Did Jai save Mahi?? - Page 2

Originally posted by: alka2212

Jai 's decision was fair enough...its not easy to point out your own flaws he could have easily taken raghav's name to save himself as he too didn't complete the game changer task and no one could have done anything as he was the captain and was asked to choose...I think tashisha would never have taken her name if she was in his place(my POV)..he was just being a fair captain and on the other hand multi was a big let down in both the water tasks when she claims to be such an awesome swimmer...though she is one of the strongest contestant she has done nothing good for her team..not even completed her task which mahi did..so I think it was fair in choosing mukti..

Yes it must hv been difficult to choose oneself for eliminations bt wrt Tanisha, if it comes onto her to take such decision she shud not name herself as she has done well in her stunts in dese two weeks..Jai dint add anything as a player,he was passing comments after d performances n some of his decisions were questionable..so his name was pretty obvious n kudos to him for accepting it..bt if Tanisha gets into a similar situation, taking her name ll not b fair, den why to expect her to take her name

Originally posted by: Rinki_r4

Yes it must hv been difficult to choose oneself for eliminations bt wrt Tanisha, if it comes onto her to take such decision she shud not name herself as she has done well in her stunts in dese two weeks..Jai dint add anything as a player,he was passing comments after d performances n some of his decisions were questionable..so his name was pretty obvious n kudos to him for accepting it..bt if Tanisha gets into a similar situation, taking her name ll not b fair, den why to expect her to take her name

^Yeah might b..bt I think instead of thinking emotionally if he had thought strategically dat wud hv been better..N when I say strategically, it means choosing 2 weak contestants which included Mahi too

Originally posted by: alka2212

Jai 's decision was fair enough...its not easy to point out your own flaws he could have easily taken raghav's name to save himself as he too didn't complete the game changer task and no one could have done anything as he was the captain and was asked to choose...I think tashisha would never have taken her name if she was in his place(my POV)..he was just being a fair captain and on the other hand multi was a big let down in both the water tasks when she claims to be such an awesome swimmer...though she is one of the strongest contestant she has done nothing good for her team..not even completed her task which mahi did..so I think it was fair in choosing mukti..

u said it all.

The basis of Jai's judgement was totally on the performances of that week itself. Hw can he nominate someone who has completed the task over someone who despite being a gr8 swimmer and performer could not even complete a single task.
More than being confident and fearless a lot of factors work wen u r performing. And luck is definitely one of it. Mukti's luck in future and Mahi's luck in future we can't predict.
But we look at the way they are performing Mahi comes across as better performer right now bcoz mahi got to do stunts which were really difficult for her and mukti got to do those stunts which are her usp.

Originally posted by: snehaHCAPK

u said it all.

The basis of Jai's judgement was totally on the performances of that week itself. Hw can he nominate someone who has completed the task over someone who despite being a gr8 swimmer and performer could not even complete a single task.
More than being confident and fearless a lot of factors work wen u r performing. And luck is definitely one of it. Mukti's luck in future and Mahi's luck in future we can't predict.
But we look at the way they are performing Mahi comes across as better performer right now bcoz mahi got to do stunts which were really difficult for her and mukti got to do those stunts which are her usp.

In dat way Tanisha's decision last week to choose himanshu over sid for eliminations was correct too...he cudnt gather pts fr d team bt she was bashed left right n center here..n jai was called an intelligent captain to hv saved Tina..She shudnt hv been called a weak link

Originally posted by: Rinki_r4

In dat way Tanisha's decision last week to choose himanshu over sid for eliminations was correct too...he cudnt gather pts fr d team bt she was bashed left right n center here..n jai was called an intelligent captain to hv saved Tina..She shudnt hv been called a weak link

Himanshoo's case was different bcoz Himanshoo couldn't perform any single stunt individually. In both the stunts he got to perform with a team. And those stunts were not himanshoo's forte. But swimming is Mukti's thing. Any ways Tanisha was blamed bcoz she chose both gud performs and Jai didn't do it. He had tested Mukti twice and she failed. It was fair enough according to me.

Originally posted by: Rinki_r4

Yes mukti is a strong contestant but what if she wud hv gotten eliminated? How bad, giving her a reality check, wud hv costed d team? She did a mistake in d first stunt bt during jai-mahi stunt when Mahi took out her goggles she was d one warning her abt it..so she is now extra cautious abt dese things..she wasn't casual abt her stunts n nobody is and had been dis while bt what r d future prospects of d team must hv been taken into consideration..It was like Sachin got out on a zero in a match n some random player scored a 10 which isn't gud bt more dan a zero thus Sachin shud b dropped from d team 😆

Originally posted by: snehaHCAPK

Himanshoo's case was different bcoz Himanshoo couldn't perform any single stunt individually. In both the stunts he got to perform with a team. And those stunts were not himanshoo's forte. But swimming is Mukti's thing. Any ways Tanisha was blamed bcoz she chose both gud performs and Jai didn't do it. He had tested Mukti twice and she failed. It was fair enough according to me.

Again how cud one assume who was gud n who wasn't without even seeing any stunt at dat tym? Vivan n sid hadn't performed any task (ofcourse I m nt taking game changer into consideration) Himanshu cudnt perform well bcz d first one too was a team task...So how was tanisha wrong when she made dat decision??.. n in mukti's case too d other one was a team task..she needed some time to
lift d dummy up..lifting it had nothing to do wid swimming..I felt it wud hv been really difficult for a girl to lift it..d first one was a blunder..she cudnt do it for d obvious reason...ofcourse v can safely assume she isn't going to repeat dis again..it was not an intelligent decision on jai's part to hv selected himself n mukti..One of d two shud hv been Mahi..had d team lost Mahi, it wud hv costed d least to d team dan loosing anyone else

Originally posted by: NAUCholic

Since KKK 7 started, mukti has done 2 stunts- and she threw away the first stunt. And 2nd mein bhi kuch khaas nahi kar paayi. So Sachin wali toh koi baat hi nahi hai😆It is like calling a footballer who haven't scored any goals Leo Messi- because he is well built. I said Mukti is strong because of her built. And yes she might be a strong contestant. BUT WHEN DID SHE PROVE THAT IN THE COMPETION till the time of decision. ? She could have done the 1st one well- but she didnt. On the other hand- Mahi tried to give her best in both he stunts she did- Yes she might be weak- but when you have an option to choose between one who tried well, and one who THREW away the first stunt due to overconfidence, it is a better decision to save the one who tries. And to say that Mukti is much stronger than Mahi, Both have done 2 stunts. And we all know the result. Where exactly is Mukti miles ahead of Mahi? Yes . Mukti is well built and must come off as a good player in the future- but right now we just need to look at the 2 stunts both of them have performed- and take a decision. Which I think- is Fair enough.

Ohh

Yes v all know d result..dat for Mukti it wasn't possible to do d task widout goggles n it was her sheer stupidity dat she had to abort d task n Mahi too left her first stunt in between..D second stunt was not only abt swimming..it required strength too n where others r given a benefit of not being blamed in a grup task den so she shud also b given..while Mahi too went wid a partner in d other stunt bt it revolved majorly arnd her..Both of dem actually hadnt been gud at d tym of decision..Hence I said v need to evaluate who can b more beneficial to d team in d upcoming weeks
When I called mukti strong it was not just bcz of her physique bt it was also on d assumption dat she's a dancer n she must hv loads of strength n flexibility vis a vis Mahi...Ofcourse when I compared d situation wid Sachin n some random player, it dint mean dat one takes d statement at its face value 😆
I felt jai shud hv looked at d bigger picture n chosen d two weakest contestants..if one of d two was going to b mukti den d other shud hv been Mahi..I said it before n repeating it dat team's loss of Mahi wud hv been lesser dan if it lost any other of its member imo

well after all the discussion i can only say that lets agree to disagree. to me mukti well never be better than mahi until she proves it by doing a stunt exceptionally well. so far she is one of d biggest disappointment of d season. even tanisha is performing better than her. for me jai's decision was fair n perfect.