Is Ruq taking Jalal's silence as consent for bad behaviour? - Page 9

Created

Last reply

Replies

119

Views

11.4k

Users

36

Likes

464

Frequent Posters

MaddyO thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#81

Originally posted by: sweet_diksha

Hi Mansi... nice update...

i m out , so can't write more... but i ll be back on Monday, and will try another post..

Just one thing...It's time Jalal should stand up for the one he claims to love... or is he waiting for Jo to defend herself first in front of Ruku, and then if ruku tries to insult Jo, he will shut Ruku's mouth?



Diksha missed your post today

You said it bang on👍🏼


elasingh thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#82

Originally posted by: sweet_diksha

Hi Mansi... nice update...

i m out , so can't write more... but i ll be back on Monday, and will try another post..

Just one thing...It's time Jalal should stand up for the one he claims to love... or is he waiting for Jo to defend herself first in front of Ruku, and then if ruku tries to insult Jo, he will shut Ruku's mouth?

It is highly unlikely that he is wating for Jodha to retaliate...Remember during hojra issue he had clearly told Ruku that her oudha is much above than Jodha...He had said it before also during Ruku's divorce issue when all were their in the room...So how can Jodha stand up for herself?
Again it is futile to say that now he has changed becoz he has realized his love for Jodha...Infact when he was crying and praying for Jodha at mazaar , he had said that he hid his love from the world but cant hide it from god...So obviously he knew that he loved her but that didn't stop him from mistreating her or let others mistreat her...
Joja thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#83

Originally posted by: elasingh

It is highly unlikely that he is wating for Jodha to retaliate...Remember during hojra issue he had clearly told Ruku that her oudha is much above than Jodha...He had said it before also during Ruku's divorce issue when all were their in the room...So how can Jodha stand up for herself?
Again it is futile to say that now he has changed becoz he has realized his love for Jodha...Infact when he was crying and praying for Jodha at mazaar , he had said that he hid his love from the world but cant hide it from god...So obviously he knew that he loved her but that didn't stop him from mistreating her or let others mistreat her...

Ela a few think ruq is a pampered kid. whatever she is, how long can Jalal tolerate this. Just because she is pampered, has no parents , childhood friend doesnt mean she insults everyone.
Jodha is also a begum like she is, how can she treat her like Bandi.
A few days back she said she is so greatful to her and can give anything for her(ya , except Jalal, as if he is her property). Did she forget about Jo taking poison to save him.. isnt she greatful about it now. forget greatful, she even asks her to go out and sleep. Is this kiddish ness.
It is really very high time, Jalal puts his foot down and makes things clear.
Yes, Jalal knows her from childhood, no one wants him to leave her or ignore. Do justice for both relation. Just because Jodha is adjusting and undestands doesnt mean you allow her to sleep out
And its not just out in cold, it also not safe. which husband can allow his wife to sleep outside alone?
elasingh thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#84

Originally posted by: Joja

Ela a few think ruq is a pampered kid. whatever she is, how long can Jalal tolerate this. Just because she is pampered, has no parents , childhood friend doesnt mean she insults everyone.
Jodha is also a begum like she is, how can she treat her like Bandi.
A few days back she said she is so greatful to her and can give anything for her(ya , except Jalal, as if he is her property). Did she forget about Jo taking poison to save him.. isnt she greatful about it now. forget greatful, she even asks her to go out and sleep. Is this kiddish ness.
It is really very high time, Jalal puts his foot down and makes things clear.
Yes, Jalal knows her from childhood, no one wants him to leave her or ignore. Do justice for both relation. Just because Jodha is adjusting and undestands doesnt mean you allow her to sleep out
And its not just out in cold, it also not safe. which husband can allow his wife to sleep outside alone?

Joja fault also lies with Jodha...Why does she let Ruku insult her? In yesterday scene when Ruku is folding blanket why does Jo says that why Ruku is doing this? Let Ruku prepare bed for herself?...

Again after recovring Jallu came to Jo's hojra and Jo was literally falling on his feet and asking abt Ben's beauty and comparing herself with her...So Jo herself think she is a bandi...
petrichorr thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#85
Had mixed feelings seeing the precap.
Monday things will be clear but at the outset it seems like Jalaal needs to be a bit more firm when one begum's antics affects the other.
Why would he accept the sleeping arrangement? No one has the guts to overrule his decision. So why couldn't he have put his foot down and said either they all sleep inside or outside.
Jodha's disappointment was clear. Anycase, lets wait n see how the scene plays out. He handled the harem chamber issue beautifully even at the time he was cross with Jodha. So lets see ...precaps could be misleading however we know that Jodha was sleeping out.
Thank god the era of Polygamy is gone!
Joja thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#86

Originally posted by: elasingh

Joja fault also lies with Jodha...Why does she let Ruku insult her? In yesterday scene when Ruku is folding blanket why does Jo says that why Ruku is doing this? Let Ruku prepare bed for herself?...

Again after recovring Jallu came to Jo's hojra and Jo was literally falling on his feet and asking abt Ben's beauty and comparing herself with her...So Jo herself think she is a bandi...

Ela, i agreeabout yday ... Jo should not have asked ruq why is she folding the blanket. Well, both are equal. Not sure why she asked it.
But about she asking Ben's beautiy. Thats fine. She is in almost love with him and would expect him to praise her. I dont mind anything between Jodha-Jalal. but cant take 3rd person, be is Ruq.
sweet_diksha thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#87

Originally posted by: elasingh

It is highly unlikely that he is wating for Jodha to retaliate...Remember during hojra issue he had clearly told Ruku that her oudha is much above than Jodha...He had said it before also during Ruku's divorce issue when all were their in the room...So how can Jodha stand up for herself?
Again it is futile to say that now he has changed becoz he has realized his love for Jodha...Infact when he was crying and praying for Jodha at mazaar , he had said that he hid his love from the world but cant hide it from god...So obviously he knew that he loved her but that didn't stop him from mistreating her or let others mistreat her...



i understand ur disappointment , ela... but the thing is that i think Jalal is waiting for Jo to stand up for herself, before he confronts Ruku.. and when he will see thst Ruku keeps humiliating Jo, and Jo is not defending herself, first he will confront Jo as to why she takes all insults from Ruku... and i do expect Jo to ask him in definite words... that she will reply Ruku in what rights, when he (her husband) hasn't given her any right and wants her only to fulfill her duties... then Jalal will understand his wrong behavior and his faults in their relation and only then he will confront Ruku... ( i m expecting this... let's see)

and anyway, it's always said... God also helps them who help themselves... So it's time now Jo stand up in front of Jalal (not Ruku) for her own... Ruku is secondary...
baubles thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#88
Hello di..I haven't been regular here in the past week, have been busy.
Great post as usual...👍🏼
What I thought about the whole episode was that Jalal knows anything said to Ruqu was not going to help. Him shutting her up would have still never made her see sense, instead her hatred for Jo would have just increased and she would have gotten more adamant and screechy.. so I suppose he was being calm only for that reason...

Ruqu was outright rude as always... for every nice thing Jo did or said to her she had nothing but rudeness to give back..I have no hopes for her really!😵
Jo was lovely throughout the epi..loved her!! ❤️
As for the last part..all Jalal saw was that Jo looked sad about the decision. He didn't hear Ruqu or the convo that took place inside. He can only guess it must be her doing.. so I don't blame him there!

Wish to see him beside Jo the whole night on Monday..that would be the best!!

Bobby13 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#89
Mansi, I can see that you were quite upset with Jalal's silence on Friday's episode. I too was little upset initially, but after thinking a while I thought that I should wait till Monday to comment on this.
Also please note that Jalal was not in the room when Ruqu was telling Jodha about the sleeping arrangements. So he does not know that it was Ruqu who asked Jodha to sleep outside. He came inside and saw Jodha going out of the khema telling that she prefer sleeping outside. So he probably thought that she herself wanted to sleep outside. I am not telling this is the actual scenario, but this could be one possibility.
Another aspect is that we have seen how Jalal always gets Ruqu to work in favor of him without telling anything against her. This is the way he has been handling her and he was successful in the past with that. So he will not change the way he handles Ruqu so soon until he is sure that his ways are not being fruitful. If you remember he was treating Ruqu in the similar way during Jodha's birthday, after Taslim track and in many other occations. Ruqu always went from her grey shade to good shade each time Jalal spoke to her in his trademark manner reserved for Ruqu. So I think we should not expect him to change his ways with Ruqu completely and that too so soon. I think he will slowly realize that his mild ways are not working with Ruqu now and then he will reconsider his methods. We should wait and see how the dynamics change between Jalal, Jodha and Ruqu and I am sure they are going to change gradually.
sweet_gargi thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#90

Hmm I have not watched the episode yet but from your analysis I feel the only reason why Jalal chose to be silent was because that was not the right time. He knows Ruqaiya well enough. She is a tantrum queen n hates Jodha. He understands her insecuirty and so anything said by Jalal to ruqaiya at that time would have been a problem in the rest of their journey. M sure he will confront Ruqaiya in his way for behaving badly with Jodha after reaching Agra😊

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".