Episode 10 - Discussions - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

22

Views

4.5k

Users

16

Likes

4

Frequent Posters

CarulinaTina thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 18 years ago
#11

Originally posted by: sareeta

Thank you so much Naina, sweet of you to say so! Yeah, I felt too that the things Jaya Ji said were at times quite misinterpreted and at times, quite drastically at that! And yeah I did feel that Abhi's talk to his mum was well... a lil over the top... Karan didnt have to display his affections for the Bacchans so obviously.. a lil segement for Hema ji as well would have made it appropriate....Hmm.. jus my thoughts

I totally and 10000% agree with you there. I thought that karan was displaying the bachans a little too much, with Abhi talk to his mum. There should have been a segment for Hema as well. The entire show was focussed solely on the Bachans. I am so dissappointed with this episode

CarulinaTina thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 18 years ago
#12

Originally posted by: aisha1

thanks😳lol

anyways i love this episode

hey karan didn't question about hritik ash kissing missing , yaar karan , jaya ko puchna tha na ki mrs right abishek bachan (why not left) ko kiya huwa , abushek ko no kiss hritik ko kiss mmm sasumahi apni bahu paar nazar rakho

exactly!!! there were so many questions that could have been asked to Jaya abaout Ash that could have been challenging for her to answer, but she was given custom-made questions instead, with obvious answers.

Edited by mamis - 18 years ago
loveanime thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 18 years ago
#13

Originally posted by: Fashion_2005

Celebrity guests this week are Mother-Daughter Combination Jaya Bachan and Daughter Shweta Nanda, Hema Malini and Esha Deol

Did you find episode entertaining and did you liked the episode? Did it lived with your expectation or you are disappointed?

I felt the questions were not incredibly tough or controversial. It looked like a fun chat with some friends, not overly exerting. That I think took away some zing, but I didnt expect that anything else ayways. 😃

Since it two beautiful and talented actresses, did they had grace in there presentation of talking?Or you think by age they have changed?

Hema Malini I think has always known to be too reserved. Jaya and Hema are both forthright with their comments. But you can clearly sense that Jaya Bachan is strict and she is a lady who has a set of principles and rules that have to be followed, and Hema is much more easy going. 😃

Did Jaya or Hema Surprised, shocked or disappointed you by their behaviour or comments?

Something I noticed that was interesting was when Jaya gave marital advice to her son, like he better not stray or do something wrong otherwise the tables will turn. Something like that, I thought Ash is lucky about the fact that if Abhi was to stray I think she can definitely count on Jaya support. I think Jaya herself would kill her son. 😆

Did you wished to see Dharamenda with Hema?

I think that would have been awkward, to the world she is still his second wife. And that is still a touchy issue. 😕

Do you think Jaya Bachan is kind of a person who differences their daughter and son in a high scale.

As a mother I am sure she loves both her children equally. But you know I think she expects more from her daughter Sweta, only because she is married and expects her to handle everything. Abhishek I think is still a baby. 😳

Suddenly Jaya Bachan is behaving as she always had loved Ash, we all know she didn't like Ash from the begining but now Jaya is giving some comments,I didn't wrote exact words but share your views:

I think Ash is the right Mrs. Abhishek Bachan-You views

Ok here is the thing she cant say anything different. I think KJ and the rest of the world are idiots if they expect her to say anything different. But no one can predict the future, and it is kind of juvenille to ask her if she is the right one, considering that this isnt an arranged marraige. 😃

Ash walks behind me and stays quiet. Your Views

Like I mentioned before Jaya is a lady who follows certain rules and principles in her life. It came across in her acting where I always felt she never did one scene where it made you raise your eyebrows. She is strict and has certain expectations. I think Ash knows that, she also knows Jaya temper so I am sure she wouldnt want to cross any line. 😆

I feel bad Shweta isn't a bachan now, and she is out so Ash will complete the feeling- Your Views

I think no matter what everyone says DIL can never completely and totally be a daughter, that only happens in soaps. You can love your DIL. Jaya keeps saying she loooooooooooooves Ash, but I think there is an certain amount of exaggeration there because that kind of love I think takes years of trust of build. You love your daughter naturally, but a love for your DIL has to be developed. The disadvantage is that they dont have a free pass on mistakes made. There is not the same tolerance level. Sweta can make mistakes but her parents will forgieve, but if Ash were to do something seriously wrong I am sure Jaya will take out the knives.😡

Between Jaya and Hema, did you find and uncomfortable feeling or insecure, since Amitabh and Hema did won the jodi of year in Baghban. There were rumours how Jaya felt jealous of Amitabh-Hema jodi.

Oh I sense none of that. I felt they have great respect for each other.👏

Between Shweta and Esha, who are more mature?

Obviously Shewta you think since she is married and has two kids, a husband and a household to manage. Shewta definitely more life experience, but Esha was very sweet. 😳

Do you think if Shweta would had joined, she would had able to make it big or you beleive Amitabh and Jaya would never had let that happened.

I dont think she has the glamor or necessarily that look to make it big. But she is well settled so I dont think she has any regrets. 😃

On the Rapidfire, was Karan being unfair since he is very close to Bachans, Did the right person won or someone else should had won?

I guess a tie was natural. What difference does it make who wins, is the Koffee hamper that precious that if the other group won, other one would have been jealous. It is petty if they thought that, and I am sure they are beyond such silly games. 😆

Do you think Karan should had asked more question regarding Abhishek-Ash and rekha?😆

Definitely Rekha is out of bounds, we all know what happened there. So I think it is childish from our parts to even consider that KJ would ask such a ridiculous question. But about Abhi-Ash he asked all he could ask, she cant give much different answers anyways, and I am sure she wishes her son's married life the best. 👏

Did you liked the Guests Combination or you think it was the Perfect Combination?

I think it was a lovely family combination. I thorougly enjoyed watching their interactions. 👏

On the dress scale- Who was looking the best? Some members here said Jaya wasn't looking good from the promos😕

Hema and Esha definitely took the cake on galmor. 😳But we have to keep in mind that Jaya is not feeling well, but she could have looked better. Sweta looked fine, nothing like wow, she dressed her age.😃

At the end of the Episode, whom Combination did you like? Jaya-Shweta or Hema-Esha

I think both these pairings revealed something. Jaya-Sweta fight more, Jaya strict mother, definitely more tensions. Hema and Esha came off as friends. I liked seeing both because they revealed different personalities. 👏

Overall, rate the episode.

8/10👏

Please Add Questions if you had any

😊Please don't forget to vote.

Chaska Meter:

https://www.indiaforums.com/forum/koffee-with-karan/594430/chaska-meter-episode-10

16573 thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#14

Celebrity guests this week are Mother-Daughter Combination Jaya Bachan and Daughter Shweta Nanda, Hema Malini and Esha Deol

Did you find episode entertaining and did you liked the episode? Did it lived with your expectation or you are disappointed?

It was okay-okay... itna acchaa nahin tha... it seemed like Jaya Bachchan;s first global public appearence to glorify "Ash is my bahu and the Bachchans rule" statement that has already been blown apart by the Indian media... Hema ji on the other hand was a bit more dignified,less opinionated etc..but she kept on turning to Esha a lot more... actually that isn't bad, its quite nice to see mother-daughter interact like that... but Shweta was v. insecure according to me. What was the need to go on about 'Mama i'm so dissappointed in you for saying Abhishek could have handled a crisis better...

Since it two beautiful and talented actresses, did they had grace in there presentation of talking?Or you think by age they have changed?

Jaya Bachchan reinforced my opinion of a strict disciplanarian - she has this v. tight hold over her family and wanted to get involved in politics and she is a very dominating, forceful person - a person one doesn;t always get along with.

Hema ji was quite submersive and I actually liked how she was quiet and she came across as a more - shall I say - interesting persona. According to me, JB had an attitude like 'I'm Mrs Bachchan, I am the patriarch of my family, I will stop Ash from acting after marriage' etc attitude. But Hemaji wasn't like that, which I liked to see.

Did Jaya or Hema Surprised, shocked or disappointed you by their behaviour or comments?

No not really... KJo didn't ask any challenging Qs to Jayaji and neither to Hemaji... but it was obvious KJo was delighted to have Jaya as he kept on calling her 'Auntyji' and Hema Malini as 'Hemaji'... I mean agar respect dikhana hai tho dono ko dhikao! Ek ko dikhakar favourites kyon khel rahe ho!

Did you wished to see Dharamenda with Hema?

No not really... I wasnt interested in Dharamendra as I've haven't seen Sholay (dont hav the patience to sit through it either *yawn*) But I still think Hemaji should have been questioned like - "How did you feel after society pointed you as the 'dirty other woman'"? etc

Do you think Jaya Bachan is kind of a person who differences their daughter and son in a high scale.

No I noticed that JB has brought up Shweta and Abhishek similarly except Shweta didnt want to get into films, a decision I believe was mututal on both Shweta and AB and JBs' sides. Abhishek is more in the limelight; otherwise there seems no apparent difference in their bringing up

Suddenly Jaya Bachan is behaving as she always had loved Ash, we all know she didn't like Ash from the begining but now Jaya is giving some comments,I didn't wrote exact words but share your views:

I think Ash is the right Mrs. Abhishek Bachan-You views

BullS**t. This sounds like Amitabh Bachchan and not Jaya Bachchan. Its so obvious she doesn't want an opinionated woman like Ash, who was had many famous break ups as her bahu. But then again my respect for her fell after I heard that she made AB Jr break up with Rani as Rani was not from too high-class a family in Kolkata [as Jaya Bhachan Bhaduri is Bengali, I sense that[.

Ash walks behind me and stays quiet. Your Views

LOL... did she say thaT? well then It contradicts my previous answer!

I feel bad Shweta isn't a bachan now, and she is out so Ash will
complete the feeling- Your Views

She said this on the show. Again it seems like AB Sr said it and not Jaya Bachchan...

Between Jaya and Hema, did you find and uncomfortable feeling or insecure, since Amitabh and Hema did won the jodi of year in Baghban. There were rumours how Jaya felt jealous of Amitabh-Hema jodi.

No not really ... both were cordial but not like huggy-buggy types who are all HAPPY to be on KwK...And plus Jaya ji called Dharam a 'Greek God'... I think it balances out...

Between Shweta and Esha, who are more mature?

Esha. Defintely. Shweta seemed Very Immature to me, thank God she didn'ty join films as she seemed like those actressses like Mallika who like to go on and on...Esha seemed balanced and quiet where required ... and she seemed submersive also... but I;ve heard she's v. fun loving etc..

Do you think if Shweta would had joined, she would had able to make it big or you beleive Amitabh and Jaya would never had let that happened.

I wish she hadnt joined anyway... I dont feel she would have been stopped By AbSr or JB anyway... She just didnt' want to...

On the Rapidfire, was Karan being unfair since he is very close to Bachans, Did the right person won or someone else should had won?

I can't tell about the RapidFire, as JB, I felt, was much better than Hema. But that "compatibility" quiz proved that Esha was better than Shweta [understandly so; I mean Esha and Hema like together !]. But the last segemnt just proved he was so after the Big Bachchans (after all, they came in his last - two -directed filsm - JB and ABsr in K3G and ABSr and Jr in KANK; KJo needs to maintain some status with them!!!)

Do you think Karan should had asked more question regarding Abhishek-Ash and rekha?😆

JB just regurgitated ABSr views on the Abhi-Ash wedding... didnt seem like her own views...and well KJo can't ask abt Rekha but i would have lurrrvvvved to see JBs reaction. But I bet she had prepared for answering a Qs on Rekha, as she had so obviously done her HW on how to Answers Qs on Abhi-Ash.

Did you liked the Guests Combination or you think it was the Perfect Combination?

It was likeable certainly... not perfect accoridng to me...

On the dress scale- Who was looking the best? Some members here said Jaya wasn't looking good from the promos😕

Hemaji was definelty looking best... Jaya was okay-okay... Esha looked nice... Shweta seemed awkward and tall in a saree...

At the end of the Episode, whom Combination did you like?

Esha and Hemaji.... Shweta was not mature and JB too dominating...

Overall, rate the episode.
teek-thaak... 7 or 8 on 10...


Please Add Questions if you had any

  1. Why not provide a similar segment for Hema ji where the other daugher (forgot name) said something abt Hema... seemed too obvious that Kjo doesnt want to insult the bachchans...
  2. Eesha personal life wasn't questioned (as in who is she dating etc)... not fair to other contemporaries who have been pestered to name Boyfriends...
  3. Why Shweta is soo immature... didn't seem Bachchan quality to her..
  4. Why JB was giving ABSr commments on Ash-Abhi... were her own comments too acerbic to be commented on?
  5. I guess thats all...Accha... why does Shweta have an american accent?? She sounded like Sanjay Dutt's daughter (Trishala).

😊Please don't forget to vote.

Chaska Meter:

https://www.indiaforums.com/forum/koffee-with-karan/594430/chaska-meter-episode-10


Thanks ... bye for now!!!
Edited by Rohit.Khanna - 18 years ago
~*!Ripi!*~ thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#15

seems like you Really hate the Bachchans

CarulinaTina thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 18 years ago
#16

Originally posted by: CRAZIE

seems like you Really hate the Bachchans

No, I don't hate the Bachchans at all.😊 I just thought it was really really unfair for Karan to give them so much importance, and I thought Jaya was arroagant at times. Just my views...

tashu92 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#17

Originally posted by: Fashion_2005

Celebrity guests this week are Mother-Daughter Combination Jaya Bachan and Daughter Shweta Nanda, Hema Malini and Esha Deol

Did you find episode entertaining and did you liked the episode? Did it lived with your expectation or you are disappointed?

It was entertaining and lived up to my expectations.

Since it two beautiful and talented actresses, did they had grace in there presentation of talking?Or you think by age they have changed?

I love both of them and they were lovely.

Did Jaya or Hema Surprised, shocked or disappointed you by their behaviour or comments?

No.

Did you wished to see Dharamenda with Hema?

Yes it would have been interesting.

Do you think Jaya Bachan is kind of a person who differences their daughter and son in a high scale.

Dont think so.

Suddenly Jaya Bachan is behaving as she always had loved Ash, we all know she didn't like Ash from the begining but now Jaya is giving some comments,I didn't wrote exact words but share your views:

I think Ash is the right Mrs. Abhishek Bachan-You views: Ash is Abhishek's choice and they have apporved her so now she has to to say this.

Ash walks behind me and stays quiet. Your Views:Ash learning and doing everything according to them.It shows that Jaya is very demanding.

I feel bad Shweta isn't a bachan now, and she is out so Ash will complete the feeling- Your Views:That was a bit too much cuz no matter wat happens there will always be a difference between the daughter and daughter-in-law.The love for the daughter will always remain more.(for every parent).

Between Jaya and Hema, did you find and uncomfortable feeling or insecure, since Amitabh and Hema did won the jodi of year in Baghban. There were rumours how Jaya felt jealous of Amitabh-Hema jodi.

I dont think so, Jaya isn't like that.Both respect eachother.

Between Shweta and Esha, who are more mature?

Shweta maybe cuz she's older aswell.

Do you think if Shweta would had joined, she would had able to make it big or you beleive Amitabh and Jaya would never had let that happend

Cant say,she never joined.

On the Rapidfire, was Karan being unfair since he is very close to Bachans, Did the right person won or someone else should had won?

It was a tie,How can he be unfair?

Do you think Karan should had asked more question regarding Abhishek-Ash and rekha?😆

No.Rekha was in the past and ofcourse the Bachchan's dont like disscussing about her.

Did you liked the Guests Combination or you think it was the Perfect Combination?

It was a good combination.

On the dress scale- Who was looking the best? Some members here said Jaya wasn't looking good from the promos😕

Jaya was looking good.Hema was looking the best and Esha was looking very pretty,much much better than the last season.

At the end of the Episode, whom Combination did you like? Jaya-Shweta or Hema-Esha

Jaya-Shweta.

Overall, rate the episode.

7/10.

Please Add Questions if you had any

😊Please don't forget to vote.

Chaska Meter:

https://www.indiaforums.com/forum/koffee-with-karan/594430/chaska-meter-episode-10

Edited by amasin girl - 18 years ago
farishta fakhri thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#18
please I want to watch shahrukh khan and his wife and hrithik roshan and his wife please and thank you!
if u put it for me... thanks
193980 thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#19

Originally posted by: Fashion_2005

Did you find episode entertaining and did you liked the episode? Did it lived with your expectation or you are disappointed?

It was good. KJo could have showed some others from the industry commenting on Hema and Jaya.

Since it two beautiful and talented actresses, did they had grace in there presentation of talking?Or you think by age they have changed?

Both actors always keep their dignity and grace. Never fails. I have seen the same in many actors of 70s-80s.

Did Jaya or Hema Surprised, shocked or disappointed you by their behaviour or comments?

No. They didn't. I felt Hema looked a bit gloomy and I was wondering because last year or so she once mentioned that she thinks Abhishek is a suitable husband material for Esha. So am not sure if she was disappointed in the wake of Abhi-Ash marriage.

Did you wished to see Dharamenda with Hema?

I wish. But I know it won't happen. Dharmendra has always maintained that they won't make any public appearances. Hema has mentioned several times that she always wished for a better life but she didn't get it. Poor thing! That's why she wants a LOVING husband for Esha.

Do you think Jaya Bachan is kind of a person who differences their daughter and son in a high scale.

Oh No. It is a fact that mothers have more affection for sons and daughters are Papa's favourite. It doesn't mean that they treat them differently. I love seeing those little tidbits between Shweta and Jaya. They were just like my mom and me.😊 A normal mother and daughter.

Suddenly Jaya Bachan is behaving as she always had loved Ash, we all know she didn't like Ash from the begining but now Jaya is giving some comments,I didn't wrote exact words but share your views:

I never read that she hated Ash. I always read and found that she liked this alliance.

I think Ash is the right Mrs. Abhishek Bachan-You views

Good. Made for each other.

Ash walks behind me and stays quiet. Your Views

I thought that was a bit out of line. May be Jaya got too carried away.

I feel bad Shweta isn't a bachan now, and she is out so Ash will complete the feeling- Your Views

It means she is missing her daughter so much that she years for one in the house with her.

Between Jaya and Hema, did you find and uncomfortable feeling or insecure, since Amitabh and Hema did won the jodi of year in Baghban. There were rumours how Jaya felt jealous of Amitabh-Hema jodi.

Actually NO. I read that Jaya commented watching Baghban that Hema suit Amitji to the T. On the contrary it was Dharmendra who told Hema that he won't watch the film because he doesn't like Hema sharing great chemistry with any other actor. I think Hema wanted Esha to marry Abhishek and get into a good family unlike her who didn't get any acceptance in Dharmendra's family. Never got any love from inlaws. Always lonely! Too bad Abhishek considered Esha his kid sister.

Between Shweta and Esha, who are more mature?

That is not a valid question because Shweta is married and a mother and Esha is still young. I thought both looked mature and dignified.

Do you think if Shweta would had joined, she would had able to make it big or you beleive Amitabh and Jaya would never had let that happened.

Shweta doesn't have the charm of becoming an actor, I guess. I don't think Bachchans stopped her. They seems to share good family bonding.

On the Rapidfire, was Karan being unfair since he is very close to Bachans, Did the right person won or someone else should had won?

Yes. Both were good.

Do you think Karan should had asked more question regarding Abhishek-Ash and rekha?😆

NO. That is too personal. He didn't ask abotu Dharmendra too because he knows that it is still a controversial thing for Hemamalini. Recently when Farah Khan wanted Dharmendra and Hema to dance together, he didn't agree because Bobby Deol was dancing with him so it would ahve looked awkward.

Did you liked the Guests Combination or you think it was the Perfect Combination?

It was a good combination.

On the dress scale- Who was looking the best? Some members here said Jaya wasn't looking good from the promos😕

I thought Shweta looked very good. I liked the way she spoke.

At the end of the Episode, whom Combination did you like? Jaya-Shweta or Hema-Esha

Both

Overall, rate the episode.

9/10

Tani91 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 18 years ago
#20

Did you find episode entertaining and did you liked the episode? Did it lived with your expectation or you are disappointed?

I thought it was awesome...very nicely siad and done...It did live to my expectation

Since it two beautiful and talented actresses, did they had grace in there presentation of talking?Or you think by age they have changed?

I think they were very beautiful inside and outside

Did Jaya or Hema Surprised, shocked or disappointed you by their behaviour or comments?

I thought they were ok...but I was a bit sad that maybe Jaya didnt mean that she liked Aish

Did you wished to see Dharamenda with Hema?

yes..I want to see their chemistry in real life

Do you think Jaya Bachan is kind of a person who differences their daughter and son in a high scale.

I think she likes Abhi better...dont know why...but I thought she does

Suddenly Jaya Bachan is behaving as she always had loved Ash, we all know she didn't like Ash from the begining but now Jaya is giving some comments,I didn't wrote exact words but share your views:

I think Ash is the right Mrs. Abhishek Bachan- I think she was acting totally acting when she said that

Ash walks behind me and stays quiet. Maybe she does😆 and mabe she's training to be quiet😆

I feel bad Shweta isn't a bachan now, and she is out so Ash will complete the feeling- I think she did mean this...because she did seem like she was saying the truth

Between Jaya and Hema, did you find and uncomfortable feeling or insecure, since Amitabh and Hema did won the jodi of year in Baghban. There were rumours how Jaya felt jealous of Amitabh-Hema jodi. No I don't think there was uncomfortableness....but I think Jaya was getting back by syaind Dharmendra was a "greek god"

Between Shweta and Esha, who are more mature? Sweta

Do you think if Shweta would had joined, she would had able to make it big or you beleive Amitabh and Jaya would never had let that happened. I think Sweta would have been a nice actress she has the face and the looks and the attitude...maybe she might have done well

On the Rapidfire, was Karan being unfair since he is very close to Bachans, Did the right person won or someone else should had won? I thought both were equal...😉

Do you think Karan should had asked more question regarding Abhishek-Ash and rekha?😆 Yeah

Did you liked the Guests Combination or you think it was the Perfect Combination? I thought it was perfect....😊

On the dress scale- Who was looking the best? Some members here said Jaya wasn't looking good from the promos😕

Hema and Sweta were looking the best

At the end of the Episode, whom Combination did you like? Jaya-Shweta or Hema-Esha
Jaya-Sweta

Overall, rate the episode.10/10

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".