he has been a Jerk and a lot of things that I can use here I was not excusing him but just trying to say that parents have the capability to make or break a child in this case Easwari chose to break


You write beautifully but I don't agree that the everything about his behaviour to be blamed on Ishwari's upbringing. He was well read, self made and successful businessman but he couldn't be honest. He claimed he loved and worshipped his mother, he loved Sona but he couldn't be honest with either of them. I still remember one scene where he felt his mother forced Sona to fast he went to confort her, but when he needs to be open and communicate he took help of lies, hiding the truth. Ishwari is bad or however she is, Dev cannot be excused for his behaviour like a jerk.

gaurimisha thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 8 years ago
#9
Excellent Post!!
I understand Dev. Thats why I do sympathise with him.

The only problem I feel he never applied his high education in his real life, it was limited to his business. He applied Ishwari's formula to his personal life and it broke everything.

He is a complex character. He appears childish in many situations. I am appalled at him, may be I expected way too much from somebody with such business acumen and high level of intelligence.

All said and done, I dont exactly hate him because I still believe he is not evil personified.
Aishu13 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#10
Wow great post, may I add something? I always thought of Dev as an circus elephant. As a child, he was forced to obey. Baby elephants are are tied down with many heavy things and are shown that they cannot escape, so as an adult they don't realize that they can escape if they try, because emotionally they are caught. Before leap, I thought Sona would be the one to show that he can escape. But Dev wrapped in his own misery did not listen, and in a way, a reverse psychology worked on him when Sona left. He began to question his own identity, and became a rebellious elephant, he is still emotionally trapped (as shown in yesterday's epi with him caring for his mom) but he has realized that he can escape. But will he realize his cowardliness and escape?

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".