Jodha Akbar: A few novel ideas? - Page 2

Originally posted by: ThorinMcBroody

awesome divya... mixing and matching two of my fav things in this world... p&p and JA... 😳
yep... I'm right there in that corner of the room housing P&P fanatics... 😆 *croons in michael Jackson's voice* you are not alone, I am here with you... in the room that is... 😆
I do have a few ideas of JA with some other books... will definetely share later tonight... headache wala busy day today... but a teaser... a bit of jane eyre... a bit of Sherlock holmes... 😆 😆

Originally posted by: lashy

No dear I'm referring to the dialogue.. I said letter by mistake.. I haven't read P and P you see.. though have an idea of the story... 😳

Originally posted by: sunshine_sun

Pls tell me how do u know we r the fans of pride n prejudice ...😆
I read this book long time back(it ws thick book indeed which thoroughly kept me on edges) n still i cudnt overcome it 😆.
The line Mr bingley said "miss elizebeth is the most agreeable woman indeed, to which MR Darcy answered "she is not handsome enuf to tempt me "😆 WOW !! i remember one scene abdul says to jalal y dont u get her n he answered "uski aaukaat badh jayengi .it sunded very much familiar ...

Shivani elopement matches with lydia wickham truely said 👏. Mr Darcy says "u shud know , shud know that i have done all this for u " believe di i fainted wen he said this line ...☺️
Di i watched this novel as a movie as of now 3 times n intend to watch it again n again 😳

As Shyamla Aunty said jo has been protrayed shallow so she doesnt come close to elizabeth ..she introspects herself ,retropects herself too but we cant expects such things from our heroine 😭

Originally posted by: Sandhya.A

No use copying the dialogues when the essence of the scene is lost, when the intensity and feel is completely missing.

Divi,

There is a huge difference between Lydia Wickham elopement and Shivaani Tejwant elopement.

Lydia did'nt elope leaving anyone waiting at the altar and disgrace anyone but her self. Also Darcy felt morally responsible as he didn't expose Wickham earlier. Hence he made amends, that too discretely. Not accept it so openly as though running away was the right thing to do.

Again Darcy praises Lizzy for changing him just once that too matter of factly. Not like a bhakt chanting his favourite mantra. Also Lizzy could be given the credit for changing him. But here Jo was the one who needed to be changed. So the credit Sounds jarring. So while the former Sounds gallant the latter sounds Sickening

There is no comparing Elizabeth and Jo. while Elizabeth admits to her faults her preJudice and ponders over how wrong she was too, our Jodha Begum is above anything wrong and is ever right. Even in the last episode she was totally Convinced that she was fully right in pulling the gunpowder out of the rifle as she did it to save the 'Niraparadh'😡

If at all the CVs intended to lift from P&P even the framework or basic idea, the net result looks like medicore imitation jewelry.

Originally posted by: varshaakulkarni

Bingo divya ... me too fan of Jane Austen 🤗... watched the movies & read her books ... though I dont remember the dialogues as u do 😆 ... but I love sense & sensibility ... the most fav of mine ... my most fav character among dashwood sisters is elinor truly a perfect sister in everyway ... & marianne a chirpy , naive & romantic in nature ...

I some how feel colonel brandons character (I knw colonel brandon is a bit old ) is similiar to mirza hakim as portrayed in the show ... mirza though very young is shown so matured & composed after the shivani incident ... he handled the fiasco so well mannerly ...

Originally posted by: Sandhya.A

No use copying the dialogues when the essence of the scene is lost, when the intensity and feel is completely missing.

Agrees, but it is obvious they refer to books to script scenes so might as well give them relevant ones to look at

Divi,

There is a huge difference between Lydia Wickham elopement and Shivaani Tejwant elopement.

Lydia did'nt elope leaving anyone waiting at the altar and disgrace anyone but her self. Also Darcy felt morally responsible as he didn't expose Wickham earlier. Hence he made amends, that too discretely. Not accept it so openly as though running away was the right thing to do.

Agreed the execution was poor - but again it was more the concept of a sister's elopement and the role in the love story ...

Again Darcy praises Lizzy for changing him just once that too matter of factly. Not like a bhakt chanting his favourite mantra. Also Lizzy could be given the credit for changing him. But here Jo was the one who needed to be changed. So the credit Sounds jarring. So while the former Sounds gallant the latter sounds Sickening

Maybe the CVs hit copy and paste multiple times by mistake 😆... I always felt Darcy was a bit emphatic there .. But yes, Jalal is too emphatic multiple times

There is no comparing Elizabeth and Jo. while Elizabeth admits to her faults her preJudice and ponders over how wrong she was too, our Jodha Begum is above anything wrong and is ever right. Even in the last episode she was totally Convinced that she was fully right in pulling the gunpowder out of the rifle as she did it to save the 'Niraparadh'😡

I am not comparing Liz with Jo at all ... Except the starting point of prejudice was the same ... Then there was no reflection, retrospection, or progress since

If at all the CVs intended to lift from P&P even the framework or basic idea, the net result looks like medicore imitation jewelry.

I think if anything they steal scenes and ideas ... And the result is imitation jewerly