Did Harshit really deserve 29 today? - Page 2

Originally posted by: princess1_43

However Returning back to the post you have to be fair to the contestant - Harshit wasnt as good as Debojit... Def better than Rahul/Abhijeet(I really liked Rahul's ending portion but I agree with others he was no where near Aishwarya) But Harshit did pull of that song really well .. .. Harshit is a very good singer but today it was Not his best performance but for the day he had the second best performance

Although Rahul's song was not pefect, but those minor errors could be neglected. The energy of his song was fantastic.

Originally posted by: apparaohoare

Although Rahul's song was not pefect, but those minor errors could be neglected. The energy of his song was fantastic.

Agree on the account of his energy.😊.. I previously said it was absolute madness... but when you are judging and know that 50% of marks are weighed in plus 50% of the votes which could save u ... then those minor errors cannot be looked over.... Rahul was not better then Debojit and a 30 on 30 performance should be to the person who has done outstanding job throughout the song ...

Originally posted by: princess1_43

Lets not get to Points - I dont know what they give their grades on ... I think the most ridiculous answers/Justifications I have heard for their grading

Examples -
Aap Ke Sur bikhere huay thay, but Antra bhat acha tha - 10
Aap Ka Gala Kharab Hai but app bhat achay singer ho - 10
Aap Ne Bahut Difficult gana chuna uskay liye one more point
Aap Ne Dance acha kiya aur masti layi uske liye one more point
Aap Ne apnay comfort say bahar gaya uske liya one more point
Aap ka sur high note par achay lagay baki ka gana acha thay uskay liye 10

Do I go any further...

However Returning back to the post you have to be fair to the contestant - Harshit wasnt as good as Debojit... Def better than Rahul/Abhijeet(I really liked Rahul's ending portion but I agree with others he was no where near Aishwarya) But Harshit did pull of that song really well .. .. Harshit is a very good singer but today it was Not his best performance but for the day he had the second best performance

War Like 😆 - I think he gets tensed up or is not open with the audience that much because if he loosens up a bit his singing will be much better...

samia one more example adding to da list which u 4got to add.😆😆

Aapne apna standerd itna hight set karliya hai nd we r so used to give u triple 10 isilye one extra points..😳😆😆

Originally posted by: madhy

samia one more example adding to da list which u 4got to add.😆😆

Aapne apna standerd itna hight set karliya hai nd we r so used to give u triple 10 isilye one extra points..😳😆😆

😆😆 lol Madhy... Seriously...Judges and their justification for giving points and one mark

I think Harshit deserved 30 today. Before commenting please listen to the original song and then compare with what Harshit has sung. This is a very difficult song and was sung wonderfully by Harshit, not missing any sur. Compare the original and Harshit's song. You will know. It is an out and out nasha song and the madness of the original song was beuatifally maintained by Harshit. Madness does not mean tottering on feet and dishing out hiccups when it was not there in the original song. In fact Rahul shouted out the song and his variations were horrendous. Debojit sang a very easy song which he has done thoughout the competition.

Originally posted by: apparaohoare

There is no doubt that "Sheeshe se sheesha" was one of the more difficult songs in today's episode. However, did Harshit really deserve 29 today?

This song is originally sung by three singers, so there is very little time to breathe when sung by only one singer. It is my personal feeling that although it was a tough song to sing solo but this song had all the ingredients to create a perfect "nasha" environment.

If we neglect the breathing issues with Harshit's performance today, still he did not have any of the nasheela expressions. Again, it sounded like a WAR SONG or FIGHT SONG, just like his last week's performance. We understand that Harshit has a strong voice, but he should realize that a strong voice is not needed for all songs.

I felt that the judges are a little inclined towards Harshit. A perfect score of 10 means a perfect performance, and it was no where near perfect. Still two of the judges gave him 10.

What do you all think?????

I liked the WAR part ...plus he is also ********

Moderator's Note: Avoid offensive remarks that offend fans...

Originally posted by: King_Anu

so we have etablished that vineet is being favored

saxena was favored and i agree with the poster. his heavy tractor type voice is too powerful to fit any hero in this industry and it sounds terrible also

worst moment came at dhamak dhamak part where it felt like a DHAMAKA has happened.

thats just my opinion so no one has to get angry about it. i am okay with other's opinion on whom i like so my opinion must be respected. besides my opinions are shared by poster here

such a performance deserved 20-22 at best

hi welcum back....

i respect ur opinion . like u respect ours n im not going to criticize it. i quoted to say hi.

anyway this is my reply to the topic.

i think harshit sang beautifully. he deserved 30.

n i think harshit maintained tht naheela environment thing very well 👏

pls dont compare harshit with rahul.... rahul is far far better than him... and harshit didnt deserve 29.. max he could get was 26.

Originally posted by: King_Anu

while we are at it

my scored

saxena 22
vinit 20
abhijit 22
debo 27
ishmeet 26
rahul 24
toshi 28

i respect ur opinion , but sincerely rahul and debojit sang way better than toshi yeterday .. i agree that toshi deserved 27-28 But rahul and debojit definitely deserved 30