Poll

who's story is great?

Login To Vote
yurimehta11 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#1
So according to you which lovestory is great and epic
Jodha and Akbar who live together and create historyor Salim Anarkali
please judge according to story not acting

Always people remeber those lovers who died together

So my question is what is great living together and face hurdles of life or die together what is epic lovestory?
Edited by yurimehta11 - 10 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

22

Views

2.7k

Users

20

Likes

107

Frequent Posters

jiya.k thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#2
jis lovestory ki gawahi aaj bhi fatehpur sikri ka ek ek pathar deta ho usse kisi fictional lovestory se compare bhi kaise kar sakte hai toh dono me se konsi story epic hai yeh batana toh dur ki baat hai...
Tarunika13 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: jiya.k

jis lovestory ki gawahi aaj bhi fatehpur sikri ka ek ek pathar deta ho usse kisi fictional lovestory se compare bhi kaise kar sakte hai toh dono me se konsi story epic hai yeh batana toh dur ki baat hai...


Well said👏
pluviophile. thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 10 years ago
#4
Salim and Anarkali. It's kinda unfair to compare them, tho. Jodha-Akbar are the older generation of the show, while Salim-Anarkali, the newer generation.
ILTHBEB thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: jiya.k

jis lovestory ki gawahi aaj bhi fatehpur sikri ka ek ek pathar deta ho usse kisi fictional lovestory se compare bhi kaise kar sakte hai toh dono me se konsi story epic hai yeh batana toh dur ki baat hai...


jiya darling, 👍🏼
myviewprem thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#6
If a salim anarkali love story happened really then I would say great
because a prince ready to give up his throne and life for a common girl his lover and going against might of a Mughal army and emperor is in itself a mind boggling and unimaginable that requires lots of courage (any human should be a bit mad to do that in first place when he knows all odds are against him and his love)
and a common girl ready to die for her love rather than reject and fall in his eyes there is no true love than that in world
But I doubt such a great love story truly happen in reality and especially never in these money minded 21st century times
Regarding Jodha Akbar all Asian girls especially indian face some saas-bahu kind of dramas in marriage nothing new about it especially if they are from diff communities. Anyways the circumstance of JA marriage where bharamal just exchanged his daughter for his future and kingdom that itself is a big compromise and no compromise can have real love.
Edited by myviewprem - 10 years ago
ghalibmirza thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#7
yuri you have raised a good point! many love stories are epic because the lovers die for each other and then end of the story but in case of stories like real Akbar the great and hira kuwari we do not know the exact facts but it seems that they must have come out of the cultural and religious differences and eventually become each others strength by being a positive influence in each other's life..Akbar was close to HK's clan and that shows how much he trusted and felt close to them and the main link must have been HK's efforts for being a loyal wife! therefor i will go with the love story in which the two individuals actually live their life together and fight the hurdles together to come out as winners together at the end!
yurimehta11 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: ghalibmirza

yuri you have raised a good point! many love stories are epic because the lovers die for each other and then end of the story but in case of stories like real Akbar the great and hira kuwari we do not know the exact facts but it seems that they must have come out of the cultural and religious differences and eventually become each others strength by being a positive influence in each other's life..Akbar was close to HK's clan and that shows how much he trusted and felt close to them and the main link must have been HK's efforts for being a loyal wife! therefor i will go with the love story in which the two individuals actually live their life together and fight the hurdles together to come out as winners together at the end!

Mandy dear mere dil ki baat kah di tumne Now I get answer of my one question why real Akbar and Hk is not remebered as great lovers because they didnt die for each other They live together just think about the situation of HK women of Harem ready to die for attention of Akbar she doesnt know anything about her hubby culture neither she had google nor any supporter from inside. Akbar' harem doesnt lacks of pretty women but he find his beloved in Hk. Thousand of compromises and adjustment they must had done to comfoy with each other but this wasnt valued much because no one cares about adjustment much What they doesnt face together death of childs to rebellion of child.They was with each other for every thin and thick but its sad they didnt valued that much and I personally believes that EK didnt justice to there story. In my opinion destruction is always easy root but creation is tough root to follow and why people claim Akbar as villain of SA story just look at this from his perspective Aftermath of SA marriage Anar doesnt know anything of politics and royal mannerism soon people starting disobeying her. look at mindset of 16 century people dancer never respected in society at that time unlike today's world.so disobeying and avoiding her will be there. and what salim can do to restore her pride. honestly you cant get respect and love forcefully. Being a king and queen its necessary to be respected by your public look at the father who goes barefoot for this child to Ajmersharif and what he returned to his parents rebellion mana pyaar bhi jaroori hai par maa baap ke pyaar ka koi mol nahi Maa baap ka pyaar anmol hai I dont write anything to offend SA fans this is just my POV
myviewprem thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: yurimehta11

Mandy dear mere dil ki baat kah di tumne Now I get answer of my one question why real Akbar and Hk is not remebered as great lovers because they didnt die for each other They live together just think about the situation of HK women of Harem ready to die for attention of Akbar she doesnt know anything about her hubby culture neither she had google nor any supporter from inside. Akbar' harem doesnt lacks of pretty women but he find his beloved in Hk. Thousand of compromises and adjustment they must had done to comfoy with each other but this wasnt valued much because no one cares about adjustment much What they doesnt face together death of childs to rebellion of child.They was with each other for every thin and thick but its sad they didnt valued that much and I personally believes that EK didnt justice to there story. In my opinion destruction is always easy root but creation is tough root to follow and why people claim Akbar as villain of SA story just look at this from his perspective Aftermath of SA marriage Anar doesnt know anything of politics and royal mannerism soon people starting disobeying her. look at mindset of 16 century people dancer never respected in society at that time unlike today's world.so disobeying and avoiding her will be there. and what salim can do to restore her pride. honestly you cant get respect and love forcefully. Being a king and queen its necessary to be respected by your public look at the father who goes barefoot for this child to Ajmersharif and what he returned to his parents rebellion mana pyaar bhi jaroori hai par maa baap ke pyaar ka koi mol nahi Maa baap ka pyaar anmol hai I dont write anything to offend SA fans this is just my POV

Here I disagree that people do not respect a commoner as queen
Hamida bano was a commoner
Nur Jahan a widow commoner
Mumtaz Mahal a commoner
Rani Roopmati a commoner
Jhansi ki rani a commoner
Mastani a commoner
Did not Akbar himself marry commoners and widows or divorce? So how can he object to his sons marrying commoner or widows? Is this not double standard?
Look at current CMs/PMs majority commoner do we not respect
People value ability and post and not commoner or royal
So like others may be anarkali would learn too
Edited by myviewprem - 10 years ago
yurimehta11 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: myviewprem


</div>
<div>

</div>
<font size="2">Here I disagree that people do not respect a commoner as queen </font>


<font size="2">Hamida bano was a commoner </font>

<font size="2">Nur Jahan a widow commoner</font>

<font size="2">Mumtaz Mahal a commoner </font>

<font size="2">Rani Roopmati a commoner</font>

<font size="2">Jhansi ki rani a commoner</font>

<font size="2">Mastani a commoner</font>


<font size="2">Did not Akbar himself marry commoners and widows or divorce? So how can he object to his sons marrying commoner or widows? Is this not double standard?</font>


<font size="2">Look at current CMs/PMs majority commonerdo we not respect</font>


<font size="2">People value ability and post and not commoner or royal</font>

<font size="2">So like others may be anarkali would learn too</font>



<div>


Anarkali was a dancer not a
normal commoner prem
I am not against commners but standard of that time for dancers is like
raja ka beta hoke naachnewali se shaadi kar li
ab ek naachne wali hamari rani banegi
its hard to digest for normal people
all people you mentioned above are just commoner not dancers that is my point correct me if I am wrong


and regarding this series Jalal was ready to marry dancer benzir so Ill love to watch


how cvs will justify his action against SA marriage and what grounds they will use?
Edited by yurimehta11 - 10 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".