Jhanak Written Update And Episode Discussion thread No 85. - Page 17

Originally posted by: AreYaar

LOL this reasoning would work if Ani had actually married Arshi for real....but he didn't. And Jhanak knows this very well....so then what breaking? There is no MU here either...she knows all the details that rituals were not completed, Arshi is just proclaiming herself wife. Even before the shaadi happened, many times Jhanak called Arshi his wife by claiming almost wife means same thing as wife only

So Jhanak's real problem is that Ani has a past with Arshi....that's what she can't get over no matter how much Ani has clarifed the journey of his feelings to her. Ironically she married Ani with full rituals herself and she knows this but still refuses to give validity to her own shaadi while crying over a fake non-existent shaadi of Anishi.....then this is just self-inflicted torture for no reason. I just can't connect or sympathize with this logic

What I really can't understand is how Jhanak can still keep running away from an Ani who has stood up for his love openly since the HA track....he has shown how much he pines for her and she immediately does out of sight, out of mind on him first chance she gets....that is where Leena's writing is the poorest.

Jab woh saamne aata hai, woh khud ko rok nahin paati from serving him chai parathe, that's it? .....this is how Leena thinks audience will be convinced ki Jhanak still loves him even if she otherwise doesn't even factor him a bit into her life?

Are kya kar sakte he ab toh...

Jhanak ko aur uski pyaar ko samajh ne keliye kuch toh reasoning dena padega...😅

And I agree J has problem with Arshi being in Ani's life and that he had feelings for her for some time...

And I feel like she expects him to come running after her even when she clearly refuses him and pushes him towards Arshi and then gets hurt when he doesn't run after her...🙃

Also I don't know if I'm the only one seeing and if makers ever put this angle forward or not, but I think Jhanak feels she is not worthy of Ani's love because of her status in the society.(Being an illegitimate child and her mother's poor and a maid). I believe she said it to Aditya when she realised she's pregnant...

I guess she feels like she needs validation from Ani in her whole life, be it her career or her own feelings, but she herself doesn't allow it to happen by not communicating properly, not accepting him or even listening to him and hurting him also in the process...

Sometimes I feel like Jhanak's still in her teenager phase of life and needs to learn and grow as a character alot... 🤣

Dekhte he...

Originally posted by: sowmya2407

Also I don't know if I'm the only one seeing and if makers ever put this angle forward or not, but I think Jhanak feels she is not worthy of Ani's love because of her status in the society.(Being an illegitimate child and her mother's poor and a maid). I believe she said it to Aditya when she realised she's pregnant...

I guess she feels like she needs validation from Ani in her whole life, be it her career or her own feelings, but she herself doesn't allow it to happen by not communicating properly, not accepting him or even listening to him and hurting him also in the process...

Sometimes I feel like Jhanak's still in her teenager phase of life and needs to learn and grow as a character alot... 🤣

Dekhte he...

@bold: This is a bang on summary. She definitely wants validation from Ani but DELIBERATELY miscommunicates with him by talking passive aggressive nonsense that always demoralizes and hurts him.

And yes, there is a strain of her feeling she doesn't fit in Ani's world so is unworthy in that sense but then at the same time they have shown her throwing so much attitude about her career in Mumbai also, the way she was so proud and confident about beating Arshi in the Mumbai dance competition....that contradicts this bechari narrative she tries to put out sometimes about how she is unworthy of Ani.....lol only consistent theme that comes through is her resentment that Ani was with Arshi before he met her.

And 100% I feel Jhanak's mentality is still that of a BRAT in many ways...the way she pouts like a child, tries to do her whole bravado act, the bursts of rebellion followed by sudden despair....she is all over the place emotionally just like a hormonal teenager

Even Ani has a childish side to him but nothing beats Jhanak's erratic-ness in my eyes right now

Originally posted by: AreYaar

@bold: This is a bang on summary. She definitely wants validation from Ani but DELIBERATELY miscommunicates with him by talking passive aggressive nonsense that always demoralizes and hurts him.

And yes, there is a strain of her feeling she doesn't fit in Ani's world so is unworthy in that sense but then at the same time they have shown her throwing so much attitude about her career in Mumbai also, the way she was so proud and confident about beating Arshi in the Mumbai dance competition....that contradicts this bechari narrative she tries to put out sometimes about how she is unworthy of Ani.....lol only consistent theme that comes through is her resentment that Ani was with Arshi before he met her.

And 100% I feel Jhanak's mentality is still that of a BRAT in many ways...the way she pouts like a child, tries to do her whole bravado act, the bursts of rebellion followed by sudden despair....she is all over the place emotionally just like a hormonal teenager

Even Ani has a childish side to him but nothing beats Jhanak's erratic-ness in my eyes right now

Mujhe toh Ani's childish side me bhi uski maturity dikhti he, because of how clear his thought process is and we can clearly see what triggered him and made him loose his brain cells... The one and only Jhanak and her behaviour...

But I hope when the makers can push her to this limits to be a villain of the love story, then show her character growth too... Can't keep her like this anymore... This track has the potential for it too...

But as usual dekhte he... Leena mata ki jai ho...

Originally posted by: sowmya2407

Mujhe toh Ani's childish side me bhi uski maturity dikhti he, because of how clear his thought process is and we can clearly see what triggered him and made him loose his brain cells... The one and only Jhanak and her behaviour...

But I hope when the makers can push her to this limits to be a villain of the love story, then show her character growth too... Can't keep her like this anymore... This track has the potential for it too...

But as usual dekhte he... Leena mata ki jai ho...

Leena has made Ani so soft and extra vulnerable since Jhanak's death....matlab alag level ka lost puppy look hai uski eyes mein ab .

Jhanak has special willpower to not be moved by his pain one bit even when he's looking at her with those lost puppy eyes....lol

Imagine, some time back this guy was just shown constantly stewing in his MUs and anger towards Jhanak....yes there was pain in him then also but the anger used to blind him more. But look at him now....ekdum bleeding heart ban gaya hai and he can't make sense of anything without Jhanak being with him. He has clearly demonstrated that he needs her to function and Jhanak still doesn't take it seriously

Baaki yeah let's see if Leena Aunty has any intention of ever showing any growth in Jhanak beyond randomly jumping on new missions other people put in front of her.....lol

Originally posted by: AreYaar

Leena has made Ani so soft and extra vulnerable since Jhanak's death....matlab alag level ka lost puppy look hai uski eyes mein ab .

Jhanak has special willpower to not be moved by his pain one bit even when he's looking at her with those lost puppy eyes....lol

Imagine, some time back this guy was just shown constantly stewing in his MUs and anger towards Jhanak....yes there was pain in him then also but the anger used to blind him more. But look at him now....ekdum bleeding heart ban gaya hai and he can't make sense of anything without Jhanak being with him. He has clearly demonstrated that he needs her to function and Jhanak still doesn't take it seriously

Baaki yeah let's see if Leena Aunty has any intention of ever showing any growth in Jhanak beyond randomly jumping on new missions other people put in front of her.....lol

Yeah, this Ani is so heart wrenching, I don't know how can Jhanak not get his pain...

Baaki, I don't want him to stay like this for long, he gave his all to his love for J and she still left him, betrayed him. Gussa aana chahiye. Aur kuch interesting karna chahiye use...

In all this, everyone left him alone, even Jhanak, he's the only one fighting...

The whole story of Jhanak show with all its characters on one side and Aniruddh's pain, his thought process, his decisions and his journey on one side...

I think shuru se hi aisa hi tha, but now it got a lot more worse, he's even more exhiled from everyone's life now.... Thanks to his pagalpan for Jhanak....

Originally posted by: sowmya2407

Yeah, this Ani is so heart wrenching, I don't know how can Jhanak not get his pain...

Baaki, I don't want him to stay like this for long, he gave his all to his love for J and she still left him, betrayed him. Gussa aana chahiye. Aur kuch interesting karna chahiye use...

In all this, everyone left him alone, even Jhanak, he's the only one fighting...

The whole story of Jhanak show with all its characters on one side and Aniruddh's pain, his thought process, his decisions and his journey on one side...

I think shuru se hi aisa hi tha, but now it got a lot more worse, he's even more exhiled from everyone's life now.... Thanks to his pagalpan for Jhanak....

@bold: Yes, I also want him to show his hurt on learning that Jhanak faked her death to stay hidden from him and yeh Nutan banne ka drama kar rahi hai to keep him thinking she's dead.

But lag raha hai Leena will cover all this up by showing her say she did this to help Daddy get his revenge toh Ani ka gussa melt karva denge ki oh this was all for a higher cause ....

I would love to be proven wrong on this by Leena and Jhanak deserves to get solid daant from him for doing this with him but lag raha hai Majnu will just be too overwhelmed with relief that she is alive

After watching the epi, the timeline of events again seemed confusing today like they papered over things

So Srishti dumped the baby on Urvashi and left and Urvashi started raising the kid.....we aren't shown when exactly Srishti/Kul came back to kill BBG but looks like we should presume that AFTER the switch happened, THEN Srishti started spreading rumors that the baby was Urvashi-BBG ka and Urvashi was living without shaadi with BBG.....so Urvashi started putting on sindoor to give legitimacy to herself and the baby but she was never actually married to BBG. Then around that time Kul threw Urvashi and the baby out of the house and after that Urvashi lived the rest of her life believing Jhanak to be her baby and feeling betrayed by BBG that she was raising his kid but he never acknowledged her.

BBG also casually papered over his part today ki oh I did try to search for my beti after my life was saved but I couldn't manage to communicate with Urvashi and then later on I just became sant and disappeared but I knew one day I would meet my daughter again.....LOL umm that is not how he was behaving when he learnt of the possibility of this being his daughter in the aashram....Leena flipping so conveniently again ....bas itna rona dhona karke he managed to melt Jhanak and she quickly embraced PAPA.....he barely even gave friendship to Urvashi but he's telling Jhanak now that I realized later on that Urvashi was the real heera and I would have been honored to have her either as wife or friend in my life .....wow poor Urvashi just ended up becoming an abstract saint in all this without having any man who actually loved her

And the Srishti-Vinayak convo was again weird.....it seems like Vinayak knows Jhanak is Srishti's daughter that Urvashi has raised but he didn't know about BBG having a twin brother? And he also made a reference to how Srishti spread rumors to defame Urvashi and didn't stand by her....so it seems like after she helped Kul kill BBG, then Srishti defamed Urvashi by claiming that the baby Urvashi was raising was BBG and Urvashi ka baby even though Srishti knew that was her najayaz baccha only. Ok then

Why did Urvashi mention in that letter that she married BB and jhanak is not paap but pyaar ki nishani. Im xurious how they will weave that letter in the story now.

Originally posted by: AreYaar

After watching the epi, the timeline of events again seemed confusing today like they papered over things

So Srishti dumped the baby on Urvashi and left and Urvashi started raising the kid.....we aren't shown when exactly Srishti/Kul came back to kill BBG but looks like we should presume that AFTER the switch happened, THEN Srishti started spreading rumors that the baby was Urvashi-BBG ka and Urvashi was living without shaadi with BBG.....so Urvashi started putting on sindoor to give legitimacy to herself and the baby but she was never actually married to BBG. Then around that time Kul threw Urvashi and the baby out of the house and after that Urvashi lived the rest of her life believing Jhanak to be her baby and feeling betrayed by BBG that she was raising his kid but he never acknowledged her.

BBG also casually papered over his part today ki oh I did try to search for my beti after my life was saved but I couldn't manage to communicate with Urvashi and then later on I just became sant and disappeared but I knew one day I would meet my daughter again.....LOL umm that is not how he was behaving when he learnt of the possibility of this being his daughter in the aashram....Leena flipping so conveniently again ....bas itna rona dhona karke he managed to melt Jhanak and she quickly embraced PAPA.....he barely even gave friendship to Urvashi but he's telling Jhanak now that I realized later on that Urvashi was the real heera and I would have been honored to have her either as wife or friend in my life .....wow poor Urvashi just ended up becoming an abstract saint in all this without having any man who actually loved her

And the Srishti-Vinayak convo was again weird.....it seems like Vinayak knows Jhanak is Srishti's daughter that Urvashi has raised but he didn't know about BBG having a twin brother? And he also made a reference to how Srishti spread rumors to defame Urvashi and didn't stand by her....so it seems like after she helped Kul kill BBG, then Srishti defamed Urvashi by claiming that the baby Urvashi was raising was BBG and Urvashi ka baby even though Srishti knew that was her najayaz baccha only. Ok then

Originally posted by: hade

Why did Urvashi mention in that letter that she married BB and jhanak is not paap but pyaar ki nishani. Im xurious how they will weave that letter in the story now.

The letter angle will get papered over somehow it seems.

Today BBG had a line about him wondering why Urvashi never told Jhanak the whole truth about her birth but his presumption is that if Srishti had found out that Jhanak knows her truth, she would have tried to kill Jhanak so that's why Urvashi didn't tell her.

Not sure why Urvashi lied in her last letter also about being married to BBG.....lol I guess Leena is counting on people having forgotten the details of the letter.

I think most of us remember every detail of the golden runak jhanak days aka kashmir!! She can change however but we know and remember it😂

Originally posted by: AreYaar

The letter angle will get papered over somehow it seems.

Today BBG had a line about him wondering why Urvashi never told Jhanak the whole truth about her birth but his presumption is that if Srishti had found out that Jhanak knows her truth, she would have tried to kill Jhanak so that's why Urvashi didn't tell her.

Not sure why Urvashi lied in her last letter also about being married to BBG.....lol I guess Leena is counting on people having forgotten the details of the letter.