preparation for war-DT NT Pg25 - Page 26

Created

Last reply

Replies

291

Views

17.2k

Users

37

Likes

798

Frequent Posters

elasingh thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: adianasr



Absolutely Ela. Dramatization and NR is fine - infact history is a linear narrative of events and each one of us can interpret each event in our own way, based on our own life experiences, cultural, social, geographical, gender and other backgrounds, and this interpretation forms the meat and flesh on the bones of this linear narrative - and this fleshing out has to incorporate these protocols.

This show could have been done so beautifully and it could have created benchmarks and still made the numbers!!! Such a waste!!!! Dil jalta hai yeh soch kar 😡


Ela here is a NR on the childhood days of Akbar written as a story for kids -

You all shd read this book, attaching link here (click on 'read the book online' or u can even download)-




This is a story based on the childhood years of Akbar when Humayun and Hamida had to leave him with Humayun's brothers at Kandahar - This is dramatization as in Natakiya Rupanter - not the rubbish EK and Zee are determined to dish out.

Adiansar thank you...I am going to read it for sure...
Rashmi81 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: elasingh

Plz friends call zee...

Ela,
I was talking to my mother-in-law who nowadays is attending a lecture series on Maharana Pratap by a historian called Charudutta Aphale.She told me That the historician told Rajput women used to use this Mirchi Powder tactics many times to save themselves from enemy.
munni_rajatfan thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
hey ela, really a very interesting discussion is going on. i want to share sumthing which i had posted in another thread;
things could have been shown in a simple yet in a balanced way. CVs could have shown tht jalal went to war & before tht he made sure tht todermal immediately shifts the whole harem into the surang made if any danger comes. but since adham & maham know about tht secret surang sumhow maham would have informed nigar about it. & then nigar comes there with an army while jalal is fighting bravely on the battlefield. so there jalal & co. defeats abul mali & army & on the other hand jodha, todermal & other begums fight & defeat nigar & army & also imprisons nigar. later when jalal comes back both jalal jodha sumhow find chand begum & thus maham's secret is out. in this way both jalal & jodha fight their war bravely, noone is degraded to glorify the other. in this way each nd evry fan would have been happy. jalal can go wrong, he can commit mistakes bcoz the show itself is about different shades of jalal but either gud or bad, he cant be shown a fool.
Edited by munnirony - 11 years ago
Sandhya.A thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: elasingh

If they show this track and if Jallu didn't survive then what will happen to sultanate? CanRahim really survive as an emperor? What is the use of capturing AM, Shenu and MC if Jallu is dead?


EXACTLY. ... ..Isn't Jalal more important to the Sultanate than the capture of the bhaagis?

Adi
If this was Jalal's strategy, then this is no strategy but sheer id***y.
adiana12 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: Sandhya.A


EXACTLY. ... ..Isn't Jalal more important to the Sultanate than the capture of the bhaagis?

Adi
If this was Jalal's strategy, then this is no strategy but sheer id***y.



Sands I have called this the stupidest, most idiotic track of heroisation of Jalal - I know all will agree with me on this!!!!

This is not idiocy, it is criminal from the pov of the Sultanate!!!!
AKT.JA thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
@adianasr

I like your theory with a couple reservations:

First, it is highly unlikely that our CVs have come up with anything so creative. 😊

Second, rather than a trial of all 3 baghis, it is more likely that AM will run away; as you well know, EK likes to have villains hanging around forever. Munim will move against MC but, as in history, will make mistakes (possibly out of anger over his son's murder) and lose, so that part will end in stalemate. Probably HM will be taken captive and his brainwashing will begin.

But why are we wasting out collective intellect, when we know that something far simpler and stupider is likely to be shown?!

Agree with all of you that from the moment he took off his helmet in the middle of the battle, to following AM out of battle-field, to accompanying Shenu into that dark cave, this was Jalal at his lowest intelligence ever. If something like this happened in a real war, there would be six arrows in his head before he could say "hello" to AM, and his army would collapse and run away.

Edited by AKT.JA - 11 years ago
ghalibmirza thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: AKT.JA

@adianasr


I like your theory with a couple reservations:

First, it is highly unlikely that our CVs have come up with anything so creative.

Second, rather than a trial of all 3 baghis, it lis more likely that AM will run away. Munim will move against MC but, as is recorded history, will make mistakes (possibly out of anger over his son's murder) and lose, so that part will end in stalemate to be resolved another day. Probably HM will be taken captive and his brainwashing will begin.

But why are we wasting out collective intellect, when we know that something far simpler and stupider is likely to be shown?

Agree with all of you that from the moment he took off his helmet in the middle of the battle, to following AM out of battle-field, to following Shenu into that dark cave, this was Jalal at his lowest intelligence ever. If something like this happened in a real war, there would be six arrows in his head before he could say "hello" to AM, and his army would collapse and run away.



😆..loved the last part!
adiana12 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: AKT.JA

@adianasr


I like your theory with a couple reservations:

First, it is highly unlikely that our CVs have come up with anything so creative. 😊

Second, rather than a trial of all 3 baghis, it lis more likely that AM will run away; as you well know, EK likes to have villains hanging around forever. Munim will move against MC but, as in history, will make mistakes (possibly out of anger over his son's murder) and lose, so that part will end in stalemate. Probably HM will be taken captive and his brainwashing will begin.

But why are we wasting out collective intellect, when we know that something far simpler and stupider is likely to be shown?!

Agree with all of you that from the moment he took off his helmet in the middle of the battle, to following AM out of battle-field, to accompanying Shenu into that dark cave, this was Jalal at his lowest intelligence ever. If something like this happened in a real war, there would be six arrows in his head before he could say "hello" to AM, and his army would collapse and run away.



My dear, my theory and my premise could never be called creative 😳 - it is the most foolish and illogical theory and premise ever 😆 - and that is why I put it together as a likely account of what we will see!!!!! 😆
ghalibmirza thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
all i can say is ekta ke natkiye rupantar ki jai🥱
elasingh thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
Zee said that jalal is going to come out in this track as a very intelligent and shrewed emperor

Related Topics

Jodha Akbar thumbnail

Posted by: talesmith · 3 months ago

Hi all! Some of you may know me already or maybe not - I had posted a modern OS named Serendipity on this forum some months ago. Here again with...

Expand â–¼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".