JDJ S8 ::Episode Discussion Live Updates #1:: DT Note Pg 37/ 86 - Page 23

Created

Last reply

Replies

1.1k

Views

90.1k

Users

153

Likes

2.2k

Frequent Posters

.Jane.. thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: AvadaKedavra


I can agree with you there but as far as I know, channels care more about an actor's recent shows...if they have a TRP pull and etc etc...and Irani's last two shows did nothing for her...yes she has a huge fan-following courtesy of IPK but her last two shows made a dent on her credibility (am not talking about her credibility as an actor here but her credibility as a TRP puller)...seeing that it's not hard to understand why Colors would pay Dsena more than Irani. Just my two cents.


I believe you. Like I said, I don't know (and frankly don't care about) how the payments work in the industry. So I guess what you're saying makes sense from recovery of cost PoV. I guess sitting at home has it's perks after all =)
FromTheAshes thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
Edited😃
Edited by .MysticalWaters - 10 years ago
Basilisk thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: .Jane..


I believe you. Like I said, I don't know (and frankly don't care about) how the payments work in the industry. So I guess what you're saying makes sense from recovery of cost PoV. I guess sitting at home has it's perks after all =)



@Bold: Hahahahahaha Nice one 😉😆

Honestly, I don't know much about these things as well...I'm just guess-timating 😆😆
RainAndRainbow thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: .Jane..


But Sanaya, though only a couple of years his senior in the industry, is a more accomplished actress with way more body of work than Vivian. You're looking at their solo lead shows, I am talking from the PoV of an overall career graph. I confess I don't know how payments work on Indian tv but in a perfect world, she deserves more compensation. If Vivian is indeed higher paid than Sanaya, then I think more than popularity or hits it's probably the very real problem of unequal pay.

I agree, irani is far better actor then dsena!! I mean seriously Dsena is woody at his best!! I don't know abt irani as actress didnt watch her shows but my friend is her fan,and is quite un-biased on her views says she is quite a decent actor!!!but Indian television is more on trp hits!! U bring them trp you are paid high, u don't bring trp,u gonna struck in bottom! (though irani isn't in bottom )I think even BW is based on hits... More hits more fat cheque!! Isn't it??? Same in TW too😆
965319 thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
Can we rename the thread?
How about-Stirring the pot between VD and SI fans.😉
or
100 ways to earn money,ghar baithe by Vivian Dsena.
Edited by mai1moono - 10 years ago
.Jane.. thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: -Patronus-

I agree, irani is far better actor then dsena!! I mean seriously Dsena is woody at his best!! I don't know abt irani as actress didnt watch her shows but my friend is her fan,and is quite un-biased on her views says she is quite a decent actor!!!but Indian television is more on trp hits!! U bring them trp you are paid high, u don't bring trp,u gonna struck in bottom! (though irani isn't in bottom )I think even BW is based on hits... More hits more fat cheque!! Isn't it??? Same in TW too😆


I actually liked Vivian in PKYEK. He isn't very versatile but what he can do, he does well I feel. But Sanaya is naturally talented and her performances are very honest and heartfelt. I really feel she's underrated in terms of awards recognition. I know from IF PoV non-fans find her overhyped but I feel she's been robbed on many occasions if we look outside the online world.
But I digress. Bollywood is nothing but nepotism but TRPs deciding the paycheck of a tv actor, to me, does not make much sense. It might be the case of course, I take your word for it. But imho, hits or misses of a show depend on the writing and how much the plot of the show clicks with the audiences, not the actors. You can't tell me Vivian got Madhubala it's TRPs. Star One did not have that kind of a mass reach and PKYEK did well only by the standards of that channel.
Chaiya_Chaiya thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 10 years ago
This isn't live, but my view on today's episode:
Liked the episode for the most part but then it started to go downheel from Subhreet's performance with crying and other "fluff" with Shahid.

What's up with the scores?

Radhika and Subreet were way overscored.

Radhika's performance was a visual treat, but only technological wise. Otherwise, I didn't see much dancing. Plus they were off sync couple of times. How come no one noticed/commented? And what the hell was Lauren thinking when she gave her a 10?

Don't even know what they will do with Simar. They already used her in the intro scene as Simar v.s Deepika. I'm dreading tomorrow's episode with there gaganess over Deepika/Simar. Lol, I wouldn't be surprised if Karan's mom "watches" the show and talks to him about it! LOL. And probably her rona dhona about managing two shows. Gosh, if it's so hard, than don't do Jhalak. You might get an offer next year.

Subhreet: there was too much of sympathy. Overall her perfromance was okay. She truly is an inspiration, but when she is competing in a dance show at this level, she should be judged with the same measuring stick. Giving her a ten was too much. Especialy when her upper body with exception to hands is very stiff. I understand she can't really be flexible when she is standing, but what about when she is sitting or when Diwakar is supporting her? So 3 judeges giving her 10 is too much. If her performance continues at this level, she may not go far as sympathy votes can only take you so far.

Faisal was my favorite. With that kind of prop, it's probably lot harder than it looks. He is a great dancer and is one of the contestants whom I will look forward to seeing--along with Sanaya of course, my #1 reason. Felt Faisal's scores were right, maybe 37 would do.

Shamita came close second, but Shamita was a little underscored. Especially when we compare her performance with Radhika's. All her moves were crisp and clear and liked almost everything except the moonwalk. She can improve on that.

Vivian and Mohit's dance choreography was about the same quality and they were scored about right. Vivian probably should have scored a point or two less considering his energy went down at the end whereas Mohit's was constant throughout the performance. They both seem hardworking types of contestants and hopefully they will improve with time. Let's face it, Vivian will probably go far in the competition due to voting, and if I am watching him, I would like to see improved vivian than what I saw today.

Judges:

Shahid: He seemed more like a host than a judge. I like Shahid, but this episode was Shahid overload. It seemed like he was everywhere where Manish needed to be. I missed Manish eventhough, he was there. Does it make sense?

Karan: Probably one of the best judges. Though wasn't happy with his marks and Subhreet sympathy promotion.

Ganesh: Was he even there? Maybe he also got overshadowed with Shahid overload. He is supposed to be a technical judge. I'm surprised sync issue went unnoticed by him in Radhika's performance.

Lauren: Less said the better. She seems pretentious as a judge. Can we not replace her with Malaika Arora Khan? Have watched Malaika in NB 1 & 2, Zara Nachke Dikha, couple of episodes of JDJ, and last 2 seasons of IGT and I love her. Her scoring and comments are on the mark.

I really hope the scores were like this because it's a first episode. Tomorrow is again going to be like today on the score front, but let's hope it gets better from next week.

Host:

Manish: As I said earlier, would prefer to see him host the show than Shahid.
.Jane.. thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 10 years ago
@nine2: Lol, that awkward moment when the other three are accomplished dancers but KJo is the best judge! No but I agree. KJo was surprisingly good yesterday. Yea he's a little flamboyant but that's how he is. I think more than KJo himself, I got annoyed at the trimurti of Remo-Madhuri-KJo. Somehow, the panel did not work for me!
And I agree with toning down of Shahid as well. Believe me, if it wasn't for him I probably would've given this season a miss but certain things really felt out of place to me.
I miss Manish too. He's hands down the best male host Indian tv has seen and this episode really undermined that.
.Jane.. thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: -Patronus-

ahhh we have very different views I see😆Vivian was terrible in PKYEK!! Both leads sucked in acting!!! I actually loved mummy n papa vampire n Sid ( bro vampire) they stole the show in terms of acting!!! Dsena as RK was better!! N no its not the dsena or Drashti who bought Trps!! Its the story writing and how it's presented to the audience!!!
As I said no idea on how naturally talented irani is as actor, I saw a tids bits of IPK in the starting found her annoying!!Later might be she improved but didn't see it!!
Star one was never a trp puller...like MTV just a channel for younger audience!!!


That's alright😆 I agree with Mummy-Papa and Bhaiya vampire being the best actors though. Along with Priya Wal.
Did you find Sanaya's acting annoying or Khushi's reactions? Because there is a difference. And it might be that her acting is not for you, which is perfectly fine. A few very critically acclaimed actors' performances don't work for me, not because I find their acting bad but they just don't touch me and I don't connect to their portrayal as an audience :)
ViccoTurmeric thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
You really think its because of 'TRPS' and 'success' due to which Dsena is paid more than Sanaya?
Wake up people! Its a male dominated society...

Male actors be it in Bollywood or TV industry are paid more than female costars...

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".