Can This Be A Perspective? Pls tell - Page 3

Created

Last reply

Replies

25

Views

1.3k

Users

11

Likes

59

Frequent Posters

dikshat thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 8 years ago
#21

Originally posted by: pkbdas61

what you have written is true for all mother - child relationships. This is not special for Ishwari or Dev. it is also true for ishwari - neha, riya, nikki as well as Asha - Sona, Saurabh.. This is the fundamental law of life. Likewise, the relationship between wife and husband is also fundamental and above the parent - child relationship. Now that Dev and Sona are married, they are ONE.. Dev needs to give his wife more priority than even his mother.

honestly, i am not able to understand Ishwari- Dev relationship at all now. It has gone beyond all my understanding where mom expects herself to be above even his wife.



Yes its true for all parents, thats why I wrote I wont term it as ehsaan.
But I wont say Wife Husband relationship is above parent child. Thats an issue I guess which leads to further issues. When you weigh one relationship more than the other, especially in these case where both the relationships are equally important and sensitive.
Each Relationship in our life has its own value and that cannot be compared to another. Many things that I can share with my Parents I can't with my partner. Likewise for other relationships.
Every relationship requires a different treatment but value shud remain the same.
Here Dev needs to prioritize things between both the ladies. Certain things Sona requires more priority and certain things/ days Ishu. Thats why we say Balance is required.

I can fully understand Dev Ishwari relationship for the reason that the writers have sketched their characters so well, have shown their background, their growth and consistency in their characters. Mayb thats the reason I never hated Ishu.

Mother is not expecting herself above wife, she is expecting herself to be the only one. Her level is above the first level for her.
Level one mayb Sona but Ishu doesnt fall under a level category.
dikshat thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 8 years ago
#22

Originally posted by: sia.krpkab


I am intrigued with your perspective, PKB!
Y do you feel Dev should give priority to Sona over Ishwari? Or even in generic terms, you hold such a thought that a husband should give priority to his wife over mother?
I would like you to elaborate more - never heard a man 's thoughts on this.

P.S. I personally agree with this thought. But my reason could be different from yours. So I will reserve my reason until I hear yours 😃


I shared mine above 😉😳
dikshat thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 8 years ago
#23

Originally posted by: sjain

So here I am back with my detailed view

Well what you have written like I said is the only reason for Dev to accept or even see Ish's faults or misdoings ..

But why its like that..The one and only reason for this is Ishwari has given her life for him ..she has done so much which he feel indebted to..she even compromised on her daughter's needs for him..because he was their only hope (according to ish) to come out of poverty..(lets not talk about male female equality here, becoz thats not important)...Dev has seen world from his mothr's eyes..during childhood every kid do so but once they grow up..they find thier own identity their own point of views..But even after growing up Dev did everything according to how Ish guided him, he saw what she showed him..for example She always reminded him of his responsibilities towards his sisters, towards working hard and succeeding..He couldn't form himself under the pressure of giving best lifestyle possible to his family..He is Dev -the son , Dev -the brother, Dev - the bread earner , Dev- the pilliar of strength responsibility..but he couldnt become Dev - A 28 year boy..He lost himself in this..He fulfilled dreams of Ish & his sisters but he couldn't dream for himself..Everyone could conveniently fall back in him..but he had no one to fall back on..He provided love happiness uncondinally to his family but he had no one to to provide all this to him..He always kept their needs demands first..but he had no one to keep his needs his wishes first..

Until one day Sonakshi entered his life..He stumbled in to a new space..Unknowingly he entered their..which he himself didnt know ever existed..Dev a young boy a 28 year old man a 8 year old kid was born that day.. HE was born..his dreams were born, his wishes were born..He saw a life for himself..just for him..Sonakshi just didnt bring LOVE in his life..she brought alot more then that..He was flying free..away from all the clutches aka Dixit ladies LOL

Now coming to seeing Ish's faults easily ..well I firstly wont use term GOD for Ish..I personally dont want to so yeah ..though I believe that parents r form of God for children on earth..but here I dont want to use it ..Dev didnt say anything (in his senses..though he said in drunk state) when he came to know she was the reason of separation..He didnt asked her for any explanations..so now when Sona will confront him about Ish's state Its gonna be one hel of a time for him..and coming in terms with it will be traumatic ..I am scared like shit

I feel I kinda deviated from the topic..but I was messed up while writing it dont know why thoughts were all muddled up -_- huh



@ Bold: Thats exactly...very very exactly my thought. Paisa kamane k chakkar mein he has not had an overall outlook towards things and life. He felt money can be the only issue in one's life, there cannot exist any other issue..That happened until he faced a heartbreak from where he got to know, money can still be earned and that is not just the only problem a person can face.
That was also one more reason he was clueless what is to done in such a situation or how to deal with this problem to win over it. He thought just like money can be earned, he will win Sona...soon to realize her love was not something to be won but earned.

Second para is very apt again...same thoughts. Sona gave him someone he needed for himself. And she was exactly wat he needed. Selfless love was required...which Sona gave him. He has big meaning behind that 'Haq' word he uses.

haha..no deviation from topic yaar...this topic is sooo huge...soo soo vast.,..u get so many thoughts wen u think abt it. Human emotions,...no one has ever been able to sum them up in a book with all views and perspectives..


dikshat thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 8 years ago
#24

Originally posted by: sia.krpkab


I feel you have gotten into the skin of Dev's character. Bravo Diksha! Your case above defines him as such a complicated character for me. And I can't understand how such people exist in real life (I am sure they do) but for me, it would be so difficult to overcome this psyche.

Thank you, thought provoking indeed. 😊


Thank you if you felt so. I really feel for each one of them and thats why I dont hate anyone of them...U know the more shit people are into..the more help they need. Ishu needs help more than hate and judgement by everyone.
He really is complicated. And yes such people exist ..very much they do.

Thank you for a lovely reply.
WeRockTheWorld thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 8 years ago
#25

Originally posted by: dikshat

Well just a random post...sometimes I fall into this "Analyse Life from different angle" mode of mine.

So today while going for work I just got this thought. Let me know if its really senseless or can be a sensible perspective. I find it an incomplete thought so I thought of asking here...😊

Dev tells Sona, Gift should not be valued in terms of its price ..Gift is priceless as it has emotions attached to it.
Sona tells him, take only that gift which you know you can give.

I agree with Dev on this . A gift is priceless . When given you dont expect anything back. Even I felt bad when the car was returned. When you attach a value to it or when you think of giving something back to that person because he /she gave you a gift then its returning a favour...it cant be a gift..., it looses the whole purpose of it. Only emotions are attached to gift

Now coming to Life..., Ishu is Dev's mom..His life according to him is a "gift" from his god who has sacrificed her happiness to make him what he is. And the same god has not asked him for anything in return (acc to him) just like no parent does.

His mother is his god , but we need to understand who made him think of her as god ?? She is the one who established that image of her in him. Indirectly ofcourse . Now as per his own theory his mom has gifted life to him ...which is priceless and should be accepted with all respect and love...but when he thinks of giving away everything that he loves in life for her because he wants to try his level best to keep her happy ...that is like returning a favour...He is doing that to his mom because she did something for him...

Now the question is would he have not done these for his mom , if he had a normal childhood??

A gift by his god which had all her emotions, feelings, no money value..a gift he cannot give back..which is now a Ehsaan (sorry for the word coz I feel parents never do a ehsaan to their kids) jo kuch bhi karo utara nahi ja sakta.

Do I blame him for not agreeing that his mother can ever be at fault..that too so easily??
No..



What I feel when you love a person...it doesnt matter what he or she has done for you , what matters is, what you can do for that person... And when someone so lovingly gifts you something out of affection dont look at the price tag..accept it wholeheartedly and feel blessed that you have ppl to give you gifts in life.
Hari73 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#26
It's a sensible issue... I just want to see how makers put this issue in coming episode. .
In reality and by nature when bird gets wings they fly away and make their own nest. Same way when couple get married and become solumate, they become one. So prioritising question does not arrive. Both has to do for each other, it will never called sacrifice. Whatever husband and wife they do for each other will never be seen in ehsaan or mahaan angle. So our elders generously make their way to ease life of couple. Husband and wife relation is above all the relation. I can call MY husband and husband says it's MY wife. This relation is completely private. But in other relation it is shared so we say our mother/ our brother. Parents still important in couple life. They will be helping, guiding and advising through out the life. Having elders at home is always blessing. If people understand this simple logic, there will never question arise who to prioritise..

I just hope..I made some sensible comment.



Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".