Emotions versus Practicality!-DT NOTE Pg 15 - Page 7

Originally posted by: SindhuMenon

Each Begums were right in their own place. I cannot however agree with Ruks because her intentions are not good. So for me she is ruled out.

Lets's see what would have happened if Rahim was in Shehanaaz's place. He would have been forgiven same as How Jalal did not even brink up Ruks involvement in Murti Kand issue and Sujamal Track. He was able to forgive them easily.

Salima made a good point. Jodha is attached to Shehannaz emotionally. However for now we know Shehannaz is a vamp. I still believe she will not harm Jodha and Jalal. Lets see.

whatever the case maybe i think jalal's decision should be more practical than entirely emotional especially when someone's life is at stake and i agree with him that one cannot wait until something bad happens precautionary measures should be taken before hand!

Originally posted by: rpeez

Hi Mandy, in case of Jalaal, I felt he took a good decision, Agra maybe a a big palace with many guards, but, that doesn't mean that anyone can drop in and live there blissfully. I am not trying to be a heartless person, but, keeping a mentally unsound person can be dangerous, both for the people (like it happened with Rahim), and herself (given the letchers like Shareef, Adham). It would have been better for her to be sent back to Mathura Ashram, where she could be treated, or at least provided with a safe environment.

i completely agree on that how can anyone from outside go inside without being thoroughly checked, not even jodha had the right to do that without jalal's permission..again a blooper on cvz part!..they think that what does trp janta know about such details..ghussa do kuch bhi!

Originally posted by: fatma201

I think those supporting Salima and Jodhas suggestions dont have children. Rahim could have died if Jalal didnt take fast action.

What guarantee can Salima and Jodha give the same thing or worse wont happen again lets say if she was real mad?

yes, fatma, i do not see the logic in their argument!

Originally posted by: happygolucky099

it is great to be back🤗


the show has really lost its charm di

now even akdha scenes are boring like hell🥱


i like star show more these dayz😭

i agree, but do visit the forum at times we all miss u🤗

Originally posted by: mishtidoi

If it was old Jalal, he would've simply packed off Shehnaaz first and just informed Jodha...but since it is not so, and he knows Shehnaaz is with Jodha...he's holding a meeting, and all his Begums know, who'll be in the eye of storm, so all three brace up in their own possible way...but I know nothing logical is gonna happen...still I hope that after this incidence Jodha ask Moti or Moti takes an initiative to be closer, around or keep an eye on Shenu baby...

But vachan can't be and won't be broken...after all Jodha gave vachan to be with Shehnaaz in this life and not in later's afterlife 😉

Didnt Jodha learn a lesson of keeping a vachan which almost broke her marriage? Does keeping a vachan justify everything? So now her other vachan will almost cost their lifes. 😡

Originally posted by: mandyg

yes, fatma, i do not see the logic in their argument!

The problem with discussions on the forum, if a member is a fan of Jalal or Jodha then they support whatever he/she does even if they are wrong or illogical.

I think one should be able to praise and also critisize them according to how the character is portrayed in the show. Critisizing your fans actions doesnt mean that you hate them but it shows you are intelligent enough not to be a blind hardcore fan.

Originally posted by: fatma201

Didnt Jodha learn a lesson of keeping a vachan which almost broke her marriage? Does keeping a vachan justify everything? So now her other vachan will almost cost their lifes. 😡

Honestly only jalal was right in this case. Nd should have send shehnaaz to mathura. I agree jodha is emotionally attached with shehnaaz but evrything cant be based on emotions. Jalal pardoned adham many times just bcoz of his emotions towards maham. So do we support tht? No bcoz thts wrong. Here rahim's life was in danger. So strong steps should be taken about shehnaaz. If shehnaaz is a kid then also she should have been scolded strictly. But prob is jalal is still in his guilt mode nd salima simply emotionally blackmailed jalal. If she really wanted to be a peacemaker she should have gone to jodha nd tried to explain her why jalal reacted. Wht if it was sum other kid in place of rahim ? Can salima give the same argument to tht other kid's parents? Regarding jodha's feelings for shehnaaz jalal wasn't punishing shehnaaz he was just sending her back for her treatment. Nd besides jodha's dialogue "bacho k sath to ye hota rehta hain" was really careless. Its time the CVs should show jalal taking his own decisions. Not get influenced by anyone even if its jodha, salima or HB. Just like wht he did in tasneem case. He gave the case to maham, heard her views but in the end he did wht he wanted to do.

Originally posted by: SindhuMenon

Each Begums were right in their own place. I cannot however agree with Ruks because her intentions are not good. So for me she is ruled out.

Lets's see what would have happened if Rahim was in Shehanaaz's place. He would have been forgiven same as How Jalal did not even brink up Ruks involvement in Murti Kand issue and Sujamal Track. He was able to forgive them easily.

Salima made a good point. Jodha is attached to Shehannaz emotionally. However for now we know Shehannaz is a vamp. I still believe she will not harm Jodha and Jalal. Lets see.

Originally posted by: Shweta16

NO lessons learned ! In fact I think Jodha was ready to pack Shehnaz's bag once she thought its Jalal's ultimate decision. Do you guys think Shehnaz will die in the end ? cuz I don't think so 😉 ...No villain dies in this show 😆 hence Jodha begum's vachan is going to break ultimately. If in history MA din't die after Adham's death then Ekta would have kept Ashwini as the senior vamp till the end of this show.

How could Jodha give a vachan of having Shehnaz with her without first consulting her husband? In 21st century a wife cant invite a friend for lunch without first talking to his husband. So how could a wife of 16th century bring a woman to live with them without first consulting him?

Lets say Jalal had refused to have Shehnaz in Agra, what would Jodha have done?
Why should Jalal agree to have Shehnaz in Agra? She is not his responsibity. She can go back to Mathura and Jalal can help with her maintenance. Will these same people supporting Jodhas action bring a mad woman in their own homes? Common, lets be logical and not blinding support every Jodhas actions just because one is her fan.