journey of the serial from JA to MEA...

ghalibmirza thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#1
the show started off with mixture of background of jodha akbar the movie with the tadka of some historical facts showing Akbar's main wives and not just jodha, which was a pleasant surprise as not much is talked or read about akbar's private life!..rajat enacted very well the part of a confident, shrewd and intelligent emperor who is still in the budding stage of learning more and more..the influence of bairam khan and MA was beautifully shown and well enacted by the actors!..a big round of applause to the whole team of those golden initial episodes!

then once the influence of both his mentors was gone from his life he was shown acknowledging jodha's loyalty and honesty towards him, how much true it might have been historically but we cannot deny the fact that her family was very close to Akbar and served him with full honesty!..i was ok with subtle changes in akbar's personality but the way they were shown in the script were not convincing enough and disconnected..here ekta wanted to make akbar as one of his regular serial male characters who become saints after falling in love and that is where she faulted big time!..subtle changes but shown majestically would have been more welcoming than showing him weak and saintly which in reality was not the personality of this larger than life real life character!

up until the big leap jalal's character was still tolerable but once salim entered he was shown completely weak and clueless most of the times with jodha bringing him to senses, as if he would not have survived without her which is not believable and all his reforms were twisted in such a way that again the credit falsely was given to jodha and the end result of all these illogical tracks to show jodha on a pedestal were not convincing and not jiving with history word for word..!
whatever changes akbar bought to the society should have been shown in a more convincing way where the consultants could have been jodha and his 9 gems but he should have been shown wise enough to implement them in a way that looks logical and convincing in keeping with the aura of this larger than life personality!

the end result of it all is that akbar of recent episodes does not look like akbar and i cannot connect this reel character to real character on whose story the serial is based...i must say that akbar of initial episodes was convincing and had a powerful impact on me as a viewer..akbar of jodha akbar the movie was very convincing in showing the subtle changes that jodha bought to his personality as the maker made sure the the persona of akbar is not lost and here i would blame the maker of the serial who just for the sake of trps killed the real akbar's character!..and then came our akbar of mugha-e-azam who was not only powerful but very convincing in showing the larger than life picture and the true qualities of akbar the great who was secular and a just ruler!..and now i am dreading a weepy weak akbar that will be shown in the serial so that the female characters are highlighted..my request to the makers is if they are reading my post not to show akabr weak or a cry baby and again looking clueless until jodha shows the light of knowledge and path of salvation!

..and now jodha's character that was shown in both the movies was subtle yet strong..but the serial jodha as per my POV is dramatic and ott at times and i guess that is what the serials are made of, either they make someone too good or the other too bad but no gray normal human beings!..at the end i must say both rajat and paridhi do look like the characters only if the script was better and in accordance to their real historical characters!
Edited by ghalibmirza - 10 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

26

Views

2.3k

Users

10

Likes

64

Frequent Posters

jayaks02 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#2

Mandy

Akbar in the serial is as important as gatekeeper at Agra who is posted at Jaipur gate. 😆😆
The serial is about Naari Shakti who transformed a demon into a king and a puppy at the same time.
We NEED to applaud and celebrate this Nari Shakti. 😃
ghalibmirza thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: jayaks02

Mandy

Akbar in the serial is as important as gatekeeper at Agra who is posted at Jaipur gate. 😆😆
The serial is about Naari Shakti who transformed a demon into a king and a puppy at the same time.
We NEED to applaud and celebrate this Nari Shakti. 😃



jaya, sadly that is what majority viewers enjoy but showing akbar weak is also not going well with many viewers, they all want to see a bossy akbar with great strong qualities and not what makers have made out of him!
ghalibmirza thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#4
i honestly cannot recognize this weak akbar in fact i am ashamed to call him as akbar! and the whole blame is on the cvz!
Donjas thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#5
Nice analysis Mandy. Let us see what happens in this Mughal e Azam track. If we can't get a strong Akbar here, then we never will.

I expect to see a Akbar vs Salim clash with Jodha and the rest trying to mediate just like in the movie. The problem here is, our Akbar is so good an actor, he is going to blow Salim away. This is going to be a total mismatch and once again the dream of seeing a strong Akbar will remain just a dream, because the opposing side capitulates without a fight.
Edited by Donjas - 10 years ago
Sabdabhala thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#6


THE CHARACTER OF AKBAR HAS BEEN BUTCHERED BEYOND REDEMPTION


I DONT THINK ANYTHING THAT THE CVS NOW SHOW WILL CHANGE ANYTHING


THE FACT THE CVS WASTED CLOSE TO 50 EPISODES ON BLACK MAGIC IN A STORY ABOUT ONE OF THE GREATEST EMPERORS OF INDIA, TELLS US ABOUT THE CALLIBRE OF THE CVS


THERE IS NOTHING SHOWN ABOUT THE GROWTH OF THE KINGDOM, PATRONAGE OF THE ARTS, DEVELOPMENT OF THE AMAZING MUGHAL ARCHITECTURE, THE BRILLIANTLY STRATEGIZED AND EXECUTED WARS, THE IMPORTANCE OF THE NINE GEMS


WHAT STARTED OUT AS A SHOW WITH A WONDERFUL VISUAL APPEAL AND THE POTENTIAL TO REACH THE ZENITH OF TV HISTORICALS, IS NOW A TORCHER TO WATCH



YD.AH thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#7
very nice and logical post
this akbar is not at all akbar
he can be any one from the tv shows
he is just a namesake akbar
he had lost his identity after his consummation
now it is just a normal man with the name akbar
ghalibmirza thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: Donjas

Nice analysis Mandy. Let us see what happens in this Mughal e Azam track. If we can't get a strong Akbar here, then we never will.


I expect to see a Akbar vs Salim clash with Jodha and the rest trying to mediate just like in the movie. The problem here is, our Akbar is so good an actor, he is going to blow Salim away. This is going to be a total mismatch and once again the dream of seeing a strong Akbar will remain just a dream, because the opposing side capitulates without a fight.



donjas, i completely agree! i know we will never get to see the MEA effect but at least we can get to see something close and if the movie was a blockbuster then at least the track can be acceptable without showing just the woman power for a change!
ghalibmirza thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: Sabdabhala



THE CHARACTER OF AKBAR HAS BEEN BUTCHERED BEYOND REDEMPTION


I DONT THINK ANYTHING THAT THE CVS NOW SHOW WILL CHANGE ANYTHING


THE FACT THE CVS WASTED CLOSE TO 50 EPISODES ON BLACK MAGIC IN A STORY ABOUT ONE OF THE GREATEST EMPERORS OF INDIA, TELLS US ABOUT THE CALLIBRE OF THE CVS


THERE IS NOTHING SHOWN ABOUT THE GROWTH OF THE KINGDOM, PATRONAGE OF THE ARTS, DEVELOPMENT OF THE AMAZING MUGHAL ARCHITECTURE, THE BRILLIANTLY STRATEGIZED AND EXECUTED WARS, THE IMPORTANCE OF THE NINE GEMS


WHAT STARTED OUT AS A SHOW WITH A WONDERFUL VISUAL APPEAL AND THE POTENTIAL TO REACH THE ZENITH OF TV HISTORICALS, IS NOW A TORCHER TO WATCH





lavi that is the naked truth of the show and a sad situation of almost all the illogical serials just because mirch masala is more entertaining than the actual facts but what i believe is that if the actual facts are put together like a a beautiful pearl necklace then it too can attract but then that would require out of the box thinking and more intelligent and creative team of writers!
ghalibmirza thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: .chandni.

very nice and logical post

this akbar is not at all akbar
he can be any one from the tv shows
he is just a namesake akbar
he had lost his identity after his consummation
now it is just a normal man with the name akbar



chandni, i would have let go the serial if akbar was not exploited to this extent and talent of rajat not wasted in a magnum, opus which now is no more than a regular sbs crap..since they want to drag it more my request to the makers is to restore the dignity and aura of this larger than life character who once was one of the strongest rulers of the world and richest!

Related Topics

Jodha Akbar Thumbnail

Posted by: jmdd

9 months ago

Journey to His Heart

This is my first try, so please ignore any mistakes. I have no intention of hurting anyone with my writing. The characters in this story are the...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".