inconsistencies in characterizations! - Page 3

Created

Last reply

Replies

69

Views

4.3k

Users

22

Likes

128

Frequent Posters

ghalibmirza thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#21


i liked ur point on assumptions..we r supposed to assume a lot of stuff and i myself do not like this..there should be continuity and consistency!

why blaming the cvz because who is responsible for the flawed scenes, editing, poor screenplay, direction, etc..the creatives! the actors r just the end product of whats given to them..they play their role as per script then its tata bye for them..now who is responsible for thinking of historical facts and then putting them together in a script logically with their bits and pieces of fiction..the whole team that works behind the camera..isn't it!...if all they r showing is per history word for word then i have absolutely no objection, but i will have objection if they do not portray a character properly and leave the rest for us to assume or imagine!...now u tell me where this khema come from when this was aam aadmi trip?...any explanation to that..because the editing is poor! there is lack of connectivity!
i shud not be comparing but DABH has been ruling charts for their well written script and less chance for bloopers!
ghalibmirza thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#22

Originally posted by: jiya.k

inconsistency of characterization is nt only problem of cvs editing of akdha's scene is also gives wrong impression 2 viewers like friday's last or 2days first scene...



whats wrong with the team of number one show
ShadeOfWhite thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#23
I agree Mandy...main tabse bolrahi hoon I'm mad at CVs !!😡
the beginning scene ended abruptly and then they reached to Agra so fast ! it was badly edited and I didn't find any logic behind it...hope they continued the night scene then many of us who r upset with Jalal's behavior would have been felt better..I'm sure JJ must have shared a beautiful night probably talking to each other..but they didnt show us.😡

the track which started off fabulously, ended leaving a bad taste in our mouths.

regarding his thoughts of MUZ, I found it very dreamy..Jalal was super happy and over the moon...not only coz he got to know he will be a father but also it will be his love Jodha, bearing his child..what can be more heavenly than this ?❤️

the characters have no consistency...

P.S. yes, I am upset with Jalal..he could have for once stopped Jodha..he didnt, which I found a big let down..then again, I'm pacifying my heart with logics
my love for JaJo is way above than anything..I cannot hold anger for them for long time
Edited by tamy267 - 11 years ago
staker123 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#24

Originally posted by: mandyg



whats wrong with the team of number one show


mandy di u r not replying to my post😭
Amor. thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 11 years ago
#25
@mandy
CVs r so confused just before a moment thy showed jalu was ignoring wat ruqu saying n gazing at jodha n another moment he was just too cool n sleep inside, thy r in so hurry which spoil characterization, thy shud hv shown a tit bit convo where jalu atleast hv asked jo is she comfortable outside or not n then let him sleep inside but no thy need to rush it agra ki yaad aa rahi hogi na

had karte h ye log bhi
cjs369 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#26
I agree..
the CV's now hot, now cold, story is getting really irritating...



MyExiledSoul thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#27

Originally posted by: mandyg



i liked ur point on assumptions..we r supposed to assume a lot of stuff and i myself do not like this..there should be continuity and consistency!

why blaming the cvz because who is responsible for the flawed scenes, editing, poor screenplay, direction, etc..the creatives! the actors r just the end product of whats given to them..they play their role as per script then its tata bye for them..now who is responsible for thinking of historical facts and then putting them together in a script logically with their bits and pieces of fiction..the whole team that works behind the camera..isn't it!...if all they r showing is per history word for word then i have absolutely no objection, but i will have objection if they do not portray a character properly and leave the rest for us to assume or imagine!...now u tell me where this khema come from when this was aam aadmi trip?...any explanation to that..because the editing is poor! there is lack of connectivity!
i shud not be comparing but DABH has been ruling charts for their well written script and less chance for bloopers!

I agree this poor editing, abrupt end of scenes and pathetic ends of tracks is all CVs fault...but I feel many of us try to use this excuse to defend their fav character...again no offence to anyone! My only point is we give too much stress on CVs faults than the whole scens and the character when things goes wrong. Sometimes we should neglect the bloopers and logic to analyse the emotions behind these scenes. But I guess this is bound to happen if the inconsistencies continues.
jiya.k thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#28

Originally posted by: mandyg

[BR][BR]whats wrong with the team of number one show[#-o][BR]

i think they are in denial mode they know very well that akdha's romance n their togetherness or their scene gives them trp but they think their drama gives them trp,tabhi toh acche khasa shoot kiya scene edit kar dete hai and 4 rectifying their mistake gives viewers soultalk's lolipop..
rouble_lover thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#29
Guys, its an Ekta serial! Can we dare to expect anything more?? hmm...I wonder.. hmm.. :l 🤔
MaddyO thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#30

Originally posted by: mandyg

hi everyone!

i know today's episode especially the first scene did not go well with many..
we can look at it from many point of views..some say that he must have made sure she is safe and then went to sleep..and he was calm and also concerned about ruq's insecurities..makes sense..and some on the other hand think he loves ruq more than jo and he just wants jo for MUZ in other words pleasure
..does not sound convincing!

my take on this part is, do u guys remember what happened in tiger track?..jodha who tried her best in saving jalal rt from the jungle scenes to making lep for him..was never shown putting that lep on him or even asking how he was feeling and went straight to amer track and she was back in her ghrina mode..for the same person who saved her from the tiger attack!!!

don't you think there was inconsistency shown in jo's characterization?

and now lets come to the second part which is similar to the first part..here jalal is shown doing every possible thing to save jodha and then beautiful salim chishti trip which they ended abruptly by ruq's inference..and jalal who was so concerned of jo's well being and safety was shown sleeping in the tent with ruq!

don't u guys think its another case if inconsistency of characterization?

i can only think of two reasons why its happening..

-cvz do not want to start their wo wala love track as yet

-they r showing us lollipop every now and then to keep us hooked on to the serial, it always happens when they bombard us with string of MUs and then to cool us off they throw akhdalicious moments..uff..cvz!!!



Mandyg😊
I agree CVs are very inconsistent
We were never thinking bad cheap thoughts about Jalal's love, CVs made viewers think those by the 1st scene, it was THAT bad

Just tell me - I wrote on my thread too, what if it was Salima Begum with them, WOULD Jalal have let HER sleep outside, what do you think?

He has no problems in mistreating Jodha, the love confessions and crying and all made us think he has changed, TODAY CVs showed us he has not, he was just shaken for brief while but now he is back to insult Jodha and walk on eggshells and pamper Rukayya

Sometimes they show things that just wipes off good work, TELL ME if anybody would have enjoyed the 1st scene today? If they had to show that why not show Jalal NOT sleep in tent but tell Ruk he needs to go out and NEVER go back in
Or tell Rukayya it is unsafe outside decoits etc. & get Jo with him or on that pretext go out

IT FELT ABSOLUTELY PATHETIC TO WATCH HIM SLEEPING CALMLY NEXT TO RUK WHEN JODHA IS OUT IN THE OPEN SHIVERING WITH COLD, nothing will justify that to me

WHY they had to show him sleeping calmly, WAKE UP and then think about Jo and go out to ogle at her - what would have been concern just came out like ogling due to the scene treatment

CVs never showed so many things

Why was MA not questioned about her part in Ben track? How she risked Jalal's life

Why was Ruk given gift by Jalal? When she almost got him killed with her jealousy!

Why was there never any investigation even a sentense about having to investigate the failure of security in Ben track

Why Jodha forgives MA & Ruk so easily? OK with Jalal maybe she is so thanful to be on good footing again she lets go

We were all thinking love track started, they do not want to start CLEARLY and will bring in another BIG MU and I am now hoping for big insults for Jodha cos somehow this doormat is not coming to her senses, she just lets EVERYBODY insult her

At the end of the day IT IS A FEELING YOU HAVE ABOUT EPISODE OR SERIAL - TODAY I FELT VERY DISAPPOINTED AND CVs turned Jalal very shallow for me

What is love worth of such man who can do that to ANY of his Begums, forget love - to any woman? NO person I know would do that and Jalal is back to Ben track feeling for me
CVs did this with their inconsitencies in characterisations

So anything they show now, love talk all will seem false to me from Jalal

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".