Originally posted by: bookworm123
Thanks for making this post. My sentiments exactly.
Some additional thoughts--
The Ishwari/Sona conversation was quite ok except that I liked Sona's earlier more practical style of conversing with her. I used to like how earlier Ishwari would open up and Sona would listen and speak less. In fact that was her styel earlier. I suppose she converses with greater familiarity now because she feels closer to Dev's family.
About the scene with RR - less said the better. Lazy writing by creatives. There are better ways to show interactions with a difficult family member with whom confrontation is difficult but need to be handled with tact..
Sona/Dev scene - I suppose the creatives wanted to bring in the aspect of Sona being there for Dev for not just his emotional/family related issues but even to help him feel better after a hard day's work. Again here I fell the writing could have been more subtle. It is not necessary for her to alleviate his day's stress by providing an opinion on his work related situation, not very credible.
Visually the episodes do not paint a picture of an educated, sensible, hard working professional girl which was expected to be one of the differentiating factors of this show.
I like your summary of yesterday's episode, made me feel better:). However, to a new viewer unfamiliar with the story till date, this is how the episode comes across -
- girl comes to future MIL and listens to her issues
- girl cooking lunch for her employers
- girl acts foolish when she receives a phone call as though it is a rare occurrence
- girl has nothing to say (not even a light hearted sarcastic comment) when faced with a crass RR
- girl waits for bf, sends him to his room in his own house and offers refreshments in his own house
- super girl cures him of his headache and swiftly makes him feel better about a complex business decision that was written about in the media
- super girl is not done. since she has no life of her own these days or anything to share about her own life, she proceeds to try and fix yet another knotty problem faced by the hapless Dixits
I was just reflecting that in real life relationships, it is actually the woman who shares more about her day and life and seeks opinions/reassurances. The situation here is so reversed that she has no emotional needs from this relationship. I think the creatives need to put on their creative caps to restore depth to her character...
I agree that this is still a daily soap and very tough to check all the boxes. The show has been so good in so many ways that expectations are more :) in fact I would not bother to critique the kind of junk we have on Indian TV at the moment but this show has been so wonderful that it is tough to hold back and not have expectations.