Dhruv is a disappointment,Really?

piya2025 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 11 years ago
#1

Pardon me,If I end up saying something wrong coz my views completely going to be based on whatever posts I have read about the last 3 epis.

Being a admire or a fan,doesn't mean everyone understand a char well..I haven't done any PhD on this char but from where I see,Dhruv is man enough to take a situation n handle it by his own.It's just that he keeps himself hidden from the eyes of the others,that doesn't mean he is not strong enough or weak.

He doesn't take part in ragging yet he stood there silently watching Nandini suffer.Then, he just met her,he might like her but isn't it to soon for him to stand up for Nandini? Wait ! It might sound a li'l wrong,so let me put it this way-isn't it too early to take Nandini's side going against of his brother like friend,Manik ?

He stood there watching every wrong activity of other fab.5 member,True but that doesn't mean he agrees to them n doesn't care for the other person.But if he starts protesting NOW,that'd look so out of character.😕

He may not say anything but his expressions are enough to understand what goes on in his head on that particular moment.Besides, it almost looks like everytime Nandini bow down to Manik's demand,she ends up disappointing Dhruv,Somewhere he expects her to fight back n be the different girl she really is or he finds her to be.

Dhruv has past that haunts him & what I think it'd take something serious,really serious to break the wall around him & to fight back.

Created

Last reply

Replies

22

Views

3.5k

Users

13

Likes

59

Frequent Posters

Arieltabi thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#2
How can Dhruv go against his childhood friends especially Manik who had always been there for him for some stranger like Nandini. Its easier said than done. And why would he go against Manik and hurt them for some stranger like Nandini.
And I think that all the fav5 has a lot of pain in their life. Especially Manik, Mukti and Kabir. Their parents doesn't care for them. They ragg people to get away from their pain, That's how they deal with their pain. I know its wrong but that's how they deal with their pain. They feel happy giving pain to others just like their parents give them pain. And Dhruv being their best friend how can he stop them from the the thing which is the only source of happiness in his friends life. I know its selfish. But people say love is selfish. We can do anything to keep our loved ones happy. So Dhruv stay quite for the sake of his friends happiness.
I don't know if people will agree with me or not. But this is what I feel.
Preternatural thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#3
Yeah I agree. The best he could do is telling his friend not to irritate her further and he did that. Plus the shoe-cleaning scene was between Manik and Nandini no one had any idea what's going on between them. So, although unhappy, couldn't stand up for Nandini. According to him, Nandini was a disappointment infact to everyone else who are unknown about the contract thingy. He thought Nandini will never agree to do that but even he was also surprised.

You're right it's not fair to against your best friend and stand by girl who he just met yesterday. But he would've stopped Manik as Manik only listens to him. I would obviously stand with my best friends but that doesn't mean I will sit there quietly and see them doing wrong things. I think Dhruv doesn't care about anything else except his group and Manik.

Edited by Abray - 11 years ago
arnavfluffy thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#4
I feel after nandini Dhruv is the most strongest character on the show!! And manik Dhruv bonding is soo tender..they complete each other!
Cat. thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 11 years ago
#5
I am someone who is disappointed by Dhruv's characterisation and I will tell you why.
With the rest of the fab 5 i.e. Manik, Cabir, Mukti and Alya , their moral compasses has always been in question, not only do they torment people but take pleasure in it. But whereas with Dhruv we have seen him established as someone who actually sees the wrong in this. I find it a bit of cop-out that Dhruv wont say anything to Manik in private because its been established that their friendship is also beyond what the others share. The fact that Dhruv could joke around when Manik was in a rage while the rest of the Fab 5 didnt even dare approach Manik kind of indicates what relationship they share.

And what is friendship if you cant look at your friends and tell them when they are wrong and again this is not in context of Nandini alone. If your best friend tells a classmate of yours to wipe his shoe, I would think that you would have the courage to tell your friend off, especially if your relationship is shown to be that strong. Just my point of view
Edited by Catatonic_Cat - 11 years ago
sadhanager thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#6
I was dhruni fan.i thought he is going to be nandini's soulmate, stand for nandini
against fab 5 (atleast little bit) one day, even though end game is manan.
but I am disappointed with shows director who is using dhruv as just puppet to build
manan story. If dhruv is weak link of manik then rishab is weak link of nandini.
There is no difference between rishab and dhruv.
I was sad yesterday because of ice cream scene, but today I am double sad because of auto ,
Note, water scene.

If nandini won't stand for dhruv against harshad (dhruv is never going
to stand for nandini)no dhruni in future. We all going to see manik harshad fight&another
hate turned love story of manan, like typical rr, bi, ipkknd1&2 , qh, d3, sh, etc etc
piya2025 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 11 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: Catatonic_Cat

I am someone who is disappointed by Dhruv's characterisation and I will tell you why.

With the rest of the fab 5 i.e. Manik, Cabir, Mukti and Alya , their moral compasses has always been in question, not only do they torment people but take pleasure in it. But whereas with Dhruv we have seen him established as someone who actually sees the wrong in this. I find it a bit of cop-out that Dhruv wont say anything to Manik in private because its been established that their friendship is also beyond what the others share. The fact that Dhruv could joke around when Manik was in a rage while the rest of the Fab 5 didnt even dare approach Manik kind of indicates what relationship they share.

And what is friendship if you cant look at your friends and tell them when they are wrong and again this is not in context of Nandini alone. If your best friend tells a classmate of yours to wipe his shoe, I would think that you would have the courage to tell your friend off, especially if your relationship is shown to be that strong. Just my point of view

@ RED- & this is exactly where I feel the catch is.
If he's not telling off Manik despite of feeling whatever they/ Manik doing is wrong,there is definitely 'd be some reason.. & It's not like he never let Manik know that he doesn't approve of what they usually do.. we have seen him telling to Manik not to be too hard on Nandini or then when the purohit guy said they are doing wrong to Navya he immediately went outside n the look in his eyes conveyed he went there to make sure if nothing she'd be fine even in that dustbin (If I can say so).


Then again it's just my POV.

Andy_Dynamite thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#8
For Dhruv, just like every other member of the group, Fab5 comes first!! He will stand with Fab5 no matter what!!! thats the main thing about fab5! brothers for life!!! right??

He does have a soft corner for Nandini, and remmeber, he did tell Manik not to trouble Nandini much.. didnt he?? And each time they bullied her,he stood there because he's feeling for Nandini aint that strong that he will fight back or stand up against his friends that mean the world to him.

Dhruv character according to me, is not that who will fight back at the spur of the moment, maybe it takes time to trigger his inner self defense. He has loads of patience i believe.😊
piya2025 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 11 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: sadhanager



If nandini won't stand for dhruv against harshad (dhruv is never going
to stand for nandini)no dhruni in future. We all going to see manik harshad fight&another
hate turned love story of manan, like typical rr, bi, ipkknd1&2 , qh, d3, sh, etc etc



Sorry to disappoint you dear but what I think he needs to stand up for himself & exactly,there I'm disappoint with the cv's..It's fine to show only Manik has the capability to clam Dhruv down when he gets through those haunting moments or vice versa..but showing him as weak as some mental case where he can't even tackle someone who is doing bad to him for nothing..it's un-digestible..

I repeat,He is man enough to stand up for himself coz he may not say so but he has his own opinion regarding the ragging business of the other Fab 5's,so if he can have a opinion which convey his mates are not doing right then I think he has enough courage to fight back Harshad or anyoneelse.

ArchRM thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#10
Manik treats dhruv as Bro & best buddy too, let Manik bad guy for outer world bt reality lies within & Dhruv know that.

It's not gd if a member of Fab-5 stands again their own group which may break their bond. & why u expecting dhruv to Stand for Nandu when he can't stand for him self against harshad.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".