Welcome to the forum!! - Page 5

Created

Last reply

Replies

157

Views

10.5k

Users

23

Likes

143

Frequent Posters

1123225 thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#41
Also, karnas part in Bheemas poisoning was NOT REMOVED by BORI.
Thereupon, the evil-minded Duryodhana, with Karna and the son of Subala,13 tried to
banish them and oppressed them in various ways. That evil son of Dhritarashtra gave poison
to Bhima with his food, but the warrior Vrikodara14 digested it.


Reminder: Karna was several years older than Bheema, and likely, an adult by then. An adult poisoning a child.


SweetRogue thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#42

Originally posted by: RadheyaUruvi



Hello. Plz read it again. according to debory translation, karna was trunk of passion tree and passion is good quality

Karna's involvement in bhim poisoning and varnavrat conspiracy is removed by BORI

How can you justify burning of woman and kids? If anyone kill your mother and kids to save his life will you accept that? Its simply sin commited by pandavas. atleast duryodhan tried to kill pandavas because they were enemy but those innocent nishadas did nothing to pandavs. admit that

Manyu generally means anger/wrath. And no, it isn't. I can provide citations. I will ask the same question to you. If domsome considered your mother and brothers enemies and burned them alive will you accept that? It's not about acceptability. Both groups comitted murder. I'm not justifying anyone's actions. This narrative only serves as balancing the equation a bit and showing that Pandavas, especially Yudhishtir aren't innocent angels. But there is nothing to conclude that Karna was better than Pandavas in this narrative at least. And I can provide many citations in which Karna comes off as a far worse person. He casually made remarks like this- Besides women always like to have many husbands,

How can any woman idealise this man whose misogyny is evident in many parts of the epic?
SweetRogue thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#43

Originally posted by: RadheyaUruvi

List of unrighteous/wrong acts committed by the Pandavas as per the Mahabharata

I have seen some pandava fans who were crying just because their idols (evil triplet) fell in the hell and Karna obtained seat along with lord vishnu. So here is the all reasons why all pandavas fell in the hell

1. When both the Pandavas and the Kauravas were children, Bhima, with his massive physical strength, grew up to be a bully, and used to torture the younger Kauravas, sometimes almost killing them in the process. This is the first of the long series of crimes committed by the Pandavas.

2. As Yudhisthira was elder than Bhima and the Kauravas, it was his duty to refrain Bhima from torturing his younger cousins. But he did nothing of this sort, and we can conclude he silently supported Bhima's misdeeds. This is the first crime of the eldest Pandava.

3. While living in Drona's school/ashrama, Arjuna, unable to excel Ekalavya in archery, and burning with jealousy, encouraged or rather we may say, compelled Drona to deprive Ekalavya of his thumb. This was the first crime of the third Pandava. And when Ekalavya had been deprived of his thumb, Arjuna felt very such satisfied. This displays he enjoyed other people's sufferings.

4. Pandavas were iligeal adopted sons of pandu whereas Duryodhana was legal heir to throne still pandava begged for kingdom without any reason

5. At the martial exhibition of Hastinapura, Bhima insulted Karna, literally comparing him to a dog, just for Karna's being from a lower-caste family. The other Pandavas silently supported Bhima, displaying their disregard for the lower-caste people.

6. When Drona sent his disciples to capture Drupada, Arjuna (and the other Pandavas) refused to accompany the Kauravas. Thus they undermined the kingdom's reputation for their own political designations. It was a clear act of treachery towards Hastinapura.

7. In the Jatugriha incident, the yudhistira supported by all pandavas plotted to burn innocent woman and five kids. Kunti mixed poison in their food. Pandavas murdered six innocent Nishadas (a Nishada woman and her five children) to fake their own death

8. During their first self-designed exile, Bhima met Hidimva and despite no fault of hers, was about to kill her. (Though later she was spared due to Yudhisthira's politically-motivated intervention)

9. After winning Draupadi at swyamvara, the other Pandavas felt lust for her despite Draupadi being won by their brother Arjuna. (According to Indian traditional values, wife of the elder brother is considered equivalent to mother and wife of the younger brother is considered equivalent to a sister. But the characterless Pandavas broke all norms and lusted for their brother's wife).

10. The five Pandavas together married Draupadi, literally dividing her like a piece of biscuit. (An ultimate disgrace towards the Indian traditions in general, and to women in particular).

11. Arjuna, while he was observing the vow of Brahmacharya, broke its all rules, married thrice and fathered three children. (The greatest 'Brahmachari' LOL)

12. Arjuna abducted Subhadra against her will, dragged and forced her to marry him. (We can say Arjuna raped Subhadra because coercing anyone to have physical relations with her/him also comes under the definition of rape).

13. Arjuna (and his partner-in-crime Krishna) burnt down the entire Khandava forest, mercilessly massacring innumerable vidhyadharas human tribes, animals and birds who had done no harm to anybody

14. The Pandavas insulted Duryodhana without any reason, when he had gone to Indraprashtha to attend the Rajasuya sacrifice

15. Yudhisthira, during the dice episode, gambled away his kingdom, his brothers and his wife just to snatch kingdom of duryodhana! (The ultimate gambler LOL). Its no one other than yudhistira who ordered draupadi to come at assembly exposing her navel just to gain public sympathy

16. Even after getting back the lost kingdom by the intervention of the kind-hearted Dhritarashtra, Yudhishthira once again gambled away his kingdom!

17. While living in the forest, Bhima used to kill hundreds of animals, who had not harmed anyone, just for entertainment.

18. Arjuna misbehaved with the disguised Shiva, thinking him to be a person of the lower-caste and abused kirata

19. The Pandavas made Indra to trick Karna into parting from his impenetrable armour and ear-rings. Pandavas were dancing after donation of karna

20. Arjuna was going to test his nuclear weapons against innocent animals

21. While living in the Matsya kingdom, Kichaka tried to rape Draupadi, and Yudhishthira, instead of protecting Draupadi, told her to 'live with it'. (Yudhisthira was ready to let Kichaka rape Draupadi for his political ambitions).

22. The Pandavas, despite being discovered during the incognito, illegally claimed the kingdom from Duryodhana. Infact all kings of aryavrat were humiliated by pandavas without any reason thats why all of them adopted the side of kauravas

23. The Pandavas, and specially Sahadeva, secretly sabotaged the peace mission of Krishna for their greed of the kingdom.

24. Before the war, Yudhisthira begged Salya to demoralize Karna, and sabotage Karna's war efforts.

25. The Pandavas never cared for their children, but used them during the great war. Arjuna ran away after using his wives for physical satisfaction

26. The Pandavas took advantage of Bhishma's affection towards them, and compelled him to reveal the method of his defeat

27. Arjuna was laughing at bhishma while attacking bhishma hiding behind woman. Bhima danced in joy when bhishma fell down

28. Arjuna overthrew Bhishma, taking cover behind one whom Bhishma considered a eunuch. (Bhishma was actually deceived by the Pandava disinformation campaign into thinking that Shikhandi was reincarnation of Amba, while this wasn't true. Shikhandi was demon not amba).

29. Arjuna killed King Bhagadatta by fraudulent means when bhagdatta lost his vision

30. Yudhisthira sacrificed Abhimanyu to save his own life on the 13th day of the war

31. Arjuna attacked weaponless and chariotless Karna from behind on the 14th day

32. Arjuna, with the assistance of Krishna, deceived Jayadratha and killed him

33. Arjuna sacrificed Ghatotkacha on the 14th night to save his own life from Karna. It's arjuna who ordered ghatotkach to kill karna with the help of satyaki

34. Pandavas plotted to murder their preceptor who trusted them more than his own son. Yudhisthira and Bhima lied to his preceptor Drona that Aswatthama had been killed, and allowed Dhrishtadyumna to kill an unarmed and unprepared Drona. Bhima again began to dance after the fall of drona

35. On the 17th day, Arjuna attacked Aswatthama from behind.

36. On the same day, Bhima brutally killed Dussasana and drank his blood just like a monster and admitted it's taste superior to milk of his mother

37. On the same day, the Pandavas killed Vrishasena by using unfair means.

38. On the same day, Arjuna killed an unarmed and chariotless Karna from behind.

39. On the last day of the war, the Pandavas killed King Salya using unfair tactics.

40. On the same day, Bhima killed Duryodhana by violating all rules of fair war just because bhima trembled with fear. Bhima even kicked the head of fallen duryodhana

41. After the war, Bhima, with silent approval of his elder brother, misbehaved with the old Dhritarashtra and Gandhari, and compelled them to leave the kingdom.

41. During the conquest of the Aswamedha sacrifice, Arjuna, due to his ego, abused and attacked his own son Vabhruvahana, and was killed by him as a result. (As you sow, so you reap tongue emoticon )

42. finally, Arjuna didn't save Krishna's wives from robbers, and fled the battlefield leaving the women at the hands of cruel robbers. (You can imagine what happened to those poor ladies)


Justice -

At last, as punishment for their lifelong misdeeds, crimes and sins the Pandavas died like beggars in the Himalayas, and experienced punishment in hell as well


And here I thought you were unbiased 😆 debating with people like you is like pouring water on an upturned pot. Believe what you want, I have no wish to debate with fanatics
Edited by SweetRogue - 6 years ago
SweetRogue thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#44
You call Krishna as Arjuna's partner in crime for Khandava incident yet use Krishna's words of praise as a character certificate for your lord Karna. Hypocrite much?
1123225 thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#45
Worse, they ignore words from the same Krishna, ripping Karna to shreds, just before he died.

Hmm. Which is more likely to be an honest assessment? What Krishna said to Karna to somehow stop a war? Or what he said to Karna at the time of his killing making sure the man doesnt die a peaceful death?


Ooh. One more. Krishna actually promises Panchali all the men who were involved in that sexual assault, including Karna, would die. Both statements could not be correct. Krishna was either lying to Karna or to Panchali. Given Krishna's words in the war, he was lying to Karna.
1123225 thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#46
Also, somehow, people seem to think anyone who dislikes Karna, the criminal, is a Pandava fan. I ain't one of those, either. If anything, I'm a Vyasa fan.

But oh, continue idolizing that sex-trafficking, child-posisoming, casteist (from his own words).


Star Plus is actually making a show whitewashing a criminal. Well, if Hirani can whitewash a living terrorist, why not a criminal who died millenia back?
1123225 thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#47

Originally posted by: Mahanayak-Karna



All statements of krishna before death of karna are interpolation. It will be better if you blame krishna. Krishana even called arjuna eunuch fool mean minded. Dont follow him blindly. Krishna even offered draupadi to karna for sexual intercourse



Understand mockery, Karna fan.


Krishna's vow to Panchali to kill Karna was made in a fill court of people. His offer to Karna was a lie. Karna was smart enough to get it. He mocked Krishna for making it. Krishna mocked him right back.


Sadly, Karna fans cling to that one page.


Also. Not an interploation: Krishna's statements to Karna at the time of his killing are there in BORI. It includes mostly Karna's order of sexual assault on Panchali.


Take al lk these statements together and TRY to understand what Krishna was doing to Karna. He was disheartening Karna with revelation of his parentage, and at the same time, mocking him with offer of empire and Panchali.

1123225 thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#48
Nope. KRISHNA did point out Karnas mistakes, even per BORI.


anjaya said, "Vasudeva was stationed on his chariot. He said, O Radheya! It is fortunate that you
remember dharma. Quite often, when they are immersed in hardships, inferior ones censure destiny,
but not their evil deeds. O Karna! When you, Suyodhana, Duhshasana and Shakuni Soubala brought
Droupadi to the assembly hall in a single garment, did dharma not show itself to you? When, in the
assembly hall, Yudhishthira, who was not skilled at dice, was defeated by Shakuni, who was skilled at
dice, where did dharma go then? O Karna! During her season, Krishna
798 was under Duhshasana's
subjugation in the assembly hall and you laughed at her. Where did dharma go then? O Karna!
Resorting to the king of Gandhara and coveting the kingdom, you challenged the Pandavas.
799
Where did dharma go then?' When Vasudeva addressed Radheya in this way, Pandava Dhananjaya
remembered all this and was overcome by great rage. Energetic flames of anger seemed to issue out
from all the pores on his body and it was extraordinary
Edited by HearMeRoar - 6 years ago
1123225 thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#49
And of course, Krishna lied to Karna. He even tells. Arjuna it is OK to lie to an enemy.
Krishna lied to Karna.
Edited by HearMeRoar - 6 years ago
1123225 thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#50
Ooh. You know what WAS removed by BORI as interpolation?
Most of Karna's digvijay.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".