|firefliesHaven|MaNan AT#141|Boxing that 'X' - Page 52

@ saamya... Yes I did not want them to talk about it personally.. I am more interested in them talking about initial days.. The pre- musicana,. Their attraction and want for each other.

I think what all this re-visiting memories idea required was to be done in a context which originally started with their story rather than Aliya and Dhruv's. It would've flowed better if they were actually conversing about each other rather than a third party and then some confessions took place as to when they feared losing each other, when was that first time they felt of their respective needs and when was it that they realised of their love. It happened too abruptly, which not only left us disappointed but if this was a means for the CV's to tick off another fandom wish well they should take in account that to travel down the memory lane, means so much more than just playing hit and run with a one-off memory. The scene was incomplete if to be said in simplest terms. Required more talk, the transitions of hate to obsession to like to love needed to be thoroughly explored. I know it's hard to sum up their story in mere minutes but some flashbacks would have supported the scene and made it easier. Get her to talk about the initial annoyance/hatred/dislike, then the other talks about how he couldn't ignore her even if he tried, get her to talk about how she saw for the first time that his monsterous act was all a mask, get him to talk about how painful it was to leave her, and conclude it on their eventual love realisations. It would've not only quickened the pace of the convo, but also summed up their whole journey and the viewers wouldn't have been left like their wish was honestly sabotaged.

The camera work was horrible last night. The writing and execution both failed. It was like they were clueless themselves.

Originally posted by: divansree

@ saamya... Yes I did not want them to talk about it personally.. I am more interested in them talking about initial days.. The pre- musicana,. Their attraction and want for each other.

We all know they love each other a lot.. So the voicing did not make much difference.

@ aashna.. Yes I rarely write you know.. Coz I am pathetic at it!

I love stalking and reading all you ppl's wonderful post.

Originally posted by: twinkle10

I think what all this re-visiting memories idea required was to be done in a context which originally started with their story rather than Aliya and Dhruv's. It would've flowed better if they were actually conversing about each other rather than a third party and then some confessions took place as to when they feared losing each other, when was that first time they felt of their respective needs and when was it that they realised of their love. It happened too abruptly, which not only left us disappointed but if this was a means for the CV's to tick off another fandom wish well they should take in account that to travel down the memory lane, means so much more than just playing hit and run with a one-off memory. The scene was incomplete if to be said in simplest terms. Required more talk, the transitions of hate to obsession to like to love needed to be thoroughly explored. I know it's hard to sum up their story in mere minutes but some flashbacks would have supported the scene and made it easier. Get her to talk about the initial annoyance/hatred/dislike, then the other talks about how he couldn't ignore her even if he tried, get her to talk about how she saw for the first time that his monsterous act was all a mask, get him to talk about how painful it was to leave her, and conclude it on their eventual love realisations. It would've not only quickened the pace of the convo, but also summed up their whole journey and the viewers wouldn't have been left like their wish was honestly sabotaged.

That homely feeling was lacking too. They weren't in the love bubble they usually are...like their own mellowness that their togetherness creates. Agree with Genie here, camera work was horrible last night. I would've preferred if the memory talk took place after their elegance...like the next morning they wake up all snuggled and speak a few words of their growth and how far they've come in this journey. Because elegance seems to be the ultimate union point for these two. As corny as it may sound, but they will become one in every way after that night. And so flicking through memories would've worked so well in that scene imo.

Originally posted by: nneeiill

yes something are better left unsaid. and as twinkle mentioned if they had to show it ..then dont throw it out randomly...

i actually want them to talk about his family and not this...something which leads them to an emotional high point

Originally posted by: VKlovesFK

The camera work was horrible last night. The writing and execution both failed. It was like they were clueless themselves.

Especially coming to MaNan scene dude that wasnt supposed to be a random talk. It just didnt fit in... It was like till monday i could see them in their love bubble and all tehraav, but yesterday it was like WTH...?

See for MaNan its their writing which is the king... if that is only not done properly even PaNi can't do anything.

Here's what i want from to see in the coming episodes..

Originally posted by: AreYaar

LOL who knew one specific hand holding scene would be such a deal maker/breaker and the ULTIMATE stamp on the MaNan relationship.

Forgive me if it doesn't work that way for me...I've seen far better from them...most especially when it comes to hand holding...this was hardly the best shot hand-holding scene b/w them.

there r so many tracks they can explore - band of brother, nayonika harshad, dhruliya, rishabh and ofcourse talen hunt. but they always introduce some random psycho track n every time fail miserably. and at the end of the day its always Nandu who became victim if audience wrath .. this is high time Manan need to work together and stop hiding things from each other.