.Lilith. thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 9 years ago
#1
Wondering whether I should give it to the CVs for keeping some things constant or frown at them for ruining something else in the process? 🤔

Yeah, just frown coz MaNan don't evoke any strong emotions in me these days and that's exactly what I'm talking about.

Let's just say that the way MaNan were sold to us, MU's were something completely alien...simply because their BASE was rock-solid.

On the other hand, the consistency in Manik's character- acting first, thinking later. In this case it's highly unlikely that he'll even think- that one dismissive look from her because she thought his presence was again her mind playing tricks on her, that smile...that bloody smile on her lips on which he thought only he had a right to, something he always used to complain about in the beginning- being given to someone else, another man so spontaneously...there goes the chances of him thinking from slim to zero! 😆

Again a point which the CVs missed...Manik is confrontational guy. Him going all #MyLyfIsSoSed just doesn't make sense! ESPECIALLY when it comes to Nandini! Him thinking that Nandini found a replacement for him is BIZARRE to begin with. Ok fine, he thinks she found a replacement for him in her life...he will CONFRONT her! He'll demand to know what went wrong even if his heart refuses to believe it, even if in the process he ends up hurting Nandini emotionally.

He'll demand to know, period.

I'm not even sure if the CVs thought so much before making him react the way he did, or it's just me trying to make sense where everything is so illogical. 😆

For all I know, it was probably a tactic to make the meeting happen the next day and not ruin the fun the group was having w/o an apparently dead guy walking in and announcing he's not dead...or whatever. 😆

P.S- Don't know whether it's the month-long break from acting or no good inspiration around but Parth's emotional breakdown in the end was so MEHH. 👎🏼


Created

Last reply

Replies

26

Views

4.2k

Users

15

Likes

137

Frequent Posters

Drivemecracy thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#2
U r right.their base is too strong for any misunderstanding or assumptions of the other moving on leaving them behind.i dont think cvs are at fault.they are pretty much beating a dead horse to win a race.u can see there is no story ahead.what will they do. But i have high respect for karishma oluchi what will she do when she came lead male gone and when she planned a story he is back.i dont know is it just me thinking thatthe cast is so disinterested or am i hallucinating i dont know but manan gave no feelings to me too.lookslike finally i moved on.
-abz- thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#3

You are right ...

But the thing is ..there are flaws . All relationship cannot be perfect ...MaNan toh definitely are not but they live it ! .. aur toh aur they are like just like 18 -20 years . This may trigger a lot if they take it in a proper way . I can feel it as in Manik and Nandini show it . Nandu thinks she is hallucinating ...Manik thinks she is ignoring ,he was just livid ; the plot had a crisp there. Both are craving and equally are suffering .
Vacuum's are created when we move away from loved ones that too with mysterious incidents ...its natural . Manik will surely live the trust once he gets an answer ..I hope that stays up without getting slaughtered .
I don't know what exactly they are showing...but I can see a hope of survival through Nandu ..she was living MaNan without Ma ...she needs it and completely deserves it .
Edited by -abz- - 9 years ago
piyali99 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#4
guys ryt now i think this was needed .. coz there really isnt any reason as to why MaNan will separate .. either it has to be a memory loss or some misunderstanding! as we all know kyy is a youth based show and we were already dreading the memory loss track and hence CVs had no option other than misunderstanding .ryt? so this was only the way to keep the viewers in a suspense ...and i think we all can take this ..as we have already waited for MaNan so long... and now when we noe manan is on its way waiting few more weeks is worthwhile .. ryt?😊
sweetdesire thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#5
Agree with ur post abt story and the way charecters react to it.

Just want to disagree with parth's acting part..I think he nailed it...ryt frm the restlessness to reach to venu on time to seeing her life nandini after long 4 month to the pain he feel when he thought that he got replaced by another person...Parth simply did a fab job there..I cried with him..he was crying lyk a baby...i want to hug him tight and console him..and that was the need of an hour for that charecter...proud to be his fan
Rose.gyp thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 9 years ago
#6
Agree with every single point you made. In fact I was going to point these out in my other topic...(I had Stepped out for some chores in middle)
Anyways.. I just don't get it. He has been away for 4 months!! Everyone thinks he is dead. Didn't he hear and react to the emotions of his friends and especially his love on Radio?!?

How is anger the first reaction when she turned away? Manik is a confrontational guy. Not one to walk away. And shouldn't he be the one doing the explaining here?! The CVs need to rewatch season 1 to get the essence of each character.

It seems like,'let's create a naam ke vaste misunderstanding so that the story can move fwd...and probably get monster Manik back. But they are losing the essence of Manan in the process. Better than this would have been a memory loss track.

On a side note... What's up with the sets now a days?? Have they converted the classrooms in the college as bedrooms for each character?? Maybe it's just me... But it was distracting. I loved that each had their own sets for home ( for some part of the first season atleast) and since F5 are rich... That could be related to. But the sets now a days are a lil dissapointing!
Just my POV.
Edited by Gypsyrose21 - 9 years ago
vaanii078 thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#7
I think they can only show misunderstanding as at this movement.more than misunderstanting he was hell shock.and PARTH he really nailed that scene.from that happines to breakdown he was soo good.and he made me cry.
LIKEDMG thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#8
New cvs don't hv any clear idea of Manik or Manan ...so whatever they will give on their own creativity ...it's diff from actual Manik or manan characterization ...cvs also accommodate wid new story..
I m finding Maddy s entry more dhamekedar in stage than Manik ...
Let's c how cvs will do Manan reunion...lots of promotion of it...
I agree manik s emotional break down doesn't work for me...it's acting ...direction...whatever...my pov is parth is really detach from Manik ...may b due to trend he came back...but I doubt we will get Manik back...
sanjana thumbnail
21st Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: LIKEDMG

New cvs don't hv any clear idea of Manik or Manan ...so whatever they will give on their own creativity ...it's diff from actual Manik or manan characterization ...cvs also accommodate wid new story..

I m finding Maddy s entry more dhamekedar in stage than Manik ...
Let's c how cvs will do Manan reunion...lots of promotion of it...
I agree manik s emotional break down doesn't work for me...it's acting ...direction...whatever...my pov is parth is really detach from Manik ...may b due to trend he came back...but I doubt we will get Manik back...



I want Maddy's character to stay on. From the beginning I found him more perfect when it comes to music. Is there any replacement for Yuvraj Thakur. Or will they let go Maddy's character.
Eggon_Snow thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 9 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: Gypsyrose21

Agree with every single point you made. In fact I was going to point these out in my other topic...(I had Stepped out for some chores in middle)
Anyways.. I just don't get it. He has been away for 4 months!! Everyone thinks he is dead. Didn't he hear and react to the emotions of his friends and especially his love on Radio?!?

How is anger the first reaction when she turned away? Manik is a confrontational guy. Not one to walk away. And shouldn't he be the one doing the explaining here?! The CVs need to rewatch season 1 to get the essence of each character.

It seems like,'let's create a naam ke vaste misunderstanding so that the story can move fwd...and probably get monster Manik back. But they are losing the essence of Manan in the process. Better than this would have been a memory loss track.

On a side note... What's up with the sets now a days?? Have they converted the classrooms in the college as bedrooms for each character?? Maybe it's just me... But it was distracting. I loved that each had their own sets for home ( for some part of the first season atleast) and since F5 are rich... That could be related to. But the sets now a days are a lil dissapointing!
Just my POV.


This...I hate the sets too. Its like they got a a half decent costume designer in exchange for a bad set designer. I hate Nandu's room, that pink is so garish and its too dark and depressing.

P.S. They better not change Manik's house, I loved that bungalow.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".