Originally posted by: sashashyam
No, Tripti dear, you are wrong, presuming that it is you who wrote the part in bold. Or was it Mandy?
Anyhow, Rajat would find it a very interesting challenge to play a bitter, self-hating, self-destructive character, and he will win, and that without shedding a single tear.
Devdas is like Hamlet, a role every actor worth his salt hopes to play at some time in his career.
PC Barua, Dilip Kumar. Shivaji Ganesan, Nageswara Rao, the list is a long one. Rajat should try it too, if he gets the chance.
Also do see my response to Ash above. The best Devdas so far was Dilip Kumar, though Shahrukh tried very hard. Too hard, and it showed, though he had better support from the actresses who played Paro and Chandramukhi.
I saw Devdas in The Hague, and in the death scene, there were mutters from the (Indian) audience Jaldi marta kyon nahin hai, ghar to ja sakte the! I did not like that, but it showed that he could not hold the audience in that kind of extreme, long drawn out tragic scene.
I wrote a review of this Devdas for Rediff Movies, and here it is. Not, you will see, a flattering one!
| Obsession gone wrong
Sanjay Leela Bhansali's Devdas disappoints
|
Shyamala B Cowsik
I could not agree more with Anshuman Rawat. Devdas is a tale of obsession gone terribly wrong.
I did not like Hum Dil De Chuke Sanam [Sanjay Leela Bhansali's previous film] and his urge to exhaust every colour on the palette in the loudest, brightest tones possible. But that may be excused --- it was not a classic revisited.
When one remembers the bitter delicacy of the Bimal Roy version [starring Dilip Kumar in 1955] --- the quietude, the aching sadness so starkly portrayed without being buried under all this tinsel --- is enough to make one weep in frustration.
Sadly, it is not the three principal actors in Devdas who fail. Shah Rukh Khan does a good job in a very difficult role. In any case, no one else could have tackled this role. His flashes of arrogant harshness are excellent, and he can carry off sensuous romantic scenes effortlessly.
Madhuri Dixit, while her megawatt charm of Dil To Pagal Hai has faded, does an equally good job. As for Aishwarya Rai, Bhansali has done a masterful job of camouflaging her weaknesses as an actress in practically every scene, and of photographing her to near perfection.
It is the director who lets the actors down in this overloud confection that strains the nerves, the eyes and the ears.
However, I disagree with Rawat on one point. He writes, "Agreed the sets are out of this world and the costumes mindblowing..."
The costumes may be excellent and painstakingly styled, but they lack the aristocratic, understated elegance of the dresses of the same class of Bengalis in, for example, Satyajit Ray's Ghare Bhaire. Ray was an acknowledged master at recreating the ambience of the feudal period in Bengal. Every woman in Devdas looks like an overdecorated Christmas tree, except perhaps for Paro in the beginning. After the interval, Paro catches up with her mother and Devdas' mother in this respect.
As for the sets, they scream of ostentation --- every room has at least one hundred clashing colours in it. Vijayendra Ghatge's (Paro's husband) house has the most ghastly blue walls with plaster mouldings ever seen in Hindi films. The floor inlays in Chandramukhi's kotha will give you a headache. And Paro's house, with more stained glass than the Chartres cathedral, also has walls and decorations that avoid coordination with the stained glass.
The sets of the three houses look like some sort of space city out of a Star Wars film, and no one can imagine anyone with taste and refinement that characterised that class in that age living in such three-dimensional cardboard cutouts. Santosh Sivan in Asoka, with a much wider canvas, had managed an infinitely superior look on a fraction of the stated budget of Devdas.
I might be out of sync with the general public, but if this is what we consider to be the acme of Mumbai filmmaking, God help the discerning audience. People have no business massacring classics like this; there ought to be a law against it.
===============================================================
Shyamala Aunty
No aunty, I did not write that 😊.
I think Rajat would make a fabulous Devdas! However much I dislike the character,I think Rajat handles these deep, dark heroes with the true air & craft of a Master!
I also agree with you.. SRK was pathetically lacking at playing Dev.
Cricket
Current Affairs
Anupamaa
12