VS - Judges or emotional fools ?? - Page 3

Originally posted by: shehzaadi91

I agree with you. 8 or 9 would have been more appropriate if they wanted to save her from elimination. But I guess they gave 10 each to increase her total score since Farah had already given 7.

again thts wrong judging u have to give marks to the performance according to wat u think not ..according to wat otehr judges hav given ....😕

I think bugger that VISHAL n SHEKHAR were rite...bcos all know that prajakta deserve to be there and bad points on grounds of her sore throat might have eliminated her...logically u may be rite...but u mite also accept that praju is one of the GEM...

WHEN A CHILD IS ILL THEN HIS/HER MOTHER PAYS MORE CARE AND ATTENTION...IT DOESNT MEAN THAT THE MOTHER IS FAVOURING HER...SO I THINK JUDGES WERE RITE...

As far as FARHA is concerned i hope u remember that in INDIAN IDOL 2 bcos of her bad remark for MY MEENAL JAIN..she got eliminated...so i think it mattered and she shud have been more compassionate towards her... 😊

Originally posted by: RAJNISHMJF1

I think bugger that VISHAL n SHEKHAR were rite...bcos all know that prajakta deserve to be there and bad points on grounds of her sore throat might have eliminated her...logically u may be rite...but u mite also accept that praju is one of the GEM...

WHEN A CHILD IS ILL THEN HIS/HER MOTHER PAYS MORE CARE AND ATTENTION...IT DOESNT MEAN THAT THE MOTHER IS FAVOURING HER...SO I THINK JUDGES WERE RITE...

As far as FARHA is concerned i hope u remember that in INDIAN IDOL 2 bcos of her bad remark for MY MEENAL JAIN..she got eliminated...so i think it mattered and she shud have been more compassionate towards her... 😊

very well said rajnish... they knows that she deserves to be there.. it was her bad luck that she coulnt not even talk.. but even though she sang.. thats not an easy job.. it was hurting her badly.. we could see that.. bravo prajuu.. 👏

well, prajkta ia a good singer. but all are good here in champions so i dont think that it was right to gv 10 to prajkta. even prajkta told that she doesnt want ne vote for sympathy. she requested public to vote her with dil n dimaag both. 👏 prajkta u r winner of our hearts but in the point of compitition VS were not good.

Originally posted by: RAJNISHMJF1

I think bugger that VISHAL n SHEKHAR were rite...bcos all know that prajakta deserve to be there and bad points on grounds of her sore throat might have eliminated her...logically u may be rite...but u mite also accept that praju is one of the GEM...

WHEN A CHILD IS ILL THEN HIS/HER MOTHER PAYS MORE CARE AND ATTENTION...IT DOESNT MEAN THAT THE MOTHER IS FAVOURING HER...SO I THINK JUDGES WERE RITE...

As far as FARHA is concerned i hope u remember that in INDIAN IDOL 2 bcos of her bad remark for MY MEENAL JAIN..she got eliminated...so i think it mattered and she shud have been more compassionate towards her... 😊

ok rite ....this was a natural fault n i m not saying praju is not a gud singer ..she si a fab singer ...but as i said this a competition ........ther is no room for faults whether its their own fault or natural one!!

last time also they favoured her when she forgot her lyrics .....now tht fault wasnt natural ...but still the ygave her chance against the rules of the show ...but chalo thik hai it was ok .......it happens sumtimes ....again today sumthing happened wit her ....and she was given teh advantage ....if everytime they do teh same thing ...isnt it unfair to otehr champions!!!😕 and plzz they r the judges not their motehr to treat them wit compassion .......if they strt acting like motehr of teh contestants .....phir toh ho gaya competition😆😆

Originally posted by: RAJNISHMJF1

I think bugger that VISHAL n SHEKHAR were rite...bcos all know that prajakta deserve to be there and bad points on grounds of her sore throat might have eliminated her...logically u may be rite...but u mite also accept that praju is one of the GEM...

WHEN A CHILD IS ILL THEN HIS/HER MOTHER PAYS MORE CARE AND ATTENTION...IT DOESNT MEAN THAT THE MOTHER IS FAVOURING HER...SO I THINK JUDGES WERE RITE...

As far as FARHA is concerned i hope u remember that in INDIAN IDOL 2 bcos of her bad remark for MY MEENAL JAIN..she got eliminated...so i think it mattered and she shud have been more compassionate towards her... 😊

umm yehh ur kind of making sense😆😆😆

maybe VS are a bit MOTHERLY n Farah isnt🤣

😆 😆 emotional fools??..!!! 😆 😆 ....i agree dey were bit emotional 2wrds praju bt i kinda felt sorry 4 her too .... oh well letz see wt happens nxt week..😛

i thought that was very unfair, i mean they should judge according to that day. They could appeal to the voters to give her another chance, but they have to be fair. And she messed up the other time too

i agree totally, i just watch the episodes

and wow, she was bad...i get it that it's not her fault but at the same time, it's not fair to other contestants who sang better than her.

She got two 10 from them which autimatically gave her an edge as judges' votes count in the final rating. Vishal at the end said Shimeet(i think that's his name) sang the worse for the day, now how is he worse compare to Prajakta!
they are emotinal fools, no doubt 😆

I hope that due to this soft judging that Ishmeet does not get eliminated! Poor boy got some harsh comments.

but I understand the soft marks for V and S. To be eliminated because you can't sing is tough too. Good luck to both Prajakta and even more so for Ishmeet.