Shamita&Scarlett Act! Standing Ovation? 40? Seriously! - Page 3

I soo agree with you..I was literally shocked with d kind of comments they received..This act was No where around the original one done by ash n madhuri..I don't knw how can they even compare it with the one!! Due to the reaction of judges I initially thought dat its only me who dint find it good..or may be my mind is not working properly..Lol bcz after watching the performance dis kind of reaction was so unexpected!

acha hota madhuri judge hoti😆

Anyway scarlet got ladoos because of Shamita

That was a 32/33 performance. Like what the hell? There steps weren't even matching BELOW AVERAGE act.

I don't care about how many free laddoos Shamita got...they will keep her till the finale that's for sure otherwise we will see some tantrums shown by her loved ones. I'm just happy Sanaya got the immunity ball and POTW!!

I enjoyed the performance. maybe it deserved a 40 in terms of dance. im not really familiar with indian dance styles but one mark should definitely be deducted for copying the same thing from the movie. There is no originality in the performance

They were better than what I saw in the sneak peek, but not worth 40. For one, there was nothing new, they simply tried to copy the original. Scarlett cannot do Indian dance .. she lacks the grace in both movements and expressions. Ganesh said she toned down her aggressiveness, but I didn't see it. Shamita was better, but their coordination was poor, and the grace and beauty of the dance was absent. They concentrated on the steps, and missed out on the expressions completely. The hand movements were very jerky at places.

Agree with you. I liked the performance but it was NOT 40-worthy performance. None of the performances today were that good, though I enjoyed them all.

Shamita and Scarlett's was a very generic performance in my opinion. The dresses were not original and looked exactly like the ones from the actual song video. Some of the dance moves were even directly copied from the actual song. What's the point of having TWO choreos working together (esp. one as good as Deepak) if they "borrow" some dance moves from the original video?

They also did not perfectly execute the song. Lots of errors in coordination. Scarlett's dance is still kinda rough. She needs to soften up a bit. Shamita was better. But you could clearly see the differences between the two and it did not appear as a uniform, coordinated dance.

In my honest opinion, they did not deserve more than a 7 or 8 out of 10 by each judge. The scoring is just abysmal and so extremely inconsistent on this show now that I stopped listening to the judges comments and just watch the performances now.