Did Harshit really deserve 29 today?

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

Aimen

@tsaian

Inactive

Posted: 17 years ago

#21

i think harshit is favourd by judges
and somehow harshit deserve near 26_27

Quote

arayq2

@arayq2

Explorer

Posted: 17 years ago

#22

Originally posted by: apparaohoare
Here are my scores for today.
Debu, Rahul - Surely 30

Toshi -24

Chotu - 24 (He had a blocked nose, and it sounded in the song)

Abhijit and Harshit - 25 or 26 max

Ishmeet - Don't know. Never heard the original song.

Debu's performance was clearly the best of the day. Rahul's was very good, lots of energy, but not really in Debu's class. Harshit took a decent shot at a difficult combination, but as you rightly point out, he didn't find the right mix. Accordingly

Debu: 30

Rahul: 29

Harshit: 28

Abhijeet: 26

Toshi/Ishmeet: 25

Vineet: 24

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

madhyha

@madhy

Inactive

+ 2

Posted: 17 years ago

#23

Originally posted by: imranhashmi
pls dont compare harshit with rahul.... rahul is far far better than him... and harshit didnt deserve 29.. max he could get was 26.

yea pls dont comapred harshit wit anyone.. 😆😆he is above this competition...nd da best nd most consistant singer left in da show👏👏

Quote

Who-I-Used-2-Be

@Who-I-Used-2-Be

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 17 years ago

#24

@ the title-- No, Harshit certainly didn't deserve 29..Debojeet was the only contestant who justified the theme and sang really well..He totally deserved that 30..Rahul was second best, was really good but not flawless at all, and he deserved less than 30..Aishwariya's rendition of the same song was a class act of his own, and Rahul's performance didn't come close..Only his ending was superb..About Harshit..He was third best, better than the remaining four but his performance was far from deserving 29..At best, judges should've awarded him 26/27..He didn't seem to get the 'feel' of the song right too..

Abhijeet, Toshi, Ishmeet and Vineet were disappointing and deserved to be awarded 25 and even lesser..

Quote

Nazneen

@SiriuslySujal

Dazzler

Posted: 17 years ago

#25

Originally posted by: simplyvivacious
@ the title-- No, Harshit certainly didn't deserve 29..Debojeet was the only contestant who justified the theme and sang really well..He totally deserved that 30..Rahul was second best, was really good but not flawless at all, and he deserved less than 30..Aishwariya's rendition of the same song was a class act of his own, and Rahul's performance didn't come close..Only his ending was superb..About Harshit..He was third best, better than the remaining four but his performance was far from deserving 29..At best, judges should've awarded him 26/27..He didn't seem to get the 'feel' of the song right too..

Abhijeet, Toshi, Ishmeet and Vineet were disappointing and deserved to be awarded 25 and even lesser..

Agree with you. Didn't really enjoy Rahul's performance too much (though, to be fair, I missed the end because the video cut off before the end of his song and the next one started with his marks ) Really glad someone other than myself appreciates that Aishwarya's performance of the same was 78290374829374920 times better than Rahul's! 😃

I think Harshit made a really good effort - and he is one of my faves in the show - but he didn't deserve that 29 for that performance. I agree it is a difficult song, with multiple singers' parts to be considered, but I think the judges went overboard. I'd've given him around 26... 27, max.

Can't really comment on the other performances, yet, as I only watched a few. I did see Vinit's, though, and it wasn't good. He also didn't deserve all the sympathy for his sore throat. Other people have had sore throats before and been told that the greats of the industry like Lata-ji and Asha-ji sang with sore throats and that it's no excuse. I think it all depends on how pitiful you look... 😆 Then again, Vinit doesn't seem to need to put on a pitiful act to win over the judges, as he seems to have some kind of magic power that wins over all judges, no matter who they are or what the show is... 😆 I'd've given him 23 or less for that performance.

Quote

maHa.

@maHa.

Inactive

Posted: 17 years ago

#26

honestly sayin i loved harshit;s singin.. he deserves a full 30 from my side but as vishal shekhar kno better abt the sur n all so i think the scoring was absolutely deserving..

Quote

aditi

@addyydda

Voyager

Posted: 17 years ago

#27

most of the singers got more than they deserved n many 4 sum inane reasons...debo was the only one who deserved wot he got...

Edited by addyydda - 17 years ago

Quote

laxmi129

@laxmi129

Inactive

Posted: 17 years ago

#28

Harshit really sang well. He derserved whatever he got. How do you rate a performance?? If one sings an easy song nicely and gets 30 then singing a tough song with minor mistakes should also be okay. Harshit is really good in this competition.

Quote

dambis

@dambis

Beginner

Posted: 17 years ago

#29

harshit did not deserve a 29 but somthing around 24-25...he was nowhere near the song, i know its a tough song but still his was not a good performance. the judges seem to b partial towards him....
harshit has a powerful voice but i would like him to sing a real soft romantic song without aggression which may help me in changing my opinion about him if i hav to consider him as a playback singer 😊
this is my opinion(not intending to hurt any1's feelings)

Edited by dambis - 17 years ago