Suhas Sawant vs Milind Ingle

HariOm thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#1
Last week and the week before that SS sung ok, going besur many times. Then he did his "love for father" drama and judges pighal gaye.

I think he is overrated. Milind Ingle sang much better than him, yet the judges saved SS & MI was in bottom 2.

Somehow SS' overly innocent face (which I think is put up) and the (not so) "nanha bangdu" stuff is annoying me.

Milind is a much better singer. I think he's been judged strictly because he is a professional singer. Infact MI sang much better than Vinod Rathod.
What do you all think him vs Milind Ingle

Created

Last reply

Replies

9

Views

1.5k

Users

5

Frequent Posters

HariOm thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#2
Wow, this forum really needs some activity. Only 4 views and no replies too
omkar.dandekar thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#3
HariOM Bhai!!!! You are perfectly right!!! Milind Ingle is DEFINITELY better than Suhaas!! I NEVER liked Suhas's voice. Just because he is the youngest contestant, he should not be treated differently. I even wonder how come a singer like Milind came in Danger zone in the first place? He may not be the best but was surely never Besura.... Whereas, Suhas was never good and not even ever in Sur. His last song 'Tera saath hai kitna pyara' was TERRRRRIBLE.... But he somehow managed to cover his faults by creating emotional scene...
Edited by omkar.dandekar - 17 years ago
simikr thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 17 years ago
#4
You are right! I thought the only song Suhas sang well was " Kuch to log kahenge". I thought that even Kshitij sang better than him and he was out last week. I wish the hostess wouldn't keep petting him, it makes me sick!!!

I agree with HariOm that there should be more participation on this forum. Many days pass without any posts. But I am glad that all the posts have something meaningful to share, not just a one word comment such as " Thanks". Haha....
spsharmila thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 17 years ago
#5
In this show for some weird reason,everybody is expected to sing in exactly same tone as Kishor kumar.Milind is always in sur but he never copys Kishor kumar's tonal quality.......probably thats why he lands in to trouble!!!!!
omkar.dandekar thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#6
But have u noticed Sharmila, Milind tried to sing "khab ho tum ya koi hakeekat" in Kishoreda's style. Didn't u feel so? Hear it carefully; u will notice that he tried to make many words sound more manly like Kishoreda...
HariOm thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#7
In yesterday's episode, Amit Kumar complimented Arnab for singing in his own style and not copying KK. But other times for Milind and other singers that was a complaint that they don't sing KK style.

Nayan Kumar Rathod was the best of this week's performances.

All in all good performances this week. And was glad to see SS get eliminated. It was a fair elimination.
shuas thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#8

helloo sir suhas here.
mere bare main itne bure comments padhe

kya baat hai man gaye sir aapko
main manata hu is comptition main accha nahi ga pa raha tha ye mujhe pata tha tabhi main apane aapko eliminate karana chah raha tha lekin judges ne mujhe itna badhava diya aur yahatak laya dusari baat maine compitishn main judges ko on the camera kaha me mujhe meri age ke hisaf se marks mat dijiye main agar bura gata hi to bure marks de ke nikaliye mujhe, mujhse jo better (kshitij ya aur koi bhi)hai usko aage layiye lekin unhone ye show main dikhaya nahi aur ek bat mujhe jo aap keh rahe hai ke emotional drama matlab aapne jaise kaha hai "love for father" drama and judges pighal gaye ye bat ye jo drama aap keha rahe hai wo on the stge jo mere father ke bare main kehake mijhe rone par majbur kardiya unhone jo drama create kiya tha vo chodake sirf mera rona dikhaya so us waqt studio audience ke sath mere sabhi paticipants dost bhi roye the
newayz ye sab batana jaruri tha kyuke aap meri buraiya kar rahe hai ye koi bhi kalakar sehan nahi kar sakata isaliye aapko ye likhana jaruri tha
aap mere eliminations se bohout khush hai vaise main bhi bahout khush hu lekin zpndagi main kabhi mile to jarur sabit karke dikhaunga ke main utna bura singer nahi hu
take care god bless.

Edited by shuas - 17 years ago
omkar.dandekar thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#9
Suhas, do u mean it was because of the editing we could not see the complete picture? Suhas, this clearly shows that you are a VERY VERY HUMBLE person. I TAKE ALL MY WORDS BACK ABOUT YOU. AND I REALLY WISH YOU ALL THE SUCCESS IN YOUR LIFE. I MEAN IT. AAGE BADHO, AUR BAHUT KAAM KARNA HAI AAPKO... AUR JAISE KE AMITDA KAHTE HAIN, "KISI BHI HAAL MEIN SUR KO MAT HILNE DO". I will pray hard for your SUCCESSFUL LIFE. 😊 Abhi Has Do, aur khush ho jaao 😉

p.s. One thing I would like to tell you Suhas; no one is enemy of anyone in K for Kishore. But if you see the quality of their singing, its really aweful. Presentation has given SOOOOO much importance than the singing. Why does people have to dance with all those choreography and all when its purely Singing Talent Hunt Show? Mind divert ho hi jaayega na??? Why dont these sony people understand this??? Look at most of the participants, they are so much busy in style marugiri??? Instead, concentrate on SUR, EXPRESSIONS, TAAL which is definitely DIRECTLY RELATED TO KISHOREDA...When someone is EXTREMELY good in SUR then he can go for StyleMaruGiri... Do u agree with me?
Edited by omkar.dandekar - 17 years ago
omkar.dandekar thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#10
Oh really Suhas? I did not see you anywhere else. Where did you sing apart from K for Kishore?

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".