@Shibz
I'm replying here as the previous thread has been closed
1st let me clear I didn't watch all episodes of S2.. but I did watch most .so my point of view is best on tht..
2nd thing, whether u agree with this or not but the fact is offscreen drama did butcher the story line..I don't care who is responsible for this drama.. but when story is suffered due to tht then u just can't blame everything on writer/creative team..they hav to be certain wht direction they need to follow to execute a story n in this case they certainly were not sure abt tht.
So if u try to find logic in each n every scene so far then, it obviously wont make any sense. As they hav ML back in show now I'll hope they will hav a decent story line from now on.. or they will take few more epi for tht. n I'm ready to giv them tht timeline. But its just me..
So far they didn't reveal anything regarding to tht accident.it was never mentioned till yesterday tht ManBir are killed. So its obvious tht they keep tht as open end. But I never feel watching S2 tht they actually want to end Manik's character. There was not a single epi where he was not mentioned. thts why its my opinion tht they always want Manik back in show either by plastic surgery or the original one.
What does she want to give justice to ManBir for? as it was not accident so she wants to know who is behind all this to giv justice wht ever happen to them.
Even today she asked Arya kya tumne Manik ko maara?Ermm.. yes thts why I said till yesterday it was not mentioned as they r killed. But in promo again she said tht she knows Manik is alive.. so of course there is inconsistency. I wont deny tht.
One scene of Maddy-Nandu that I had seen had Maddy transferring gum on to her palm during handshake. Her reaction then, all the time she kept behaving like she would behave with Manik! Neither did I get her reaction to Maddy then nor with the new formed "friends"(that includes Feb3 too) I found it odd. I didnt watch tht epi I guess. so I wont comment on tht.. but whtever I hav seen her behavior with Maddy was never like she was with Manik.. @Bold, you mean to say from the time S2 started they've been waiting for Parth's confirmation to start with the investigation? YES..whether Parth or plastic surgery wala Manik or Maddy as Manik(as from very 1st appearance, Maddy's voice/attitude everything is same as Manik.. I thought tht time he will be Manik if they didnt find any other Manik) ..
Manik's dream is Feb3's happiness?Ermm ok. You forgot.. its all abt Yaariyaan.😉😆 so yes music binds them, it was their happiness. so fab5 as band was his dream.
@Bold, thank God you agree! But wait how did you know then?Confused I think I already mention tht..
It's funny how during S1, to defend Nandini ppl had to compare her actions with Manik's past actions. and now to defend S2's Nandini, ppl have to remind us how she was butchered during S1 as well!LOL : its the truth tht its always Nandini's character who suffers the most whether its in S1 or S2.. its not any justification as I don't support it whether be it in S1 or S2. but I'm saying wht is the fact.
Oh well I have always questioned logic even if it bore no fruit, and I will continue to do so. Likewise rant whenever my favourite characters are butcheredSleepy No one is asking u not to rant. at least I'm not saying to do anything like tht.. its open forum so I just replied wht I felt..as most of u r saying tht Nandini's character is all butchered coz she is smiling, taking part in election, roaming with new friends.never remembering Manik etc etc.. I have just different view point on tht part. other than tht, yes I also hav few issues with Nandini in S2 but my points r different. Its never tht she forgot Manik. Manik is always in her thought..
Now its upto u whether u'll agree or not. who m I to force u to do anything n why should I..
Edited by moonlite131 - 9 years ago
Anupamaa
Iss Pyaar Ko Kya Naam Doon
