inconsistencies in characterizations! - Page 5

Originally posted by: cjs369

I agree..
the CV's now hot, now cold, story is getting really irritating...

Originally posted by: jshweta16

I agree this poor editing, abrupt end of scenes and pathetic ends of tracks is all CVs fault...but I feel many of us try to use this excuse to defend their fav character...again no offence to anyone! My only point is we give too much stress on CVs faults than the whole scens and the character when things goes wrong. Sometimes we should neglect the bloopers and logic to analyse the emotions behind these scenes. But I guess this is bound to happen if the inconsistencies continues.

Originally posted by: jiya.k

i think they are in denial mode they know very well that akdha's romance n their togetherness or their scene gives them trp but they think their drama gives them trp,tabhi toh acche khasa shoot kiya scene edit kar dete hai and 4 rectifying their mistake gives viewers soultalk's lolipop..

Originally posted by: rouble_lover

Guys, its an Ekta serial! Can we dare to expect anything more?? hmm...I wonder.. hmm.. :l 🤔

Originally posted by: MaddyO

Mandyg😊
I agree CVs are very inconsistent
We were never thinking bad cheap thoughts about Jalal's love, CVs made viewers think those by the 1st scene, it was THAT bad

agree!

Just tell me - I wrote on my thread too, what if it was Salima Begum with them, WOULD Jalal have let HER sleep outside, what do you think?

i think not because ruq would have made arrangements for her and not jalal, since this is supposed to be lady's department.

He has no problems in mistreating Jodha, the love confessions and crying and all made us think he has changed, TODAY CVs showed us he has not, he was just shaken for brief while but now he is back to insult Jodha and walk on eggshells and pamper Rukayya

he has problems mistreating jodha..he gets restless and unhappy after doing so..he did not change, he had feelings for jodha since the beginning, the moment he set eyes on her..there was something special about her that made him burn his hand when taking the payal out from the fire! a man looking at a woman will never do the above act if he is not attracted towards that woman.

he never insulted jodha, jodha herself opted to sleep outside when ruq left her with no option, since she left he could not sleep in peace, that is why getting up and going outside to see her, but he should have said something, did the cvz miss something here..i wonder!

Sometimes they show things that just wipes off good work, TELL ME if anybody would have enjoyed the 1st scene today? If they had to show that why not show Jalal NOT sleep in tent but tell Ruk he needs to go out and NEVER go back in
Or tell Rukayya it is unsafe outside decoits etc. & get Jo with him or on that pretext go out

i agree! the scene could have been shot in a better and more logical way..setting up a khema and sleeping in the khema is against the protocols of aam aadmi stuff isn't it?...i think its a blooper!

IT FELT ABSOLUTELY PATHETIC TO WATCH HIM SLEEPING CALMLY NEXT TO RUK WHEN JODHA IS OUT IN THE OPEN SHIVERING WITH COLD, nothing will justify that to me

she was not shown shivering but did not like the fact that they both were sleeping inside and jodha was sleeping outside like a dasi.

WHY they had to show him sleeping calmly, WAKE UP and then think about Jo and go out to ogle at her - what would have been concern just came out like ogling due to the scene treatment

absolutely hated the inconsistency when the scene started i was like what???..he just slept..and then he goes out..fine..and then what..jodha wakes up and sees him then do they do something is now what i am thinking about..HB dreaming about grandson..chisti's prediction..jalal in hamam giving a sweet and naughty expression when thinking of MUZ stuff..did they actually do it is what i am worried about now😕..what do u think?

CVs never showed so many things

cva missed on many things and i am wondering why?

Why was MA not questioned about her part in Ben track? How she risked Jalal's life

hell will break loose on her at once..but yes she should have been questioned..again the discontinuity or it could be that jalal was too involved in saving jodha's life and did not care of anything else!

Why was Ruk given gift by Jalal? When she almost got him killed with her jealousy!

ruq got the gift for bravely almost killing ben and then taking care of her with help of akhda.

Why was there never any investigation even a sentense about having to investigate the failure of security in Ben track

hmmm..good question..cvz should keep in mind such points..again discontinuity!

Why Jodha forgives MA & Ruk so easily? OK with Jalal maybe she is so thanful to be on good footing again she lets go

jodha, is a changed personality after her near death experience..she came back because of jalal..because deep down she has very strong feelings for him which she is not ready to bring to the surface yet..maybe with time she will only if more MUs do not disrupt them..why she forgives ruq or maham..we can say she does not expect much from them..when you do not expect anything from someone then where is the hurt..but she feels hurt and offended when jalal says something to her and vise versa..there is a saying in punjabi, let me know if u need translation...'sajjna ne phul marya meri rooh umbran tak roi'..in short..many ruqs or mahamas can insult me i will not be affected the day i will be insulted by my love will be the day when my soul will cry loud to wake up the lords in heaven!

We were all thinking love track started, they do not want to start CLEARLY and will bring in another BIG MU and I am now hoping for big insults for Jodha cos somehow this doormat is not coming to her senses, she just lets EVERYBODY insult her

she is no doormat dear, she is a damsel in love😳..when ruq told her to sleep outside she went out of the tent head high..she did not beg for anything..she said she will sleep outside even if she hated to part from jalal..and why would anyone treat her as a doormat..she has got everything without asking or throwing tantrums..jalal thinks about her, dreams about her, and looks at her even when ruq is talking to him..does she need anyone else..she is content and she is happy!

At the end of the day IT IS A FEELING YOU HAVE ABOUT EPISODE OR SERIAL - TODAY I FELT VERY DISAPPOINTED AND CVs turned Jalal very shallow for me

i too did not feel too good..it was not one of those feel good episodes..i am blaming on improper characterization and editing!

What is love worth of such man who can do that to ANY of his Begums, forget love - to any woman? NO person I know would do that and Jalal is back to Ben track feeling for me
CVs did this with their inconsitencies in characterisations

i agree with inconsistency part here but it does not bring jalal up or down as far as his feelings are concerned, they r there..they were there...and they will stay..no wonder akbar had 7 kids from MUZ even after having 1000plus women! and he had a special passage going from his room to jodha's..doesn't that tell something!...even in the era of polygamy muz got way more than any other begum could get and we should not forget that he had other begums to deal with as well..anyway lets see how cvz pann out upcoming episodes..although not much hope from the way they will execute but lets see...

So anything they show now, love talk all will seem false to me from Jalal

again, it all depends how well the scenes are shot and one thing i would say that cvz should take care of these minute details that can make or break a character! just like that dhakka scene left a bitter taste for me and i could not relate to jo for a long time..

one point i would like to add on execution of the first scene from cvz point of view..i think they were trying to show symbolism..on one side there is ruq in her khema wrapped up in luxury and he is with her wrapped up in comfortable blanket but cannot sleep in peace..his soul is somewhere else..he gets up and leaves all the luxury and comfort of his cosy bed with ruq and walks outside the khema leaving behind ruq and moves towards jodha who is sleeping on earth because she does not need all the comforts or luxuries she is a content soul with whatever little she gets..jalal is attracted towards her and gets peace in just standing and looking at her..now this view of hers is giving way more pleasure and satisfaction than a comfortable bed could have ever offered him..a symbolism of shifting of his heart in search of peace and contentment which he has found in jodha as his partner!

Originally posted by: pallavi003

well, I think after the trp chart came out,all went in party mood,and didn't end the script,and after the shoot and the editing of friday's epi,they found that the residue was nt covering the total time slot, hence the tent wala filler scene,that also brain child of some naive,junior apprentices, otherwise it couldn't come out so illogical..

Originally posted by: PadBear

Mandy, I didn't find the first scene annoying. CVs turned those looks exchanged into a question mark for us that's all. Both looked calm. When Ruq arrived, that was the end of that particular walk in the park of love, but there have to be many more na... it's a love story, not a slap dash romantic comedy...or is it? ... CVs will have to decide.

Originally posted by: mandyg

can i call u cuddly bear please or that is only reserved for our dear shyamala😆..anyway, i always love your replies..i am adding another aspect to the first scene from cvz point of view, will copy paste from one of my replies...

'one point i would like to add on execution of the first scene from cvz point of view..i think they were trying to show symbolism..on one side there is ruq in her khema wrapped up in luxury and he is with her wrapped up in comfortable blanket but cannot sleep in peace..his soul is somewhere else..he gets up and leaves all the luxury and comfort of his cosy bed with ruq and walks outside the khema leaving behind ruq and moves towards jodha who is sleeping on earth because she does not need all the comforts or luxuries she is a content soul with whatever little she gets..jalal is attracted towards her and gets peace in just standing and looking at her..now this view of hers is giving way more pleasure and satisfaction than a comfortable bed could have ever offered him..a symbolism of shifting of his heart in search of peace and contentment which he has found in jodha as his partner!"

let me know what u think😊

Originally posted by: PadBear

You can call me CB too 😳...i dunno if you have to ask Shyamala's permission though... hahah.

Well yes Mandy Bear! Even I felt my heart all pighaly-melty seeing Jodha being so content outside...so imagine Jallu Bear's haalat?? hai hai!! Poor guy had the existence of his heart confirmed in triplicate when her eyes met his.

cosy bed with Ruq is nothing now compared to standing out in the fresh air watching Jo enjoying the Great Outdoors. This is what love stories are made of.