Jhanak Written Update And Episode Discussion thread No 86 - Page 148

Originally posted by: PPak

Ani already told his family he considers J his wife during J's post death ceremony. He also has told Arshi he loves J. Arshi clearly knows this as she has told this to Shristi and further used J's name to entice Ani to sleep with her. Ani already told her to get used to his care for J.

All this dialogs of why you are with her Ani make no sense. He has made it clear he is in love with J and wants her. But with Arshi his stance is not clear. He is not aksing her to leave, Writers even have Minu thinking he should be with Arshi.

Ani has moved away from his stance of asking Arshi to leave because he does not care (2 weeks ago). He specifically asked her to stay and again and again finds excuses to say that his helping J does not mean he will dump Arshi. Till he is certain J will accept him, he wants to keep Arshi because he feels he owes her and has family pressure. This is so against the way he speaks to his family - he is so rude on accasion - it does not seem family can influence him to stick to Arshi - which then implies he wants her as backup for his happiness should J not come thro.

The writing is a big farce and is inconsistent. There is no way to make sense of this. Every episode only makes Ani look worse and J seem like a hypocrite. On one hand - she wants him to go to Arshi didi - on another hand she accepts his help during her hard times and rubs it into Arshi that Ani is with her.

I used to like this show, now its the most nonsensical show I have ever seen in ITV. Krushi is only saving grace.

We were discussing the same problem with the makers...they are trying to portray their leads in a poor light and place Arshi as a victim...which is wrong...there is no logical flow to the story...at this stage, neither of the three leads behaviour or decisions make any sense..

...I am clear about my stance..I will wait to see if pregnancy is false...if not I will quit..If there is a real bachha, there's no point of rooting for Runak, at least for me.

Originally posted by: NITHYAARYA

So much of trolling is going on arshi's character after her intimate scenes where she is forcing ani.maybe she requested makers to do the changes in her character.

I hope KrusHi also makes such requests😂 unki baat koi nahi sunta...har dusre hafte either Ani or Jhanak is being bashed or trolled...this is clearly giving nepotism/favouritism vibe🤣

Originally posted by: AreYaar

LOL if everyone keeps questioning him about his rishta with Jhanak, then yeah he can possibly take some impulsive action regarding that and declare her his wife again......that would very much be in line with the kind of random flips that happen in this show.

But there is Didi ki pregnancy waiting in the wings toh I doubt they will let Runak have any respectability for their rishta.....finger pointing hi chalegi with everyone making cheap insinuations....lol then Jhanak can give her lectures to keep her own image clean and throw Ani under the bus again

Jisko jo karna hai kare! Bas jaldi se preggo track Lana hai to lao so that I can decide mukti milne ka waqt huwa ya nahi from this shit show!🤣🤣

Originally posted by: Dibya_C

Jisko jo karna hai kare! Bas jaldi se preggo track Lana hai to lao so that I can decide mukti milne ka waqt huwa ya nahi from this shit show!🤣🤣

Isiliye toh jaldi laa nahin rahi Leena …she knows people are expecting pregnancy bomb any day now toh pehle woh tassalli se Jhanak and uske Papa ki dastaan dikha rahi hai

She will bring it when she thinks people are getting complacent and least expecting it

Originally posted by: Dibya_C

I hope KrusHi also makes such requests😂 unki baat koi nahi sunta...har dusre hafte either Ani or Jhanak is being bashed or trolled...this is clearly giving nepotism/favouritism vibe🤣

i dont think it is nepotism...even in Imlie story, everyone was speculating that Malini actress was having an affair with the then director; since her screen space was unbearable. In Imlie, Malini was built up well and so her case was a bit justified and the character had some layers even though she went from very good to very evil; the progression made sense. Here Arshi was nominally good in the start, veering to bad many times with excuse of Shristi & Bipasha manipulation and has many a time been white washed by Ani and others. In Imlie the best part was once ML realized he was in love with the FL he was clear in his mind - what he wanted. Not like Anirudh - Ani has been portrayed to be a pathetic weak character post AniArshi marriage - one who blusters when faced with family pressure but in the end always caves in to them.

This is just Leena's style of toxic writing; which is tied back to trp viewer likes. Clearly Chandini has some issues with the script - she is never seen in most Jhanak BTS celebrations. Makers want to play it safe - they say Ani Arshi are married - Ani' calls it official; Arshi says she is his biwi, even Minu is for the couple; yet Arshi tells Shristi marriage did not complete. They want a divorce track, so the ywill stick to the marriage track.

Even tho I love Runak at this point I think story wise its too late for them. Damage has been done. After showing Ani sleeping with Arshi willingly and saying whenever he goes nasdeek to Arshi he sees Jhanak - do you really want to see Runak romance?

Story has lost its charm - baby will be death knell. Makers are playing with fire. Hope it will burn them and teach them a lesson; so future storytelling will be reasonable.

Originally posted by: Dibya_C

We were discussing the same problem with the makers...they are trying to portray their leads in a poor light and place Arshi as a victim...which is wrong...there is no logical flow to the story...at this stage, neither of the three leads behaviour or decisions make any sense..

...I am clear about my stance..I will wait to see if pregnancy is false...if not I will quit..If there is a real bachha, there's no point of rooting for Runak, at least for me.

100% agree. I dont want to see a story where Ani is bound to Arshi for life because of child. Eventually it will become too complicated.

Even Brij - one day he tells J to stay away from Ani next day he wants her to marry him. Are they changing the story on the fly? Still waiting to see how they will reconcile Ani letter and Brij Shristi story. Knowing writers I wont be surprised if J loses the case and is made to look like she was accusing Shristi for her own purposes of hooking Ani - so they can all insult her again.

Originally posted by: Dibya_C

We were discussing the same problem with the makers...they are trying to portray their leads in a poor light and place Arshi as a victim...which is wrong...there is no logical flow to the story...at this stage, neither of the three leads behaviour or decisions make any sense..

...I am clear about my stance..I will wait to see if pregnancy is false...if not I will quit..If there is a real bachha, there's no point of rooting for Runak, at least for me.

100% agree. I dont want to see a story where Ani is bound to Arshi for life because of child. Eventually it will become too complicated and cringe. I want to see a story where J's success changes dynamics between Runak and how they manage it. This Arshi angle has been overly drawn out now. So far nothing good has happened for Jhanak...not a single thing.

Even Brij - one day he tells J to stay away from Ani next day he wants her to marry him. Are they changing the story on the fly? Still waiting to see how they will reconcile Ani letter and Brij Shristi story. Knowing writers I wont be surprised if J loses the case and is made to look like she was accusing Shristi for her own purposes of hooking Ani - so they can all insult her again.

Originally posted by: NITHYAARYA

So much of trolling is going on arshi's character after her intimate scenes where she is forcing ani.maybe she requested makers to do the changes in her character.

Originally posted by: MJ_1009

im also seeing arshi be bashed left right & center to thr point where ppl requested to remove from the montage or get the original montage back..

LOL makers took it too far with this incident of Arshi violating a drunk Ani....iske baad all their attempts to whitewash her don't seem to be working on people since most are still in sadma from what Arshi did that night

They are trying to flip flop Ani and Jhanak's characters as usual so that people don't remember what Arshi did but I don't think it's working so far....and if they do bring the pregnancy, uske baad aur bhi reminder hoga for people how Arshi forced herself on Ani to achieve pregnancy.

In Imlie, Malini didn't rape Ani with the intention of getting pregnant....she just wanted to break Adilie....but here, Arshi very openly showed to the audience her cunning in trying to trap Ani via a pregnancy....who will consider her bechari in this? .....giving Ani one random dialogue about how he imagines Jhanak even around Arshi doesn't make Arshi's actions of forcing a baby from Ani justifiable.