Maham Anga : A Classic Case of MPD - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

21

Views

2.5k

Users

11

Likes

94

Frequent Posters

myviewprem thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#11

Originally posted by: prav2

Nice post kushi ...

But i wonder if there was ever a jalal's mom or for that matter if there was ever a mom in her... she for sure she loved the concept of being jalal's mom..
Adham could never meet up her high standards of how a son should be a("A class apart from others) Jalal was always an envision of how a son should be for her and that's y the extra guilt she carried till to date that she loved ja;al more " Bari ammi" is a Status Symbol for her a matter of highest pride ... and till the date when jalal fits her envision ,she was controlling adham and the day she realized jalal is slowly changing and not completely fitting her bill ,she immediatedly wanted adham to take that place ...

and when all is lost instead of feeling remorse she is still blaming the shenshah for all that and now wants to meet the son jalal ... so for me she is one of those people who would never understand what love is and without love how could she be a mom ever?

Badi ammi is truly status symbol
Edited by myviewprem - 11 years ago
Khushi_love thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#12
Is it possible that MA is a victim of OCD...

Here is one way to think about MA having OCD :

Her mind got stuck on the thought or image of Adham on the throne.

Then this thought or image got replayed in her mind over and over again till she developed OCD for it...

...I presume that a patient with OCD is obsessed with an idea to such an extent that all his major relationships/activities of daily life get affected...here, MA's OCD for the throne for Adham made her disregard her affection for Jalal, gradually turning it into resentment...n her mind also found justifications for her blatant treason...

Khushi_love thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#13

Originally posted by: adianasr



Aap baja farmati hain Khushi Begum - this is Jalal's Mom wanting to rest in peace that Adham's Mom has been forgiven and Jalal's Mom thus gets her redemption...
and Khushi only a son like Jalal has the capacity to take the pain of both the mothers and heal them...
and now that the cry for the son has reached him, he will come for the mothers...
this is the journey to show how selfless a child can be... a beautiful journey for all those children who are selfless even when parents get self-serving - Sands is so right when she says that HB must have done punya by the truck loads in all her past births to get such a child !!!!!!


Adi...sometimes you are sheer poetry when describing Jalal's emotions..👏

...I wish I could collect your writing & store them somewhere to re read them sometime in the future...but alas!...am too lazy for such things...
Khushi_love thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#14

Originally posted by: rpeez

There was one more personality, Wazir-e-Aliya.

This one resented anyone getting more than her, and led to Bairam Khan's downfall as well as Ruqaiyya's MC...😒


Yes Raksha...if it was MPD, Wazire Aliya would be another one...but I think I agree with Donjas & Cleo, that MA's case is probably not actually MPD...
Khushi_love thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#15

Originally posted by: myviewprem

Maham has many personalities in her

1) Adham's mom
2) Jalal's mom
3) Hamida's competitor for Jalal love
4) Ruqaiah's scheming mother-in-law(how she made jalla scold her in DEK)
5) Rajvanshi hater for Jodha
6) Jealous parent competing with BK for jalal's attention
etc etc there are more I shall skip them
Basically after Aurangzeb she takes the medal for most scheming person in mughals of all time, third is nur jahan, fourth Mah chu chuk


MA is basically an overly oppurtunistic, manipulative, power hungry, evil woman, who can cross any boundaries to reach her goal...n here her goal was the throne for Adham...her various avatars, have this single goal, if you introspect closely...
Khushi_love thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#16

Originally posted by: rima4ever

she is jalals mom now


Yes Rima...right now, she's only Jalal's mom...n the loving son will definitely go to meet his mother...how can he not??😭
Khushi_love thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#17

Originally posted by: prav2

Nice post kushi ...

But i wonder if there was ever a jalal's mom or for that matter if there was ever a mom in her... she for sure she loved the concept of being jalal's mom..
Adham could never meet up her high standards of how a son should be a("A class apart from others) Jalal was always an envision of how a son should be for her and that's y the extra guilt she carried till to date that she loved ja;al more " Bari ammi" is a Status Symbol for her a matter of highest pride ... and till the date when jalal fits her envision ,she was controlling adham and the day she realized jalal is slowly changing and not completely fitting her bill ,she immediatedly wanted adham to take that place ...

and when all is lost instead of feeling remorse she is still blaming the shenshah for all that and now wants to meet the son jalal ... so for me she is one of those people who would never understand what love is and without love how could she be a mom ever?


What you are saying is making a lot of sense, esp bold underlined...she was in love with the idea of being the emperor's mom, just the way Ruqu is obsessed with the idea of being MUZ 😆




Khushi_love thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#18

Originally posted by: mandyg

khushi, a good take on jalal's mom versus adham's mom..adham was lahoo ka putra and jalal was doodh ka putra..initially she might have taken good care of jalal as she knew he will be the future king and she will have her control over him and by keeping him in control she will have adham's future secure..ek teer se do nishaane..but while bringing jalal up she developed that soft corner for him as a son..just like when u keep a pet u feel sad when the pet dies..and here after adham died she herself died completely but towards the end she did realize that adham too was wrong somewhere and that she too was at fault..but that love for a pet whom she raised surfaced and wanted to see the one that she cared before dying!..but if adham would have killed jalal she would not have felt so bad and would not have died like this..but jalal on the other hand will feel shattered as this was the mother he knew and she was with him during his most tender days and she was the one with him holding his hand when he took his very first baby step!..and i am feeling more bad for jalal than for maham!


Mandy, I m only feeling bad for Jalal...

MA only deserves pity, IMO...nothing more, from me at least...😊
harrybird thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#19



Brilliant Analysis Khushi ! 👏

Jalal's Mom Vs Adam's Mom ! How beautifully you have brought out the conflicting emotions of MA ! 👍🏼

Today is MA's Swan Song - Final Part !

My heart goes out for Jalal & not MA for she has got more than what she deserved. Ashwini has immortalised the character of Mahamanga & Bcos of Ashwini, MA character got glorified to this extent !

Looking forward to MA's final journey & the awesome acting duo RT & Ashwini together ! 😊


Khushi_love thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#20

Originally posted by: harrybird




Brilliant Analysis Khushi ! 👏

Jalal's Mom Vs Adam's Mom ! How beautifully you have brought out the conflicting emotions of MA ! 👍🏼

Today is MA's Swan Song - Final Part !

My heart goes out for Jalal & not MA for she has got more than what she deserved. Ashwini has immortalised the character of Mahamanga & Bcos of Ashwini, MA character got glorified to this extent !

Looking forward to MA's final journey & the awesome acting duo RT & Ashwini together ! 😊



Yes Anjali...my heart too, goes out for Jalal only...if I cry today, it will only be for Jalal...though so far, I have never ever cried during a film or show in my entire life...I may have gotten moved a great deal on many occasions, but cry, never...😆

But y do I think my record may break today??😭

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".