NOVEL~*Hiding behind a Stranger*~THREAD 47-CHAPTER 52, TSR for 53 UPD - Page 19

Created

Last reply

Replies

1.5k

Views

48.5k

Users

31

Likes

10.2k

Frequent Posters

Testmytest thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago

Originally posted by: lashy


Nice time y'all must have had!🤗
Ma ka haat ka khaana for the young guy!

Yes! since Friday night that is what I have been doing!
He got to hand out with his high school friend, he goes to college in South Carolina, because of Florence hurricane he had few days off, so he was here.

lashy thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 6 years ago

Originally posted by: Testmytest



Lashy thank you so much for clearing my doubts! Love your explanation for each scene and you always have an answer as to why/who/when/what/where/which/how...

Thank you so much... that is so sweet of you. 🤗
Unfortunately, I cannot add all of these details in the chapters or they'd read like an over-elaborated text... so, I drop clues as to what might have happened behind the scenes and have to allow the readers to figure the rest out via circumstances/characters...
Here, I am able to answer anything you want to, though 🤗 and thank you for giving me the pleasure of being able to do so!

I did get some courage to pen down my thoughts, will post it in a day or two. Me travelling today. I couldn't function properly yesterday, AMK's face, the whip, the flogging, Heera's reaction when she finds out, the Shezaade was on my mind 😔

Oh MY... here's a big big hug to you dearie 🤗

Edited by lashy - 6 years ago
lashy thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 6 years ago

Originally posted by: Testmytest


She will be ok, let her take time to recover. I can imagine what she is going through, I myself had a hard time yesterday to focus on my daily routine. We are talking about her CS here, so it is hard for to keep her emotions in check.

>>>👍🏼 I understand da

Yes! since Friday night that is what I have been doing!
He got to hand out with his high school friend, he goes to college in South Carolina, because of Florence hurricane he had few days off, so he was here.

>>> Happy mommy!

daisydee425 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Networker 3 Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
Amazing updates
thanks for pm
Sandhya.A thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
The strength of an author's words lies in the impact it has on the readers. The collective shock, floods of tears, desperation, fury at the hands that whipped and pathos at the man that bled...Lana's rush into hibernation to cry her heart out ... ...all show the effectiveness of your writing Sahiba. ⭐️

You brought the dark and gloomy dungeons with its horrors and pains alive in this extremely effective chapter. Take a bow dear.🤗

The descent of the prince from a proud and prejudiced master with conscience in dilemma over his instincts and best judgement against his self importance to a deranged freak and a heartless tyrant has been beautifully described.

Loved certain descriptions and choice of words...

Instead, with every passing hour, the Shehzaade found himself losing a few more grains of peace

The threads of sanity were barely holding up - showing true signs of wearing out. What if those threads were to snap?

The voice of reason ...

When Akbar was around, you rarely suffered from such anxieties'

'Get rid of your ego... and get him out of this case... it's obvious... he spoke these lies because of his love for a girl - nothing beyond that. In the very least spare him for political reasons!


Versus The voice of the devil...

He CANNOT be irreplaceable! No one is indispensable' The Ustaad had served his purpose. He'd find another. Someone BETTER!

The picture of the Shehzade in dilemma was apt. 👏

STEP 1.

Enter the sly manipulative wicked deplorable despicable old bat wanting to shut any ray of reason or mercy to enter the Shehzaade's warring mind. Like Manthra feeding Kaikeyi the drops of poison of political insecurity that ended up destroying what was precious to her, the evil black devil in flowing white robes poisons the Shehzade with a lethal dose that kills his sense of justice and blinds him to the truth staring at his face.

1. Khan Sahib has been raising an army with the stashed up money.

2. His men get paid by the Shehzade but defy him on Khan Sahib's orders.

3. There is public support for Khan Sahib and his Sahiba and in comparison Shehzade is rumoured to be weak and indecisive.

Wah FS! Wah! Were you classmates with Manthra and Shakuni mama or were you their tutor?😡

STEP 2.

The Shehzade now wants to first prove to himself that he is not weak. Why else would he be coming to her quarters at that time? Probably to convince himself and his conscience that he was not wrong in putting her to death. To deride her for daring to rise in revolt against him, HIM the all powerful and being the cause of the downfall of her Ustaad.

But her natural defense and nascent innocence and humble stance combined with his own principles not to disrespect a respectable woman makes him grant her request and he comes back without spilling his fury and hatred on her. Now that makes him seem weaker in his own eyes.

'Why wasn't i able to be harsh! Am i really weak as FS said it is rumored? No, i am not. I will prove it."

STEP 3.

The poor guards who probably shared a joke and didn't notice his sudden entry...they seemed disrespectful to him and mocking at his weakness. I AM THE BOSS. And i will prove it. This is what you call - Arandavanukku irundathellam pei. (Jo dara hua hai, uske liye chaya bhi bhoot dikhtha hai.) When you wear red goggles everything appears in a shade of red.

The poor unsuspecting guards were doomed to darkness forever and would never know for what. ( What will you call that Rosejaan... how would their families feel... that is royalty.)

STEP 4.

The fury that stemmed from FS's poison and rekindled by his inability to refuse and insult Heera and fanned into a wildfire at the guards' seeming mockery was all directed to the unsuspecting Khan Sahib whose skin he ripped apart by the barbed whip and soul he ripped by his unfair and biased ego.

The whips...the whips...oh my...dear Sahiba...you made them so real that we felt the pain. The little by little shattering of Khan Sahib's spirit and body... the bloodied stone walls and the hardened jailors were shocked beyond belief at the Shehzaade's insanity. We are all but Khan Sahib's well wishers. Aapne tho hamara haal behaal kar diya.

The memories of being flogged in childhood...the very man who restored his self esteem and erased the pain of those scars, now tearing and ripping his self esteem again with a barbed whip and giving him more pain and scars...😭😭

Every drop of blood spilled will take away any remnants of loyalty AMK still possesses. The Shehzade has now given him valid and irrefutable reasons to consider the debt of devotion repaid.

Every drop of blood spilled has made the Shehzade fall in his own eyes. Instead of satiating his pride, they only made him feel worse.

Every drop of blood spilled has garnered a thousand drops of tears. Kya likhi hai aapne...👏

Again certain choice of words were very powerful...

His throat was stuck with the most painful lump he'd ever dealt with - for the stony wall staring him that instant appeared softer than the heart of his former-master.

Turn what would have otherwise been an unpleasant ordeal, into the most excruciating one of his young life.

Perspiration drenched the skin on his neck, while terror sponged out his life dry from within.

But like guilt on a dirty conscience, the blood stayed. Stuck in the nooks of his nails. Stuck between the webbing of his fingers. It just wouldn't go!

Excellent writing Authoress Sahiba. You have proved the power of the pen. How much pain it could cause...even more than the sword.

Now the Shehzade has crossed the limits of cruelty that he himself realises that the stains are indelible. I have always wondered at why he is the Shehzade and not the Shehenshah at the time of the story. Yes. He needs to be answerable to a higher authority. When the rebellion rises in favour of Heera by the Hindu majority, he will face the consequences of his madness. He will need Heera and AMK to help him. Fingers crossed.
Edited by Sandhya.A - 6 years ago
lashy thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 6 years ago

Originally posted by: melovesja

Lashy my heart was like stone ,stopped feeling anything with that barbric lashes that i dont get a single drop of tear, only pain of shahib and both of them condition.

I can understand, sweetie!🤗

At first i like prince fighting with ego but this farooq ...

Thanks dear... for appreciating that scene!

i want coldest but harder punishment for him then any other.
Ugh I wish so too... but... 😔
let me just be in the satisfaction that FS will enjoy no spot in Heaven!

Prince is totally parted between his emotion and ego.
This lashes hurts me more then anything. But for your writing you absulatly well written prince hafty ego and how effect of others ego brushing words effect that royal stoops low in others and his own eyes but still wants to cover up
Exactly... he's fallen in his own eyes... doesn't want to accept it...
That was what that last bit was about...

and as your poem Godess must be steering and aweak till his wounds heal.
I loved the way you saw with one sentence the fear of losing life of royal that at movment of curtain make him insecure.
Yes... Thanks for appreciating the 'curtain insecurity' scene!🤗 It was a one second scene, but showed a lot about his current state of mind!

Like tejraj's meeting with ks. Only hope of ray is tejrajs concious.
Exactly!👍🏼
Don't undermine the genius of the Ustaad though...

Edited by lashy - 6 years ago
lashy thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 6 years ago
Sandy Sandy Sandy... that waaasss amaaazzziii...n...g...

lashy thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 6 years ago

Originally posted by: daisydee425

Amazing updates
thanks for pm


Thank you 😳
lashy thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 6 years ago

Originally posted by: Bindu.

I don't think it was just to keep up his promise of treating her like a noble-woman ,though that's how he convinces himself or tries to convince.Nor it was ego because,his ego was satiated to an extent seeing Heera folding her hands and pleading him.

You have used the words 'natural defence' and 'nascent innocence' to describe what the shehzaade felt.So,I think he found her words and sentiments,genuine and not manipulative like the old fox said.

I think he was conflicted. When he saw her expressions, they seemed genuine. Once he stepped out, he wondered if she was manipulating him by her 'innocence'😊

Also,his extreme anger is for Khan Sahib but not Heera.

Anyway,whatever the situation might be,I feel he does completely believe in the love of AMK and Heera.So,he might not have been able to crush the prized gift she got from her husband.I remember you mentioning about shehzaade's love or am I confusing it with something else😕


So Bond feels that it is his belief in true love. 👍🏼 Alright... never struck me... that angle...


Originally posted by: binduprasad41



I guess...our little mind rule our body...whatever going on in our mind over power us.
First of all guards were not laughing at him...who dare to do that.
Shehzaade is famous for his cruel punishment before also...so why would mere guards take that risk. They were just doing time pass...talking and joking around.
They didn't have any idea shehzaade would came to punish some one by himself. So they were busy themselves forgetting everything around. They didn't notice his presence .


Farooq sahib words over power shehzaade mind...he seeing everything by Farooq words.
If we wanted to see positive...we see positivity everywhere but when your mind is full of negative than how can we see positive. This leads him to punish those guards...only to satisfy himself that he is powerful .
No one dare to mess with him.
This is exactly what Sandy's written in her review too!👍🏼

Shehzaade and heera angle...Ofcourse Farooq sahib did brilliant job to corrupt shehzaade mind...no matter what Farooq is best in his job...great manipulatar...who knows how to turn things in his favour.

Poison is in small amount or in big amount...it has same effect.
👏
If shehzaade didn't stopped by at Heera room...things were lot better...I guessed.

Now Heera knew shehzaade true nature...she knew how to approach him.
After all diplomacy is her benefit ...she used shehzaade own word's against him...but that doesn't mean shehzaade couldn't harm her but he didn't...why ?
Heera is noble woman...aura around her bound anyone to respect her...and she is pleading infront of him forgetting her pride ...her innocence affected him. He couldn't ignore her words...spoken by himself infront of everyone.
But in other note I guess shehzaade don't harm women unlike Khalil...after all his position doesn't allow him to do that.
Ofcourse here again shehzaade felt himself weak infront of Khan sahib and his begum.
If he allow that darogah to destroyed Khan sahib precious gift...it must satisfy his ego but he let that go which added more fire in his anger.
But in the end Khan sahib pay price by his own blood.

I am not saying that if shehzaade didn't met Heera before he not punished Khan sahib that way...Ofcourse he would punish him but not this way.

So Bindup says that Shehzaade felt weak because he ended up acknowledging her aura/innocence... his ego was affected by the fact that he let the lens go.. 👍🏼

Shehzaade made Khan sahib suffered in many way but still he stood strong ...mere guards didn't notice his presence which lead them to disrespect shehzaade unknowingly...Heera diplomatic approach...all this made situation worst...and all this made Farooq sahib words true in shehzaade sense...so yes if all this not happened...things were lot better for Khan sahib.

I hope you all understand what I am saying...😕

This is true. Like the many steps that built up to Karna's death, there were many steps that led to ultimately what Shehzaade did.

Had Shehzaade not been already suffering these visions and voices - thanks to a near-month of sleepless nights.
Had Farooq Sahib not spread an extremely potent poison.
Had he not stopped by Heera's room and ended up caving in to her wishes.
Had he not found the guards laughing.
Had AMK not appeared to strong/unbreakable when he saw him.

It would've all ended very differently😕



Edited by lashy - 6 years ago
lghosh thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 6 years ago

I am sorry for being out of action because I was stricken with grief and sorrow literally! I don't remember being enveloped in such distress and being so destitute since I watched Shakti' and Aakhree Raasta' and back then I was so tender and young! I was the one here who was whipped and lashed, my soul was scarred in depth, my spirit was bleeding in pain and trauma, my heart and body was feeling every flogs from the heartless, insensitive, boorish ruler!

Lashy, sorry but I couldn't read the last paragraph, no matter how much I tried and I will not read it, for the sake of my sanity! By the time I went to the third lash I zoned out and words became blur and I stopped! All I could see was the imagery of him chained with his arms stretched up to the ceiling and he facing his back to the monster hearing the metal clink of the whip and thinking to himself it is not the usual leather one and then the first whip and his beseeching voice and plead screaming and begging for the heartless and ruthless savage to hear him out but to no avail! That was it and I stopped! That image kept roaming in my mind and then Lashy's edit didn't help with that blood stain on the wall either!

I can be rough and tough on the front but I do have a faint heart I guess and I abhor such gory violence of any kind. When I read NJAPA and that insane chapter happened there too I shamelessly will say I skipped it, simply scanned over it and in my mind I had this fear lurking from the beginning which I never voiced that here in HBAS, I hoped this sort of violence of any sort would not happen (keeping my fingers crossed) but here I am seeing my love so barbarically and inhumanly tortured! The fear surfaced and shook me to the core with its content and our Author Sahiba's vivid linguistic extraordinaire!

I simply don't know how Heera will survive after knowing what KS has undergone and all because of her innocent ploy to seek justice for her sister's untimely and unjust demise in the hands a of a brutal general! How will she stay calm when she will see the distinct deep zigzags of scars on his back and all she will think with a lump in her throat that she is the cause of it all! No matter how she will physically and emotionally heal him it will haunt her insides to the core! Who and how will she heal herself from all this guilt?

I just read about Chittor example but sorry to say Chittor and this is not the same, it does not fall in the same category! With Akbar and his intentions, if you have read about him and his intentions in his biography, you will know it was a political move to bring all the Rajput kingdoms under his Mughal Empire and he did that deliberately to teach the Rajputs to surrender to him, to instill fear for political reasons. This here was a personal vendetta, a war fought with oneself to win over his ego! Akbar was much more intelligent and had a common sense prevailing in his head over his shoulders and he adhered to his advisers but always used his own judgment to finally decide with reason and logic but here what do we find? A man, a future emperor, the second most powerful man in the nation, caught between his alter ego and his conscience, a weakling because he succumbed to the wily ploys of FS in spite of knowing he was doing something gravely wrong, he was playing in to his hands and yet he did it willingly just to prove to his ego he is supreme!! No, it is not the same as Chittor! I can not equate him with the likes of Akbar! The only grace I will give him in this chapter is what you know, not the order to the Darogah to give the lens back to Heera but that in spite of seeing the idol of Ma Bhavani in Gauri's arms he didn't yank it away and throw it crushing to mere powder! That is the only and only good act of the Shehzade! Sorry all of his admirers, he did cross the line this time by leaps and bounds in the direction of Netherworld! And his punishing those guards proved it too how much he has lost himself to prove to the world to display his power and supremacy over the nation! The first edit shows him looking in to the Chakravyuh on the wall, with his fist in the center! He thinks he holds the center of this problem in his grip and it is in his power how he churns it out but what he doesn't know is he is caught himself in the center of the Chakravyuh and he doesn't know how to get out of it! Yes, in the end, his ego was the winner but in the war between his ego and conscience, what won? Ego gratified - yes but conscience gratified - definitely not! He is nothing but a weakling who allowed himself to be played by an evil wise fanatic and acted exactly how that evil wise old haggard planned and wanted him to! He played in to his hands like a pawn of a chess game! He is not fit to be the emperor who can rule the nation!


And I am not even done with FS yet!

Yes, we see and hear of such inhuman attacks even in today's world, then too I get upset and feel horrible but I move on because I am not personally invested in them. I don't care who suffered what and when and how it is normal to see such pain inflicted on others and by whom in the past!! All I know is it is AMK here we are talking about! Yes, I am seething in anger and pain and sorrow! I was enveloped in this fire of emotions and burnt in them for the past 2 days and no matter how much I try to forget that image lingers in m mind! Now after deliberate circumspection of looking and thinking it over that fire is burning within me now and I do not know how to douse it but with the blood of all the evil souls here specially FS and Shehzade! Yes, I am angry! I have not involved myself for almost 2 years on the characters whom I have grown to love, cherish, respect, admire, adore and dream about to see them writhing in pain! But here I am seeing and feeling it and it feels horrible when you see them in such harsh situation in so much of unbearable pain! All I could see is AMK bathed in blood with the whiplashing and his screaming in pain, he who bears all the pain with a clamped mouth is shrieking in pain this time!

Ok, there I go again! It becomes all blurry again! Sorry, will come back later! And I apologise sincerely if I have hurt anyone with my rantings! I am not myself today.

Edited by lghosh - 6 years ago

Related Topics

Jodha Akbar Thumbnail

Posted by: hemakeerti

4 months ago

FF: Pale Blue Dot Thread 6/19/2025 Chapter 44 Part2

Hemakeerti OSes - Compiled PBD INDEX Prologue Chapter 1 Chapter 2 Chapter 3 Chapter 4 Chapter 5 Chapter 6 Chapter 7 Chapter 8 Chapter 9 Chapter...

Expand ▼
Jodha Akbar Thumbnail

Posted by: Swissgerman

6 years ago

Jodha Akbar FF Who loves Him Most Chapter 78B updated on 08/07/2024

Jodha Akbar FF : --- Who loves Him Most (M) --- Link to my other threads Thread 1 Thread 2 - Thread 3 :::::Thread 4::::...

Expand ▼
Jodha Akbar Thumbnail

Posted by: Swissgerman

9 years ago

Jodha Akbar FF: Shahzada of Her Dreams Chapter 48 Updated 20/7/2025

... Shahzada Of Her Dreams ... ::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::Index::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::: Chapter-1.....The beginning Chapter-2:...

Expand ▼
Jodha Akbar Thumbnail

Posted by: Shinning_Stuti

5 years ago

Thread 3: Destined Love... (Chapter 61 updated)

Prologue: How it happens when both the hearts fall for each other madly without knowing each other? He is the emperor of the great Mughal...

Expand ▼
Jodha Akbar Thumbnail

Posted by: ParijatDeewani

2 months ago

Jodha Akbar Vm Thread

Hey y'all! I've created this thread so that you'll can easily access all the Akdha Vms in one place. Please feel free to add to the list. 1....

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".