Originally posted by: charminggenie
@Bold and in Black,
I was done stating my opinion before I read where you mentioned how we flock around to defend Manik .
Read the highlighted lines of your own post, see the hypocrisy which we have been calling out upon. Manik's feelings which have been building since day 1 is regarding as frivolous, unnecessary and ill-timed . Even though he has been constantly being the only one who has been for Cabir in all his worries or has been protecting/.covering the group since long. While you give clean signal to Alya and Dhruv who have not even realized what they want. I like Alya and Dhruv together as friends for now because they are being their individual self together, are they ready for any relationship? No because there is much to grow up for them as well . Alya who though growing beautifully away from her bubble, kept a secret that might not save Mukti on time. So she still has a long way to go as far as being mature is concerned. Dhruv constantly needs guidance , he is still on a shaky wicket, so should he also give up on his individual space and just relegate back in the gloomy back?
okay. let me say this for the last time. I dont have a problem with their relationship blooming midst everything , I had a problem wih he way the screenplay today was partricularly timed regarding the scene. They are i dont know , in my opinion also too old to do the catching and running dupatta thing which I know is done in plenty shows and movies but that does not mean I like it , I find it immature but anyway its indian tv I get it, having such a scene against such serious issues happening to others I felt was the lack of sensitivity on the cvs part regarding the screenplay. I have said this plenty a times before but I dont understand why for one character i have to constantly defend my opinion and justify when you guys ar generalizing my views and making something else. So yes I will call that overtly defensive. Manik ke baarey ek bhi bhool why cant we write? If we have a problem we will...this is a free place.No character is perfect.This was not even about them it was about the scene timing. The reason I have no problem with Dhruv Alyas progression is because just like you said , they have no idea in itself that it is happening which makes it all the more beautiful cause midst teir current and future heartbreaks they unknowingly have stumbled upon each other for support or shelter. Thats what I meant.
You just said Manik basically has no right to live his individuality and personal life , while Cabir, Mukti , Alya and Dhruv are free to do so? Cabir is settling his new equation privately as he should, there are things he need to understand and realize before he can confine in fab5 . Except Mukti who basically has not even realized what is happening to her , all of them needs this time apart to figure themselves and what they want.
I never said that , you thought I said that. I never stated or believed that he has no right to live. Its smiply your assumption of my opinion. Mukti somewhat knows what she is getting herself into but she canot find any other escape either , it is a helpless situation for her. she feels suffocated and pills only feel like a solution to her , which is obviously wrong.
Should Cabir stop loving or being with Raghav, hey because , Mukti is pill popping or should just be the joker like in the past who faked his feelings and new emotions behind the mask? If as I feel you would rightly disagree with it, then why isolate any other character too.
I never said Manik should stop loving. I didnt mean that even. Anyway.
Does being individuals prohibit their growth as a group or disrupt their bonding - Nope. They were using bullying to cover up their vulnerabilities when they were together which made them a bit toxic, now is their time to face their own issues and fight for themselves . This does mean when one of them will be down and out , they will forget everything and rush to protect each other.
You made an accusation basically mentioning how we made this topic all about Manik, probably the lines you wrote yourself seemed like a blur now.
I made an accusation because whatever my topic was became solely about Manik in the comments , I have a right to be irritated o one point being blown out of the proportion.