Pia's defense!!!!!

Hey guys!!!

okay this is not a pia bashing post or anything of that sort.

I was just wondering, if you put your feelings aside about how much you hate pia, how many of you actually can think of giving pia another chance?

I mean she is also human, so doesn't she deserve another chance?

Before you answer, please think logically before answering the question, put all the negative feelings you had for pia ever since KS started, and put yourself in her shoes. (please don't be like i would never do that to my sister, common claim).

I was just wondering how many of the lovely people from the KS parivaar, are actually willing to give Pia another chance.

Thanks,

Shina

Hun,i can't even think to put myself in her shoes...i'm better then that.Pia is so self centered,spoiled brat,even if i tried to put myself in her shoes,i won't be able to come close to be as obnoxious as she is....

Originally posted by: divya74

Hun,i can't even think to put myself in her shoes...i'm better then that.Pia is so self centered,spoiled brat,even if i tried to put myself in her shoes,i won't be able to come close to be as obnoxious as she is....

See exactly my point, i want you to put the negative feelings aside and think about it. Because the pia you stated there is a universal opinion, but that aside and think about it.

See but i can't ever do that because i am NOT pia!
and i can't pretend that the things that she did aren't horrible.
and i can't erase the things she's done out of my mind.
Her previous actions have to be taken into consideration.
it's not like she has done horrible things only once...its repeated over and over again.!!!
As a human being i am going to judge her and i can't help it!!

Hehe ibet my TOK teacher would be proud!!!!
😊

How can pia say that she gave her shoulder to jai when he was in tears... actully he never wanted that... she forced him to rest on her shoulders.. What is her feelings towards bani.. why didn't she gave her shoulders to her when she was in need.. what about her love Pushkar.. why didn't she try to understand himm .. This is all because they are all pennyless people.. and the reason why she gave her shoulders(and many more) to Jai and only Jai because he is crorpati.. There is nothing true in her philosophy and thought.. she is so self centered and nothing... she thinks of her only.. but she thinks she loves all others.. and what she thinks love is not the real love... nobody can make her understand that too

Originally posted by: lonely14

See exactly my point, i want you to put the negative feelings aside and think about it. Because the pia you stated there is a universal opinion, but that aside and think about it.

Arre yaar,i can't seem to put myself in her shoes......sorry,i can't it's very difficult....maybe if she didn't sleep with her brother-in-law,then i could've tried.....😕

Shina,

Good post , a POV, that I so agree on.

I have , in my own way , in earlier posts tried to show Pia as a superficial character and not evil and negetive. She is susceptible and vulnerable, yes.

As for the episode yday and her reactions, it was not surprising at all to me:

One, she got to hear the truth from Jai himself.

Second, she respects Jai Walia, she has admitted that, but yesterday, she was shown teh difference between her respect and what she thought was love.

As for her Bani di, she is devastated for she has suddenly realzied to what extent her mistake has costed the happiness of others including pushkar.

She is jus as human as anyone else and time is the best healer they say, and so will she with time, as she has , realize her true calling.

As for her turning negetive, well she has experienced, pain, seen her dreams shattered, lost what she thought was love, drowing in guilt, for her Bani di, and such emotions , all at once , can drive one to extremes, of eitehr going to depression or react and say I want what I want and may be Pia will go into an angle where she will regret her not marrying Jai Walia, for she had a chance to do so. Jealousy is a feeling has to fight with on his own and no one can do that for you and so will pia do that and battle with her inner self and come out a better person and the end of it.

It takes a lot of negetivity at times to make one see the positive light at the end of it all.

My thoughts!

Sareeta

as much as i try to sympathize her she ends up doing things that leaves me fuming 😡 😡
letz not talk abt jai but pushkar ,the guy tried moving the earth to make her happy and content but.....
how much do u think a guy can take if u constantly keep on throwing another man on his face 😡
there was never sense in her actions
i thought that atleast after what happened on 3rd oct she will regret next morn but ...
she is still married technically at least she owns it to pushkar to totally end their relation before jumping into bed with another man leave alone ur brother in law
jai was manipulated by her on that night, he was drunk and lost she was not, a line for morality has to be drawn ,no woman however modern can try and justify this forgettable incident and to top that she tells jai that i offered u shoulders when bani made him cry plzz.. 😡
and then she tells pushkar that she has forgiven him ffor what???? as far as i know other than marrying her he has made no other mistakes.
u know the only person i sympathize with is pushkar 😭 that guy has lost all and yet is trying ...he deserves much better.earlier atleast she had that love for her sisters but i tell u there is no regret for what she did but a sad realization of what she could not have 😕 even if she regrets it is being overshadowed by her love for jai i think hence ....
sorry dear but try as much i just cannot try and defend her

pia is only playing a character what her director wrote for her. yes it is different in real life. some one should let her know that how much her sister loves mr jw. she is not aware off.

Originally posted by: jigna_07

See but i can't ever do that because i am NOT pia!
and i can't pretend that the things that she did aren't horrible.
and i can't erase the things she's done out of my mind.
Her previous actions have to be taken into consideration.
it's not like she has done horrible things only once...its repeated over and over again.!!!
As a human being i am going to judge her and i can't help it!!

Hehe ibet my TOK teacher would be proud!!!!
😊

Yeah see that's just the preset notion of pia!!!!!

i know we are going to judge her, but we can try and understand her can't we?