Created

Last reply

Replies

25

Views

2.6k

Users

8

Likes

49

Frequent Posters

Blackwater thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#21

Originally posted by: russhmeSS



Honestly, it was quite confusing. Because only Parvathy was safe and he had to choose from remaining 6 contestants. Ideally he should have chosen the weakest ones, because unlike last week they had the decision completely in their hands. I appreciate that he accepted his mistakes as captain and nominated himself, but as individual player he is strong and so is Mukti. So either of them getting eliminated could have costed the team.. I feel he should have nominated Yuvraj (not being able to swim is a biggest disadvantage for him) and Mahi (though she has determination to complete stunts, but she otherwise seems weak as far as strength/stamina are considered)


Exactly!! Mahi n parvathy wud hv been an ideal choice bt parvathy was already safe..Had I been a captain, I wud have chosen Mahi n someone else..if somebody has to leave, let it be her..Yuvraj cud b really gud at other stunts bt water stunts r going to b a big let down for him while playing in a team or individually
NAUCholic thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#22
@Rinki- Not able to quote you IDK why . This is the reply for your comment in which you quoted me previously.😊
I somewhat agree with the last point^ teams lose wala.
But at ground level, looking at the 2 stunts- and NOT the previous backgrounds, I think Jay's decision was fair.
So techinically speaking, he was fair.
Practically speaking- that is looking at the dancer background and built and everything, Mukti would have been a future asset more than Mahi. So planning for the future, Jay could have saved Mukti- but future planning hota hi toh he wouldn't have said his name too. 😆 Because as Vivan said- commander ko uda diya toh fir team ki lagan bohot aasan hoga- because a new leader would take time to settle- and on the other side we have Tanishia who has settled well in the team.
So if he had took the decision keepingin mind what would the team lose etc in future, then forget Mukti, he wouldn't even have nominated himself. So he obviously kept previous grassroot level performances in mind. And talking about fair and unfairness, it was a fair enought decision.
Both did 2 stunts- Both failed. 1 tried well in both but failed.
1 threw away the first one due to her stupidity and overconfidence, second stunt- yes she tried and she wasn't at fault like she did with the first one. And failed
We have 2 fails in both case. Both contestants ke second stunt mein they genuinely failed. 1st stunt mein 1 tried and failed- and one did stupidity and failed.
So see- grassroot level mein when we compare, saving mahi was fair enough.
So yeah, I have spoken of 2 perspectives.
Edited by NAUCholic - 9 years ago
Blackwater thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#23
^ Hmm I think differently here too..I think it is better dat blue team gets a new captain..he has failed miserably as a captain..Faisal was saying something before d elimination stunt (n I think dat was related to Jai..I cudnt hear it properly as someone entered in my room n I had to lower down d volume..he was talking of negative vibes..I ll rewatch d epi again to listen to him)..So d future seems bright widout jai as a captain 😆
D thing was Mahi n mukti both were bad in dere first stunt...one acted stupidly while d other left in between..I can't say one was better instead I ll say d other was a little worse dan d former..Hence I brought d future aspect into d discussion..I think had someone else b at jai's position he wud hv definitely placed Mahi into eliminations, keeping her past performances n how much useful she cud b for d team, in mind..d other might have been mukti..bt jai's choice wasn't Mahi..dat was wrong imo
Off topic: Sometimes it happens wid me when I quote someone n reply, d text doesn't show up or sometimes I face an issue of double posts..I don't know how n why if starts behaving weirdly sometimes 🤔
krutiv100 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#24
I think it was fair a decision. Jay did two stunts and lost points in both although the first task relied on only Mahi, I think if Mahi had gone in the Tank and Jay got the keys out they may have completed it faster.
about Mukti, she is a national swimmer and in both swimming stunts she failed. At least Mahi completed her stunt this week and last week too she was so close it was only one strawberry left. Raghav did two tasks, the car he wasnearly there and also he was the only one in their team who actually even managed to get a dummy out of the bus, Faizal was already so upset and crying about failing his task and Yuvraaj didn't even get to do a task this week, Parvati was safe so Jay didn't really have much choice other than himself and Mukti.

Also at the end of the day its not just about teams but individual performance, see Jay's team lost but Parvati was safe as she sucessfully completed her stunt(Tina's disqualification issue aside).

I hope who ever the new captain is makes better choices according to the tasks.
Edited by krutiv100 - 9 years ago
NAUCholic thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#25

Originally posted by: Rinki_r4

^ Hmm I think differently here too..I think it is better dat blue team gets a new captain..he has failed miserably as a captain..Faisal was saying something before d elimination stunt (n I think dat was related to Jai..I cudnt hear it properly as someone entered in my room n I had to lower down d volume..he was talking of negative vibes..I ll rewatch d epi again to listen to him)..So d future seems bright widout jai as a captain 😆
D thing was Mahi n mukti both were bad in dere first stunt...one acted stupidly while d other left in between..I can't say one was better instead I ll say d other was a little worse dan d former..Hence I brought d future aspect into d discussion..I think had someone else b at jai's position he wud hv definitely placed Mahi into eliminations, keeping her past performances n how much useful she cud b for d team, in mind..d other might have been mukti..bt jai's choice wasn't Mahi..dat was wrong imo
Off topic: Sometimes it happens wid me when I quote someone n reply, d text doesn't show up or sometimes I face an issue of double posts..I don't know how n why if starts behaving weirdly sometimes 🤔


Yeah everyone has a different perspective and opinion. I think we both have spoken enough (a lot actually😆). So yeah. Peace out for now😆 Agle hafte koi aur topic pe debate karte hai( Supporting Raghav and Faizal starting se- but I don't think unpe koi debate hoga- but haan. Baakiyo mein koi na koi kuch kaand karega so uspe debate karte hai😆) Ya fir maybe we'll end up debating together against someone else😆 Lets see.😆

Off topic- Yes the text didn't show up. It happens once in a while. Maybe some website/code issues 😆
Edited by NAUCholic - 9 years ago
priya185 thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#26
mahi failed both her tasks too but she put in more effort in mouse/fish task
Edited by -Priya- - 9 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".