JA downfall - Page 6

Created

Last reply

Replies

284

Views

21.8k

Users

28

Likes

738

Frequent Posters

SindhuMenon thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#51

Originally posted by: elasingh


Jodha Akbar is now a sinking ship...Nothing can save it from sinking ...The trps are telling..Serial went wrong when it deviated from history and became harem centric..There was a limit to the crimes committed by Ruku..Her asking to share kids of Jodha was very very ugly and as if it was not enough Jalal ended up punishing Jodha for their death...That was the last nail in coffin...Since then JA has lost its no 2/3 position and has never regained it and never will...

Then they showed Ruk giving opium to a kid who called her ammijan...That was deplorable act...Worse Zee and EK did not get Ruk punished for it..That was very very unethical of Zee and JA team...Is it so easy to quit opium without medical care? Anyway now the only route left to Zee is to take leaps after leaps as they have decided to skip history which was backbone of any historical serial...They should never have taken this serial if they had no resaerch work done for it..

Instead of doing research JA team showed us a cheap copy of Jahangirnama and said they are showing the truth..Anyway now it is clear to all of us that since the begining they were following Indu Sudarshan's novel "twentieth wife" ...It was an easy route..But do they know that novel is total fiction...

Historical serials should be made after doing a lot of research and love for history...JA has none..Jalal only shouts and screams and till today has never managed to catch a real culprit...and Jodha is just a crying mother who is always so careless that anybody can turn her child against her...The leads have been butchered mercilessly to save Ruk, the only villain left in the show...


Anyway nothing can save JA now and after this leap it will be SA after some episodes...Zee plz never ever make historicals as you don't have the calibre


It is the only historical show which has no history in it...



well said Ela...cant agree more..Even if its going to be SA, not sure if viewers will accept this. We all are so attached to Akdha, cant imagine someone replacing them here and going to be given focus.

Now I strongly feel this show will at least end by summer..
Edited by SindhuMenon - 10 years ago
Rak014 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#52

Originally posted by: SindhuMenon



well said Ela...cant agree more..Even if its going to be SA, not sure if viewers will accept this. We all are so attached to Akdha, cant imagine someone replacing them here and going to be given focus.

Now I strongly feel this show will at least end by summer..


The worst part is Sindhu, I dont think Ekta will end it any time soon!
It will eun for atleast 2-3 more years. They drag will like a rubber. be it a historical show, or fictional, what matters is, it is Ekta's!😆
Rak014 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#53

Originally posted by: elasingh


Jodha Akbar is now a sinking ship...Nothing can save it from sinking ...The trps are telling..Serial went wrong when it deviated from history and became harem centric..There was a limit to the crimes committed by Ruku..Her asking to share kids of Jodha was very very ugly and as if it was not enough Jalal ended up punishing Jodha for their death...That was the last nail in coffin...Since then JA has lost its no 2/3 position and has never regained it and never will...

Then they showed Ruk giving opium to a kid who called her ammijan...That was deplorable act...Worse Zee and EK did not get Ruk punished for it..That was very very unethical of Zee and JA team...Is it so easy to quit opium without medical care? Anyway now the only route left to Zee is to take leaps after leaps as they have decided to skip history which was backbone of any historical serial...They should never have taken this serial if they had no resaerch work done for it..

Instead of doing research JA team showed us a cheap copy of Jahangirnama and said they are showing the truth..Anyway now it is clear to all of us that since the begining they were following Indu Sudarshan's novel "twentieth wife" ...It was an easy route..But do they know that novel is total fiction...

Historical serials should be made after doing a lot of research and love for history...JA has none..Jalal only shouts and screams and till today has never managed to catch a real culprit...and Jodha is just a crying mother who is always so careless that anybody can turn her child against her...The leads have been butchered mercilessly to save Ruk, the only villain left in the show...


Anyway nothing can save JA now and after this leap it will be SA after some episodes...Zee plz never ever make historicals as you don't have the calibre


It is the only historical show which has no history in it...


@bold, huh?😲😲
I didnt know this!😕😕
BTW, should one submit proofs on their historical researches before starting a serail?
SindhuMenon thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#54

Originally posted by: Rak014


The worst part is Sindhu, I dont think Ekta will end it any time soon!
It will eun for atleast 2-3 more years. They drag will like a rubber. be it a historical show, or fictional, what matters is, it is Ekta's!😆



@bold: oh really. then I think CVS and Ekta may watch it..rest will leave ..😆
Sweet24 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#55

Originally posted by: elasingh

JA has fallen in Trp again...Last week's trp is 3.3 compared to previous week's 3.5...The reason for it is that again Ruk escaped by killing Resham...and burrying the proof against her...It is not just that forum members are against Ruk but all over fans of JA have become fed up of the negativity she brings to JA..



JA has not been able to sustain its position post H and H's death...The reason for it has been majourily Ruk who was the obvious culprit but didn't get punished...Things started going wrong for JA since ugly child sharing track...It was sick and disgusting...


The more writers have tried to save Ruk the more serial has fallen...Let them ruin the serial in the name of NR...We do not care..



From Monday onwards we r moving to our next show on life ok, I have already plan now to left it permanently.

I will read written updates of u all, and slowly slowly I will left this show. This is the best way to leaving a habbit of the show.

I love my thoughts, my selfrespect more than anything else. If I am not liking this rukaiya , I will surely left means left.
I am not believing in tolerating her nonsense anymore. I don't have that patience, and don't want to spoil my mood everyday when I came from office and sit in front of TV to get relax.
U don't know but what kind of feeling I got when i see, how she is hurting a small kid, seeing a kid we get a special feeling to love them. But its painful to watch now, I get angry now.


I have started hating her character so much,

edited -JA DT
Edited by -RD- - 10 years ago
taaniroyal thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#56
yes agree with you...
because of Ruku everyone fed up with this show...
Rashmi81 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#57
The new layout is not so good .😕
SindhuMenon thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#58

Originally posted by: Rashmi81

The new layout is not so good .😕



Probably the font size could have been smaller . but some options I am loving. like under each post now its easy to get into buddy list, PM etc. its more flexible nah..😉
ghalibmirza thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#59
ela tu chahe mujhe ignore kar ya laat maar i will still comment😆..ela if they had strictly gone as per history then this show would have been something else!..i wanted the show to be like siyaasat presentation wise..as i hate ott stuff and ekta's cliched copy paste stuff!..i am up for reality cinema and more of artsy types and the likes of siyaasat..ZGH..and many old pakistani shows offer it..even some of our old indian shows were class apart!..saans is one of my favorites.. but JA would have been something else if given proper treatment and how i wish it was kept short and good and in resonance with historical facts and presented in such a way that every character leaves an unforgettable mark..and as of now i cannot see the real jalal jodha or even ruk as they were in history and leave a confused and disgusted impression!..the impression of real ruk is more clear in siyaasat as it makes total sense since the characterization is such!
elasingh thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#60

Originally posted by: Rak014


@bold, huh?😲😲
I didnt know this!😕😕
BTW, should one submit proofs on their historical researches before starting a serail?

Its a good idea...Producers should submit proofs before making historicals..

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".