I dont get it : (

187176 thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#1

Ok i am really really really confused and i just want to know reason why so i can understand more...

All this is just my thinking and may be stupid or naive or whatever so excuse me

Bani and pia

I had actually thought that bani had done the right thing by bringing pia home for an number of reasons

*Firstly pia thinks that bani still likes her and rano , the docter said as well not to get stress. So it made sense for bani to bring her home than just leaving her there or telling her the truth.

*Bani did say that shes not gonna forgive pia for what shes done. I know she never did anything before but she had no need to since pia had gone out of their lives and more inportant things going on.

*Jai - she brought pia infront of jai again but what was she suppose to do.How was she gonna explain not being in the walia mansion again šŸ˜•. Plus Banis not gonna wanna leave wm because of pia.Plus i think if Jai was the attacker i am sure bani would have still supported him if he lost his memory.

Its not just fact pias her sister humanity comes into it as well. I am really off the mark and want to understand why people bashing her so please do explain because i keep asking in pm so instead decided to make a post.

Tarun

*He has no real sympathy but i did wonder was jai abit harsh on a mentally ill paitent ? or was he justified.

I thought he might have been and hope that tarun does not do something stupid. Jai was right as a husband..but is he not taruns friend? same with bani of course her not supporting tarun was out of characteršŸ˜†.

Most of the story has incosistency down to the kreatives and none of the characters are kept same either. However this is all confusing me as i am not gettting this...maybe i am just in a sympathetic mood or something but still

thanks nina x

Created

Last reply

Replies

6

Views

706

Users

4

Frequent Posters

swatinarang thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#2

Originally posted by: Ektas_Angel

Ok i am really really really confused and i just want to know reason why so i can understand more...

All this is just my thinking and may be stupid or naive or whatever so excuse me

Bani and pia

I had actually thought that bani had done the right thing by bringing pia home for an number of reasons

us ne apne pero par khud kulhari mari hai.

*Firstly pia thinks that bani still likes her and rano , the docter said as well not to get stress. So it made sense for bani to bring her home than just leaving her there or telling her the truth.

that doctor is also with pia in her plan of memory loss otherwise most of the times doctor says that people should be shown old photographs so that she can recall, but this doctor is so 😔

*Bani did say that shes not gonna forgive pia for what shes done. I know she never did anything before but she had no need to since pia had gone out of their lives and more inportant things going on.

but now i think she has forgotten everything and that day is near by when she is gonna put blame of rape on JW and gonna save her rapist sister for that stupid kasam to her stupid psychic parents (they were psychic as only psychic people go for extreme measures such as suicide and her father was a stupid drunkard person)

*Jai - she brought pia infront of jai again but what was she suppose to do.How was she gonna explain not being in the walia mansion again šŸ˜•. Plus Banis not gonna wanna leave wm because of pia.Plus i think if Jai was the attacker i am sure bani would have still supported him if he lost his memory.

she may have given a number of reasons that she is to stay separate because of her job or something, why she brought her to WM. she might have shifted pia to some guest house of WI or some other employees flat tellign her that she has got that from company, but no she wants all luxuires for her rapist sister too so brought her there to torture her husband. i am quite sure if it would have been a non dixit or even Jw she may have taken some other step and may have thrown him out on the street.

Its not just fact pias her sister humanity comes into it as well. I am really off the mark and want to understand why people bashing her so please do explain because i keep asking in pm so instead decided to make a post.

for humanity i am not saying her just to throw her on roads, but she may have tried to settle her somewhere else and may have arranged for some other job where she won't come face to face with JW on a daily basis

Tarun

*He has no real sympathy but i did wonder was jai abit harsh on a mentally ill paitent ? or was he justified.

i think now that he has been fully cured, but is in deep love with bani.

I thought he might have been and hope that tarun does not do something stupid. Jai was right as a husband..but is he not taruns friend? same with bani of course her not supporting tarun was out of characteršŸ˜†.

i think Jw should have taken care of him and again Jw is right in keeping him away because if he will become too possessive about than because of his illness he can attack bani and her unborn child also. so better to keep bani away from him, but he himself shld have taken care of him, but tell me which husband will take care of a friend who is in deep love with his wife.šŸ˜† i think Jw was great enough for not strangling him for loving bani.

Most of the story has incosistency down to the kreatives and none of the characters are kept same either. However this is all confusing me as i am not gettting this...maybe i am just in a sympathetic mood or something but still

i have given my POVs

swati

187176 thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: *Indian currey*

šŸ˜•.....confused too... šŸ˜•

I know thats why i wanted to know its been puzzling me

radha07 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 18 years ago
#5
interesting points but im also confused ...sorry cant help.... 😊
Henna 786 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 18 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: Ektas_Angel

Ok i am really really really confused and i just want to know reason why so i can understand more...

All this is just my thinking and may be stupid or naive or whatever so excuse me

Bani and pia

I had actually thought that bani had done the right thing by bringing pia home for an number of reasons

*Firstly pia thinks that bani still likes her and rano , the docter said as well not to get stress. So it made sense for bani to bring her home than just leaving her there or telling her the truth.

*Bani did say that shes not gonna forgive pia for what shes done. I know she never did anything before but she had no need to since pia had gone out of their lives and more inportant things going on.

*Jai - she brought pia infront of jai again but what was she suppose to do.How was she gonna explain not being in the walia mansion again šŸ˜•. Plus Banis not gonna wanna leave wm because of pia.Plus i think if Jai was the attacker i am sure bani would have still supported him if he lost his memory.

Its not just fact pias her sister humanity comes into it as well. I am really off the mark and want to understand why people bashing her so please do explain because i keep asking in pm so instead decided to make a post.

Tarun

*He has no real sympathy but i did wonder was jai abit harsh on a mentally ill paitent ? or was he justified.

I thought he might have been and hope that tarun does not do something stupid. Jai was right as a husband..but is he not taruns friend? same with bani of course her not supporting tarun was out of characteršŸ˜†.

Most of the story has incosistency down to the kreatives and none of the characters are kept same either. However this is all confusing me as i am not gettting this...maybe i am just in a sympathetic mood or something but still

thanks nina x

man im confused.. šŸ˜† ill tell u my views after i sleep šŸ˜† u heard about my day šŸ˜† ill go after update is up šŸ˜‰

im confused like you

Henna x

187176 thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: radha07

interesting points but im also confused ...sorry cant help.... 😊

šŸ˜† šŸ˜†i think we need start a confused society or something.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".