Pia's defense!!!!! - Page 4

Originally posted by: adee_ahsan

we cant give pia a 2nd chance no sis will give it!

but isnt the point of sisterly love - like maternal love - that you love unconditionally?

Originally posted by: goldenword

I don't know about Pia being given another chance, but yes she has been projected as one of the dumbest humans susceptible to her own whims and desires.

Number 1 - why did she assume that Bani did not love Jai. She never had the capacity or brains to go deep into the pysche of bani and figuure out her likes and dislikes. Pia is too self absorbed and self centered a character to think clearly about anyone but herself. She believed that Bani does not love Jai, because deep down she (Pia) wanted Jai back in her life. So she did not want to give account to the time that Bani and Jai spent with each other and the feelings that potentaially may have developed between them. Come on even if you keep a pet in the house, u develop a compassion and love for that creature and Bani and Jai are not pets but humans.

But all the above is not a crime! It's her airheadedness, not malice! We cant condemn people for being stupid!

2 - Her offering shoulder to Jai was more out of her own selfishness coz she wanted to possess Jai. At that point dhe did not even consider that her di and Jai are still officially married. 😕

Jai threw the divorce papers in her face saying "ye lo maine sign kardiya hai, now you're Banidi is free!" she's no lawyer, why would she believe otherwise? she was in court the day the judge himself approved the divorce!!

3 - How is she so convinced that Bani did not love Jai. After all Bani was carrying Jai's child so there must have been some attraction at least between them.

yes this is true - but she stormed in on JW when she found out about the pregnancy accusing him of all sorts! and he said to her that they both consented BUT he gave the impression that it was a mistake - which he too believed at the time!

Like I said I don't know whether I would like to give her any chance, coz she has too myopic a way of looking at things. She has literally tried to break her own sister's home and also set fire to her own home. Her conscience is answerable to two people and that is Pushkar and Bani. If these two can forgive her then who are we to decide her fate. 😉

well said - myopic - perfect phrase!!! but again, everyone deserves a second chance, IF they really regret their actions.

Originally posted by: lonely14

Hey guys!!!

okay this is not a pia bashing post or anything of that sort.

I was just wondering, if you put your feelings aside about how much you hate pia, how many of you actually can think of giving pia another chance?

I mean she is also human, so doesn't she deserve another chance?

Before you answer, please think logically before answering the question, put all the negative feelings you had for pia ever since KS started, and put yourself in her shoes. (please don't be like i would never do that to my sister, common claim).

I was just wondering how many of the lovely people from the KS parivaar, are actually willing to give Pia another chance.

Thanks,

Shina

Who are u addressing this to. Are u asking her family et al in KS to give her another chance or are u asking us viewers to view her in a different light or ae u asking forgiveness for a real Pia charecter in our neighbourhood.

If it is the former, then the question does not arise since she has always be forgiven nay endured by people who matter.

As far as viewers go ...well...

P is seriously flawed but she cannot garner that sympathy which we been very generous in disensing out to our other flawed charecter JW. A small factor which is responsible for this bias is that RK adds to the charecter a piece of himself making JW breath real on screen. RC lacks significantly there.But the crux lies in the charecter development of P. Her charecter is not charismatic, is monochromatic, dull, her interactions with sisters unreal,chemistry with Pushkar stilted and so on.

A Pia next door would not deserve any sympathy points from me bcoz my reading into her charecter tells me that she will never reform enuff to be worthy of compassion. Her nature prevents her from transmuting!!

CAT

Originally posted by: Cordelia

but isnt the point of sisterly love - like maternal love - that you love unconditionally?

Cord Dear,

No amount of maternal love can forgive a sister for this. Unconditional love!!!!! wasn't this what Bani had been giving Pia till now. Forgiving all her mistakes and helping her no matter what.

And what did Pia do????? Even if she was not aware of Bani's love for Jai. For God sakes, he is Bani's husband, she was going have his baby, that means they did have a relationship. There are certain relations which have the banner "taboo" on it. Some relations which need different type of respect. You can not just fall in love with your Jiju. She literally threw herself upon Jai (a drunk Jai). Wasn't she the one who questioned Jia about morals for sleeping with Bani, when she was not in her senses. What did she call it?????? !!!!!!!!

There is no excuse for Pia.