I think it is time for a test - Page 5

Created

Last reply

Replies

53

Views

3.5k

Users

26

Likes

156

Frequent Posters

bookworm123 thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#41

Originally posted by: Malvika07

THANK YOU for making this post!!

I NEEDED to make it for my own peace of mind.

This was exactly what came to my mind after yesterday's episode.. Ishwari didn't irritate me that much yesterday, I'm getting used to her behaviour now.. in fact, yesterday she was much more open to receiving the news, she didn't put up a cold front which she keeps doing freequently this days.. which is why, it was all the more frustrating to see Dev chickening out.

Yes, it is sad that we have stopped empathizing with her because her character which was possessive earlier as well but so credible and likable has suddenly turned into a star plus MIL sans the make up/ghoonghat/jewellery. If we do not empathize with her, how will we relate to the ML separating himself for FL for her??


The central conflict of the show is out in the open, but I didn't expect to find myself so unsympathetic towards Dev and Ishwari both.

Exactly. We were prepared for the show's premise but with the characters they gave us in the first 90 odd episodes.


The problem I've had with Dev right from the very first promo is his lack of ability to stand up for his love. His behaviour right now is a lot like guys we know, who promise you the stars and the moon but when it comes to acting on it, they chicken out. Raising the kushal roy point was bang on!! Kushal was supposed to be blatantly wrong for Sonakshi, it's a really bad sign that we find ourselves sympathising with that character

I really want Dev to realize Sonakshi's importance in his life, he needs to yearn for her,fight for her. And for that he needs to see beyond his mother for one minute without feeling so incredibly guilty. Like someone mentioned before, he can't see nirasha in his mother's eyes.. so every time there's a conflict in the house, he's gonna ask Sonakshi to shut up. Dev is the most lovable character when he's delivering romantic lines, it that's mostly Shaheer's charm. My lack of connect with Dev's character is ringing alarm bells in my head and making me wonder if I'll be rooting for this couple in the long run!


Absolutely! We want a conflicted but manly hero! The makers need to be careful about their depiction. It is at the end of the day primarily a love story and they have to show us the ups and downs while maintaining the dignity of all the characters. They may want a realistic touch but not one that puts off viewers looking for entertainment that does not upset them

I wanted Sonakshi to be upfront with Dev and tell him that she needs to tell her parents too. Dev is anyways least bothered about her family, at least Sonakshi needs to think about them instead of joining dev in worshipping Ishwari. We all know what Dev will do if ishwari refuses for their alliance,but I wonder if Sonakshi tells him that her parents aren't ready for their union and therefore they need to break up what would dev's reaction be? Possibly ' You can't do this to me'.
Right now, I just have one advice for Sonakshi.. run, girl!!



Completely fail to understand why they have made Sona such a doormat of late. Where is her life, family, career etc.? I feel for Sona because it appears that if they break up, she has nothing else. They need to maker her end of the story look richer...They also seem to have forgotten that from the begining Dev was very respectful of her family and very fond of them. Calling them mam/sir, gallantly offering to drop Elena home when they first met etc. What happened to that Dev??
bookworm123 thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#42
Dev needs to yearn for Sona. For this to happen first he need to understand her importance in his life. Now tell me how he will understand her importance in his life when she is there for him 24/7.
From the confession till today, everything was cake walk for Dev in this relationship. Obviously he took her for granted. I said some time back in soumya's post, we never know the value of what we have till we lose it.
Let him do more mistakes, let him choose his mother over Sona, Let Sona move out of his life and thats the time he will actually understand what is her importance in his life. It may looks like sadistic while saying but I am waiting to see him suffer for Sona and i am glad that story is moving forward from their koo chikoo moments.



An aspect of the show I loved the most was the respect given to the FL by everyone. For ex - Loved how Dev defended her, even to his mom and brought her back home. Another time both Ish and he tried to cajole her into accepting the phone. Sona may have realized her love and pined for him but it was who always reached out to her and gave her so much importance. She never acted overly interested in his relationship with Natasha in front of him but he was so transparent in case of Neil. he invited himself to her home to get to the bottom of the matter!

Do not know why they have abandoned that aspect of their storytelling of late. She seems so accessible to him. When they break up, I do not want her to be so accessible to him. That is like being a partner without the perks of being one!
bookworm123 thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#43

Originally posted by: pkbdas61

I think more than Kushal Roy, Neil Lakhotia will give Dev a run for his money. he is rich, very caring and also loves Sona.. She deserves a real chivalrous prince and not a pussy prince.



Agree!! Where is the Dev who was so chivalrous with her when mami insulted her in the dumb charades episode? The Dev who pointed out even to his mom that she treated Sona unfairly, who waited 5 hours to apologize and get her back? Who had a firm talk with mami about how she should be treated post her return to work?

More than Ishwari, i am livid with Dev. I speak as a man. I just cannot connect with his behaviour, no matter how close he is with his mom (Shaheer had a very difficult part to play yesterday and he did it brilliantly.. his lips too were literally quivering!), i cannot digest the fact that he is unable to talk to his mom. if he cannot do it now, will he do it after marriage? Can he talk about everything, except his own needs?

I think, if this continues, Dev should make the promise of marrying the girl the Ishwari wants, and move on in life. Sona too can move on and so can the audience. We have seen kuch rang pyar ke and it was a blessing.. However, something tells me that the makers may toe this line. they will make Dev actually promise to Ishwari ( due to one of the intial promos where Sona tells him - jab kissa khatam hone wala hai...) .They may then show how Sona will try to win Ishwari's heart. I hope this is not the line that they take. It will be too cliched.. it will then become a Saas-Bahu serial.





I think many of us are disturbed not because he delayed today. I t is understandable if it takes several attempts. What is upsetting is the characterization, it does not bode well for the future. In real life, it is tough to see a girl happy in such a set up
Edited by bookworm123 - 9 years ago
bookworm123 thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#44

Originally posted by: VIMAL.M



RS have written DABH for some time.I think he brought that idea.

I want to ask Sona.Sona darling you also have your own mom.What about her.Why think of ur new mom so much.Who will think about ur old mom.



Someone needs to ask her this.
ARCH21 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#45

Originally posted by: bookworm123



I am so glad I made this post because all the responses are improving my mood.

When I read the update and later saw the episode I felt quite upset. It is just a show but because it is somewhat realistic it does resonate with experiences in our lives. I had a very close friend who grew up with me. The guy had to back out because he would not oppose his mom even though he was crazy about my friend, my friend too could not fault his logic. However the mistake he made was to involve her so much emotionally. All of us close friends felt so bad for her and had to work so hard to collectively help her recover. So, anytime on the show, I get the sense that Sona will be devastated I feel very upset. I hope the makers focus on his pain this time since we have had Sona crying (very very well) in the run up to epi 76

No matter how complicated their relationship, quite frustrating to see Ish engage in chula drama instead of making attempts to get Dev to come clean...She was so frank in case of Natasha - "I may not be as imp for you" and Dev promptly assured her she would always reign

How can Dev say to her so casually - let us not tell anyone?. How can they disrespect her family like this? He just wants her to sneak around in his house and come to his room whenever he gets a moment's respite from work and ma? Sona also was quite annoying with her "ma" talks. She does not want up upset his ma, what about her family, dignity and feelings??


😃 Sorry! I was in a bad mood ... the realism in the show touches you - for good or bad... I had to vent & I vented here 😃

Sorry to hear about your friend. I am sure she is all better and doing very well with such good friends around her!

That's another point with the show - these guys just don't have any friends - not Dev, not Sona nor Ishwari. We need both - friends & family in life to keep our vision straight sometimes. Sometimes family is too close to the issue and that's when friends bring in that welcome outsider's perspective. Otherwise we would just be running around each other in a box...

The contrast between both families is time and again shown clearly.
The Bose family is open and care for each member of their family even if it is a cousin. They are one whole.
The Dixit family draws boundaries and defines who's who...

The Boses say things openly - even if they don't like something.
The Dixit family beats around the bush. Especially the closest 2 - Mom-Son

The Boses sense something amiss with a family member and instantly reach out, even when they are pushed back. Talk, share and console.
The Dixits sense something amiss, make assumptions in their head and run their thoughts at jet speed in many directions. Until someone brings up the courage to address the core issue, the issue has already become a crisis...

The Boses trust each other enough to say what's on their mind.
The Dixits carry a facade of being one unit but don't even recognize each other.

Sona - slowly and surely turning into a Dixit!!!!!
Not once in her thoughts or in her conversation with Dev does she bring up her family. Only 'Maa' ko bura nahi lagna chahiye...

As they say, the shortest distance between 2 points is a straight line ... All Ishwari had to do was touch her Son's hand and ask directly... 'do you like someone?' or maybe reach out to him the next morning and ask ... the Son so obviously had something important to share...

All she did ... all she does ... is turn the focus on herself.

We all know what's going to happen He wasn't going to tell yesterday but he will in this week. But many times the action is as important as how you go about it... and this is what I want to see...

There is always some drama going on around him. It was expected for him to be irritated the next morning after seeing his mother on the kitchen floor with the chula. His half-hearted answer to Sona about telling his mother could be explained that his mind was distracted with the kitchen drama...

His night phone conversation was in better senses and him saying, 'lets keep this hidden forever' was just like saying, its proving too difficult, can we just not do it... not that he meant it that way but just like sometimes we say 'oh too tough! lets not do it'... in the moment...
(Look at me trying to justify this... 😃)

I was just so angry with Ishwari and her self-centered vision, flashbacks & assumptions... It was funny! I hadn't had dinner and after looking at Ishwari & fuming at the drama... when my Mom asked me 'should I get you dinner?'... I was like, 'Please, I will get it myself'... 😆

Edited by ARCH21 - 9 years ago
_Payalj_ thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#46
Quoting what I wrote in another post on the same topic:
Dev Dixit is just the guy a woman should never fall in love with or marry. They say that one should never marry a guy who hates his mother or one who is totally tied to his mother's apron strings. Dev in addition to being a Mommy's boy also comes with tremendous emotional baggage. In fact for any woman he is bad news with a Capital B.


all said and done Sona has done the stupidity of falling for this man. Maybe she fell in love with his apparent goodness and kindness to his family without once giving a thought to how difficult it would be to live on a daily basis with him and his family . Compromising your self respect for a few days is OK but it can't be done on a perpetual basis.

sona has further allowed him to take her for granted by quietly taking his Mamis insults. Fine his Mama helped them a lot but is he going to allow GKB a free rein because of that? Would he have kept quite if that foul woman was insulting his mother? Glaring once is just not enough. He should have spelt it in black and white but then again his mother's emotions come before sonas self respect.

I think Sona should either ask Dev to pull up his socks or run away as far as possible from this mother son duo. Marriage is not a week long affair that adjustments to this level can be made. It is not easy to live everyday Compromising or sacrificing your sense of self.
WeRockTheWorld thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 9 years ago
#47
Ladiess I am so disappointed the way Sonakshi's Character has been diluted to zero self respect . Its so painful and absolutely humiliating to see such a strong character is thrown to the drain just to make her look like a typical Indian DIL for TRP.
She needs to get a life!! He doesnt deserve her at all. He is taking her for granted and she is being treated like a doormat ( Hate to use that term for anybody ...but situation calls for it😡 ) This is so unfair.

She has no regard for her mother ...not bothered abt her family. I mean when Dev is not bothered to tell his family why should she force him to do so. Isnt it evident that he is not sure of her . If he was sure of her then he will be confident of convincing his mom. He did that when he broke engagement with Natasha. Infact he didnt tell any one or take anyones permission...so this clearly shows he is not sure of this relationship at all. And Sonakshi understands this ...why cling on to someone , when they are not sure if they want you in their life or not. She needs to pull away...and give space.

Really pathetic!! Sorry if I hurt all the Dev fans , but I dont think he is being fair with her.
fanktlk thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#48

Originally posted by: bookworm123



Completely fail to understand why they have made Sona such a doormat of late. Where is her life, family, career etc.? I feel for Sona because it appears that if they break up, she has nothing else. They need to maker her end of the story look richer...They also seem to have forgotten that from the begining Dev was very respectful of her family and very fond of them. Calling them mam/sir, gallantly offering to drop Elena home when they first met etc. What happened to that Dev??


I saw this missing even during the Puja.. Elina was on her way out.. I though they would show some acknowledgement between Dev or Elina.. or that he will volunteer the driver to drop her... or just say hi or bye as she leaves.. otherwise there was no need for Elina to be there other than Vicky.. They have certainly forgotten that Dev.
WeRockTheWorld thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 9 years ago
#49

Originally posted by: fanktlk


I saw this missing even during the Puja.. Elina was on her way out.. I though they would show some acknowledgement between Dev or Elina.. or that he will volunteer the driver to drop her... or just say hi or bye as she leaves.. otherwise there was no need for Elina to be there other than Vicky.. They have certainly forgotten that Dev.

Did they change the CV team or have they lost the entire concept in the fight for TRP 😕
pkbdas61 thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#50

Originally posted by: WeRockTheWorld

Ladiess I am so disappointed the way Sonakshi's Character has been diluted to zero self respect . Its so painful and absolutely humiliating to see such a strong character is thrown to the drain just to make her look like a typical Indian DIL for TRP.

She needs to get a life!! He doesnt deserve her at all. He is taking her for granted and she is being treated like a doormat ( Hate to use that term for anybody ...but situation calls for it😡 ) This is so unfair.

She has no regard for her mother ...not bothered abt her family. I mean when Dev is not bothered to tell his family why should she force him to do so. Isnt it evident that he is not sure of her . If he was sure of her then he will be confident of convincing his mom. He did that when he broke engagement with Natasha. Infact he didnt tell any one or take anyones permission...so this clearly shows he is not sure of this relationship at all. And Sonakshi understands this ...why cling on to someone , when they are not sure if they want you in their life or not. She needs to pull away...and give space.

Really pathetic!! Sorry if I hurt all the Dev fans , but I dont think he is being fair with her.



Yes, exactly.. he was capable of taking his own decisions then. what has changed that he cannot take his decision now? Even that time, his mom told him that she is not going to influence him by her decisions and the final decision should be entirely his. Now what has changed?

only Dev Babu knows what is going on in his mind. But from his behaviour it looks like he is living in denial. He has suspected that his mom will reject Ishwari and is scared of this and is scared of telling Sona too. One cannot live in denial for too long without facing the consequences. The immediate one is Sona's suspicion that he is not sure about his relationship with her.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".