Neha - The Haunted Soul EDITED

Tia.0 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 8 years ago
#1
Today's topic is not Dev or Sona, but Neha.

Neha is forever confused, forever unhappy soul.

Nothing and no one can make her happy. Why? Because happiness lies within one self while she keeps looking for happiness in lifeless objects.

Neha expects to get every privilege, every opportunity to land in her lap because she suffered in childhood and since Dev got everything he owes her all of it.

Dev owes Neha for being the caregiver for their sisters while he got all opportunity and lion share of mother's love and care.

But even he can't make Neha happy.

He can't make Ranveer live on money he earned, Ranveer doesn't have the capability to earn as much money as Dev and Neha wants a combination of Dev's money and Ranveer's love which unfortunately she can't custom make.

If we could customise our life based on our preference then today I will be married to a Hrithik Roshan look alike, Shahrukh Khan natured (DDLJ one, not Darr one) author or poet or chef.

But I am married to a teddy bear look alike, Sheldon natured (Big Bang Theory) Engineer.

P.S. The last person on Earth I wanted to be married to was an Engineer. I just couldn't tolerate their smugness and arrogance being the Artsy-Fartsy type and often the butt of their joke regarding arts and literature.

But you know what? I could not be happier and may be if I could have custom make my life partner, today I'd be really unhappy because just like any other custom order, you didn't fall in love with the actual product, you fell in love with the IDEA of the product which may or may not match your expectations...

Sometimes in life, we want many things. But we don't know what we need until we find them. And I needed the person I am married to.

Moving on from my life, let's come back to Neha.

She expects in exchange for her hard work raising her sisters and giving up her opportunity, everything should be just a bed of roses for her from here on out.

But as I mentioned in my previous post, love, money and happiness does not come without effort. You have to work for all three.

Neha can get only one of them easily because the hard work had been already done by her for it, and that's money.

But love? Neha didn't want to do anything for it.

She loved a man who loved her back - Convenient

She wanted to get married, her family made it happen - Easy peasy

But she picked a man with a poor background who had some responsibilities just like Dev had to his family.

In middle class homes, every expense runs on priority which no one taught Neha.

Ranveer should have discussed with Neha before handing over the money to his family. He can't expect Neha to discuss where she is spending their money and how much she is giving as a gift to her family and not reciprocate. I agree with Neha on that.

But as far as we know, that's his first offence and Neha should make it very clear that she won't tolerate him taking decisions without discussing with her ever again. That's the same advice I gave Sona and the same advice I am giving Neha.

But even to warn Ranveer or give him ultimatum, she needs to talk to him.

So what Sona did today is just try to arrange that talk and remind her what she will loose if she loses Ranveer.

But there are people who'd rather cut their nose to spite their faces.

Neha is one of them.

Instead of talking to Ranveer and coming up with a solution where both could reach a mutual understanding or may be even both decide they are not suitable for each other, she decided to not only refuse to talk with him but send him divorce notice because Sona brought him home and right now in her mind, Sona wants to throw her out of Dixit house.

Neha sees everyone who doesn't nod their head on what she wants, as her enemy when she doesn't get her way.

Ranveer magnified the issue by comparing Neha with Sona which again Neha can't tolerate since right now Sona is persona non grata in her book.

As I mentioned before, Neha needed to figure out what she wants most in life and what she is willing to give up for it.

It seems that she decided that giving up Ranveer is the key to her happiness. But she will regret it. Because she made the decision without thinking or talking it over.

What it looked like to me today is a child who throws tantrum for not getting their own way and keeps pushing the people who love her to see how long they will put up with her.

All part and parcel of her experience, I don't deny that.

And if that's what she wants, she should get it with her family's support.

But then again, she can't put the responsibility for her decision on someone else.

That's the burden of adulthood. If we insist on taking our own decisions, the responsibility of the same also lies with us.

But the million dollar question is, even then, will she finally be happy? I don't think so. Because like I said, happiness lies within and Neha looked everywhere for her happiness except in her own heart.

EDITED: Sorry to all those who I hurt with Engineer comment. It was meant strictly for the men in my family (cousins) who made my life difficult growing up. Obviously my mind was changed by my Engineer husband since I married him. Really sorry if all the Engineers out there got hurt by my statement. My intention was just to show that if I was custom making my husband, I won't be as happy as I am today because he is nothing like the image in my head and neither I am the kind of person he thought he will be married to. But we found what we needed in each other and we are happier than ever.
Edited by tia.o - 8 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

56

Views

4.6k

Users

24

Likes

215

Frequent Posters

gemini54 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#2
Speechless on a Rocking Post👏
Will may be pen some thoughts later for now I think you may have covered all
---Edited----


Edited by gemini54 - 8 years ago
sona_naksh thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 8 years ago
#3
Bang on post tia
I agree wid it
Neha can never be happy because she wants everything but doesnt want to earn it ...be it money love or respect
She wants dev to take care of her , take her tantrums over sona and give watever she asks for but doesnt want ranveer to take care of his family ...
I agree neha had a troubles childhood but it was not dev's fault as ishwari n neha present it to be ...he was given opportunity and he worked hard for it ...he worked day n night wid his mother to meet d ends ...it was nt like neha n ishwari vr troubled n dev was having gala tym ...
Neha wants everything in return of her childhood but she alwaz knew ranveer is a man of self reapect ..hd ll never take help frm dev ...but den she thot d way he accepted job he ll take other things also wich dint happen so dis conflict ...
I feel wenever v make any relation its d efforts frm both sides n wenever it is broken both have deir share of mistakes however less or more ...
Here also both ve done some mistakes ...n d simple solution to it is talk ...how much tym u need to b ready for talking ...

...Doctor... thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 8 years ago
#4
Beautiful post Tia!
Agree with everything you mentioned. One thing I noticed about Neha is that she thinks Sonakshi got everything she dreamed of. Neha fails to notice the amount of efffort Sonakshi is putting in, just to adjust with the narrow minded Dixit, Neha fails to notice how a self respected nutritionist has turned into a punching bag with a job of serving tea. Neha, as far as I remember understood Ishwariy way more than Dev and confronted Ishwari about her wrongdoings. She doesn't do that anymore, she's turning into Dev (always sticking to mom's words and doing shit) -_-
Jade0001 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 8 years ago
#5
Fantastic Post

I agree Neha had to forego her education to take care or be a mother to her younger sisters while Dev went to school . years passed and he became a businessman wow so its time for Neha to throw tantrams instead of asking her brother to help her get some indepentancy all she thought about is throwing remarks at Dev that he is the most loved sure that was the way Ishwari loved her children one more then the rest .
Neha should have tried for her ownself to invent herself see what she can be good at , she decided to learn English and fell in love she never took that chance to explore herself bring her own persona to light no she felt loving Ranveer will make everything easy for her and he'll listen to her every word her brother will support them so life will rosy but when she discovered that Ranveer will not any help from Dev she was disappointed yet she tried staying happy but her happiness did not come from within her as she tried to hard to always just be happy thinking life will get better
she dislikes the fact that Ranveer first considers his family before her now when Dev does the same then its good because in Dev's case she would be also benefitting
the decision to send divorce papers without even trying to make the marriage work is totally insane .
Neha wants wealth she wants love , well love she did get from Ranveer but it seems luxury is much more important to her if she had work experience than yes she too could go out and earn and spend her money as she wishes now she cannot just take money and spend which is causing alot of problems for her
Tia.0 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 8 years ago
#6
Thank you, Sabita... 😊

Originally posted by: gemini54

Speechless on a Rocking Post👏

Will may be pen some thoughts later for now I think you may have covered all

Tia.0 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 8 years ago
#7
You know there's a saying that if you expect a fish to climb tree, then you will only end up being disappointed. Why would Neha expect Ranveer to happily live off Dev, I don't know. But she just paved her own way to disappointment. Ranveer always was very true to everyone. He is a middle class self-made man and that's how he presented himself. Neha on the other hand, did exactly what I said once in my post that sometimes women do. Some woman marry a man thinking them as DIY project. But if you are marrying someone expecting them to change, you are just doomed to disappointment.

Originally posted by: sona_naksh

Bang on post tia

I agree wid it
Neha can never be happy because she wants everything but doesnt want to earn it ...be it money love or respect
She wants dev to take care of her , take her tantrums over sona and give watever she asks for but doesnt want ranveer to take care of his family ...
I agree neha had a troubles childhood but it was not dev's fault as ishwari n neha present it to be ...he was given opportunity and he worked hard for it ...he worked day n night wid his mother to meet d ends ...it was nt like neha n ishwari vr troubled n dev was having gala tym ...
Neha wants everything in return of her childhood but she alwaz knew ranveer is a man of self reapect ..hd ll never take help frm dev ...but den she thot d way he accepted job he ll take other things also wich dint happen so dis conflict ...
I feel wenever v make any relation its d efforts frm both sides n wenever it is broken both have deir share of mistakes however less or more ...
Here also both ve done some mistakes ...n d simple solution to it is talk ...how much tym u need to b ready for talking ...

gemini54 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: tia.o

Thank you, Sabita... 😊


Edited my post..a slightly different take than yours
gemini54 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#9
[
Here are my thoughts

You cant reach for anything new if your hands are still full of yesterdays junk- Anonymous

Neha has been one of the characters that I absolutely adored on the show. She was Bold - she even broke her marriage ( The first one) because she did not want children, she was not afraid to voice what she felt, was a wonderful surrogate mother to Riya and Nikki and In my opinion the only person in Dixit house who knew Easwari true colors.


Neha was a neglected child there is no ifs and buts about it, she was given a great responsibility as a child to take care of her little sisters while she watched Dev get a lot of attention including all the perks. That alone is enough to severely scar a human being but the beauty of it was she never had issues with Dev or his happiness and as far as , Riya and Nikki she was like a surrogate mother to them that makes me believe she is a good soul. I for one dont even believe her issue is with Ranveer but with Easwari and this acting out is all the suppressed anger and emotional pain that she was subjected to when she was young.

I remember one poignant scene with Ranveer when she talks about not ever having a doll to play with , another haunting scene was when pencils were given to everyone except her.

It is a rule that the child who cries the loudest gets the attention she did not cry when she was a child and is doing so now.

Yes it is unfair on Ranveer but in my opinion I dont thing Neha even has the emotional maturity to understand that she is doing wrong. She fell in Love with Ranveer , in my opinion very rushed because he was the first one who paid exclusive attention to her. She knew that Ranveer was poor but just like before when her A/C broke down she thought her brother will solve that part of the equation the money part. But what she did not take into equation is that Ranveer may have his own thoughts on the subject.

Here is where I feel that she really is emotionally scarred to even understand that and to it is added GKB influence as seen in earlier episodes GKB did have an unusual bond with her and could influence her.

This influence is what is happening when she sees Dev and Sona happy and in her mind Sona is also poor financially but is enjoying every luxury and enjoying Love then why can she do the same.(The thought of Sona enjoying is a seed that GKB has sown). when you have the emotional maturity of a child we are susceptible to directions especially from an adult who does have influence on her.

Like I said before the child which cries the most gets the attention and this Divorce is her cry for help.

The past scars in this case runs deep and need to be healed first. So in my opinion she needs healing more than anything else.

You have to make peace with your past in order to keep your future from being a constant battle here she needs to make peace with herself and the past first.

Edited by gemini54 - 8 years ago
sona_naksh thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 8 years ago
#10
[Bang on post tia
I agree wid it
Neha can never be happy because she wants everything but doesnt want to earn it ...be it money love or respect
She wants dev to take care of her , take her tantrums over sona and give watever she asks for but doesnt want ranveer to take care of his family ...
I agree neha had a troubles childhood but it was not dev's fault as ishwari n neha present it to be ...he was given opportunity and he worked hard for it ...he worked day n night wid his mother to meet d ends ...it was nt like neha n ishwari vr troubled n dev was having gala tym ...
Neha wants everything in return of her childhood but she alwaz knew ranveer is a man of self reapect ..hd ll never take help frm dev ...but den she thot d way he accepted job he ll take other things also wich dint happen so dis conflict ...
I feel wenever v make any relation its d efforts frm both sides n wenever it is broken both have deir share of mistakes however less or more ...
Here also both ve done some mistakes ...n d simple solution to it is talk ...how much tym u need to b ready for talking ...
QUOTE=tia.o]
You know there's a saying that if you expect a fish to climb tree, then you will only end up being disappointed. Why would Neha expect Ranveer to happily live off Dev, I don't know. But she just paved her own way to disappointment. Ranveer always was very true to everyone. He is a middle class self-made man and that's how he presented himself. Neha on the other hand, did exactly what I said once in my post that sometimes women do. Some woman marry a man thinking them as DIY project. But if you are marrying someone expecting them to change, you are just doomed to disappointment.

Originally posted by: sona_naksh

Bang on post tia

I agree wid it
Neha can never be happy because she wants everything but doesnt want to earn it ...be it money love or respect
She wants dev to take care of her , take her tantrums over sona and give watever she asks for but doesnt want ranveer to take care of his family ...
I agree neha had a troubles childhood but it was not dev's fault as ishwari n neha present it to be ...he was given opportunity and he worked hard for it ...he worked day n night wid his mother to meet d ends ...it was nt like neha n ishwari vr troubled n dev was having gala tym ...
Neha wants everything in return of her childhood but she alwaz knew ranveer is a man of self reapect ..hd ll never take help frm dev ...but den she thot d way he accepted job he ll take other things also wich dint happen so dis conflict ...
I feel wenever v make any relation its d efforts frm both sides n wenever it is broken both have deir share of mistakes however less or more ...
Here also both ve done some mistakes ...n d simple solution to it is talk ...how much tym u need to b ready for talking ...

agree aid u
Frankly neha wanted a ghar jamai for her ...but she fell in love wid ranveer or at least she thot so ...may b she loved d fact dat rznveer loves her ...m nt sure ..but she definitely never loved ranveer ...
Neha thinks everything is rosy for sona ...but wat she fails to understand is evry rose has thorns too ..its up to u either u enjoy d feel of petals or d prick of thorns ...

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".