The mind vs the Heart! - Thread - I need You! (Day 17); pg 28 - Page 6

Originally posted by: anotheranfan

Liked your analysis of episode in mind vs heart context.. Bold and red are the parts are what i would rate as 👍🏼 and red is what i would clap for.. 👏👏... only if maanik got that too

I think more than harshness, i think maanik's keeping in her college that gave her the much needed hope.. And a chance to see beyond his words and see that he did want her to stay in the college.

and as for maanik blaming nandini for getting close to him while he himself was the one who lost it.. this isnt the first time is it ... Well if he wants to make her suffer he needs to figure this out... this isnt puppy love.. its ingrained in him deep, so he cant get rid of it easily and for that matter ever.. He can hide it but he would need to take lots of efforts for that.. Maanik... maanik... maanik... when will you understand that your are fighting a loosing battle.. You might be delusional in thinking you would be able to make nandini suffer but you wouldnt be able to take it seeing her suffering... So get a grip of your heart or else just like in your words it wouldnt be fun to see your mind loose if it cant fight even for a minute..

Originally posted by: maankigeet4ever

i am finally here..reserved for sunny.

Twinkie my girl..why you so good with words ? humph, Sunny wants the same talent😭lol. Seriously thou, you rock😉

Well here i am...watched the episode which i absolutely loved by the way. Today was a little lighthearted episode which was a welcome change.

Well all praise the lord...Nandu is back..with a bang !! like Cabs says. Girl..twinkie and I have been waiting for you all week !!! But i guess she really needed a strong signal from Manik to bounce back with her determined nature and the expulsion being canceled by Manik was that signal. Now that she realizes he can't let her go, she realizes 'if she can break it, she can fix it.' this whole soha track has been so beneficial for this couple. Not only have they realized their love for each other, they have discovered how fragile trust can be. <font color="#ff0000">And Nandu has found out how delicate her Manik's heart really is. And she will work to not only win him back but she will learn to better protect his heart.</font>

Manik..Oh Manik. This guy is so simple despite seeming impossibly complicated because in simple terms as Cabir usually says: Manik does opposite of what he says.

I laughed, like legit laughed at Manik when he claimed that he will make Nandini suffer now and that she will see the 'real monster' because that's just about the biggest lie i have heard from him. <font color="#ff0000">If he wishes to make her suffer emotional, he is going to end up in much more misery.</font> He feels the emotions she feels and if she is in any pain, you can bet he will be hurting twice as much. Her tears are still his undoing.

His pain is going to work at all ! I hate to break it to Manik but Twinkie and I have already discovered your secret: there is no monster manik..that facade and shield has now been shed.

Because he proves himself wrong a few hours later when he is tenderly wiping the flour from her face. Oh what a scene ! Manik's internal battle of mind and heart is most visible when he is in close proximity with his Nandu because she robs his ability to think. Love the way his heart just takes over when Nandini is in his arms and the sheer temptation to wrap her petite form close..and that almost forehead kiss ! how hard he fought that, clearly evident.

And then he plays the 5 year blame game and I laughed again. I am sorry truly, i shouldn't be mocking Manik today but I was like Cabs today.

Cabs is my superstar and his presence in Manan's life is such a blessing. And the viewers too. His scene was such a welcome one. And he is so straight forward..lol. asking Manik how manages to get to Nandini every time. I predict good times ahead in Cabir's place with Navya, Nandini and Manik.<font color="#ff0000"> Navya and Cabir are gonna be partners in crime in patching MaNan up.</font>

I am reserving my comments for Pandit and Manik face off until i see how it happens but one thing is for sure: It's gonna be real fun ! If Manik becomes Pandit's new student, it's only because he wants to make Nandini suffer..in other words, stick as close to Nandu as possible.

Okies, i wrote you another essay. I just realized i didn't quote your main post so I couldn't bold the sentences i wanted to praise in particular but you know, you always write well my friend :)

Edited: I forgot to mention one of my favourite moments from today, The look Manik gives Nandini when he sees her on the college stairs. Oh baby, that look was pure love. It was relief of knowing she is back for good. I may have not being to describe Manik's emotions right but that look i loved .

- Reya aka Your Sunny <3

Originally posted by: twinkle10

Hahaha omg loved, loved, loved this! You know what was the highlight of your response? How you repeatedly referred to us and how we've been waiting for their actions or how we unmasked Manik's secret. I simply chuckled at that.

Don't worry... we shall be in role reversal today and I shall do the highlighting of your certain sentences to express my delight over some of the stuff you wrote. I just loved your line how she'll not only fix her heart but learn better as to how to protect it. This journey of theirs started with Soha but what a learning experience it's for them. And tbh I'm glad that they have gone through this element of pain, lack of trust and agony in a short span of time and whilst they are still in the process of discovering the depths of their love for each other. It would have been beyond difficult if Nyonika had plaid some trump cars of her at a later stage in Manan's relationship and Nandini would've fallen in it. That would've been more painful for the both of them as their would've been firmer expectations involved as to none out of the two would break the other's trust. I feel at the end of this journey that they're both treading on now, one of the aspects of a relationship that Manik would realise is that it is important to be friends with your companion in order to understand them better, understand the relationship of love better. If we actually think about it, Manan never experienced a taste of friendship, it's almost like they skipped that phase altogether and from enemies, they became lovers. But this is there chance to strengthen their bond! To seal the deal of being best friends with each other and then being lovers.

Cabir definitely stole the show today! And you're absolutely correct in saying that the duo of Navya and Cabir won't let Manan ever fail or break. You know how you mentioned to me yesterday how Cabir's sense of maturity is the basis of why he's character is such. If we actually think about it, same is the situation of Navya. Just like Cabir, she went through the journey of experiencing a blunder and then her battle of trying to rearrange her life back onto track. In the span of these 6 months, and especially last one month, the growth in her character is the reason she is able to understand the pain associated with love.

Yeh I agree with you there, honestly speaking... whilst we know the outcome of Manik and Pandit's confrontation in music class everyday, it will be interesting to watch the role Nandini will play in terms of keeping the two away from each other.

Haha you know I love your essays! It's something I look forward to nowadays,

That look was simply mesmerising. I knew you would like it because I loved it haha

The calmness and feeling aplomb that takes over as soon as he sees her standing in fronting of him was so evident in his eyes.

Umm sorry for another essay... but i just couldn't help it lol

Twinkie <3

Originally posted by: twinkle10

Firstly thankyou so much for your response! Such lovely words.

And yess... that element is definitely there. Nandini for once has blind faith that no matter what Manik says, his real reason of not letting her go is because he couldn't see her go. Now I feel this battle will be a harder fight for Manik than Nandini.. Because he's in denial and she has it all sorted out. I'm glad she knows she's the only solution to his problems and it will definitely be interesting to watch at which point Manik gives in completely to his heart. Ironic how he claims to her that the monster is back, in order to scare her.. I mean she's the first one who noticed that there is no monster within him and it's just a facade. So she has the least to be scared of here... 😆

Originally posted by: twinkle10

Alrightey so here I am again!!! Aah the bliss of writng an essay for you is the joy that nothing else provdes hahah

Anywho... so first thing first. Dudeee people probably hate us right now for being the massive sadists and tragedy queens that we are. I mean we like happy endings but the emotions of pain, hurt and agony that our Manan experience is what makes us love them. Maybe it's because it brings out the best in the both of them and their passion and need for each other seems to escalate to a brand new level. It's probably also because we both know that after they surpass this sea of fire, there is only "forever" destined in their lives.

Man how I love reading the repetitive lines of ours that express how Manan's bond is bound to get stronger and unbreakable after this track. The thought "whatever happens, is for the best" seems to have been only written for them. Because no matter how many times they face misunderstandings or difficult times , destiny always manages to bind them together in a knot which compels them to work together and find the solution of the situation.

Hahah you are a little nerd I must say ;)

And I agree 100% with you on the bond that Cabir and Navya will share amongst each other in the coming future. They will truly be the missile of friendship where I know for a fact that this life-longing friendship of theirs will also help the both of them in the healing process of their love-wounded hearts. They will eventually be the biggest support system for each other! :D

I sincerely hope you got through much of your uni workload and feel a little de-stressed now! :)

Aaah god job partner! I brought up a similar point in one of replies to another writer on this thread. Manan need to learn from their mistake of the lack of miscommunication here. Whilst they do it out of goodwill to save the other person from worrying too much about circumstance, but it is important they understand that when the're alone, they are 2 and when they join they become 11. Half their problems wouldn't even arise if they learned to open up more with each other and share their worries, because after all they are just two halves of the same heart. They need to become each other's strengths not each other's weaknesses.

Okies so now I'm done! Feel kind of bad thought I took so long to reply to you :( but I hope you know this just the start of our endeavor together of analyzing every second of Manan's life! haha

Loads of love...

Twinkie <3