Unfair Judging Or the Format?

Originally posted by: KrishnaKalpana

I am follower of the show from the first season and I loved the concept and it was quite unique unlike other dance reality shows.

But nowadays I feel its the wrong judgement or the format which is making it annoying to watch. Sorry to say this but the bharathnatyam act yesterday was pathetic. There was no bharthnatyam in it. It only had the bharthnatyam costumes but nothing else. If it was presented in some other name it was ok to watch but this was really annoying.

And the tragic part is the judgement. If any normal dancer, you dont need Remo or Madhuri to judge it; or even a common man who really have watched even one bharatnatyam dance on stage would never say it was near to anything that can be called bharatnatyam. And it did not deserve anything more than 5/10.

And the comments which says this was done in just one week, sorry but when they judge other western dance forms doesnt that also happen in the same one week and that too by some non dancing celebrities? I am not expecting a person to learn it in one week and give to to perfection if they do what they are capable of then judge it accordingly.

Why is this happening you need to think!!!!

This post is not to bash any contestant or to make the fans unhappy. But this is the truth atleast according to me.

I like all the contestant and love to watch their performances, but you should have a fair treatment towards all the contestants.

PS. I am a Drashti fan and hope me making the post will not create another 100 hate topics on her. This is my opinion on the show format/judgement and an act. and not the hate for any contestants.

Originally posted by: handlessthakur

The judging on this show has always been off...Salman Drashti have got 30s for medicore acts and rip offs of Salman's past perfomances..and the wheelchair act they did last week, it wasnt even worth 20 yet got 24

coming to Lauren, the only problem for me was her stiffness ..and Punit lost his balance in the end..u cant expect pure bharatnatyam in one week..what they did was good enough considering all the contraints..and I feel learning Bharatnatyam in one week is much more tougher than learning western dance forms..and sorry to say but apart from Sana noone else has learnt much of western forms in this show..Drashti is at the exact same position where she was at the start of the show..no growth nothing..all she did all these weeks is lifts and more lifts..I am not bringing her in this topic cos u are her fan but because u said that non dancers are learning western forms in one week..sorry but Drashti and Shaan arent..and kids are repititive..so if these guys an score 30/30 for repetitive perfomances, Lauren can for sure score 28 for her effort and Punit's choreography

Originally posted by: samana17

haha! I didn't watch their performance but I think even the judges said that it was not perfect.
And regarding being unfair I dun even know why was sana kicked out!
The only actual 'JUDGE' there is remo. The other two are just for the trp of the show.

Originally posted by: kingkisunshine

@bold bang on yaar...

i was abt to make a topic on the exact points u have return... its not oly Lauren who learns dance forms in a week... but each and every celebrity does that...rite.. i think MD sudn't hav said that... instead cud have said some other things...i mean it can let down any other contestants..coz all are putting in their efforts for a week oly...

PS: this is just a view on wat MD said... not becoz she praised Lauren r to bash her...

Originally posted by: handlessthakur

The judging on this show has always been off...Salman Drashti have got 30s for medicore acts and rip offs of Salman's past perfomances..and the wheelchair act they did last week, it wasnt even worth 20 yet got 24

coming to Lauren, the only problem for me was her stiffness ..and Punit lost his balance in the end..u cant expect pure bharatnatyam in one week..what they did was good enough considering all the contraints..and I feel learning Bharatnatyam in one week is much more tougher than learning western dance forms..and sorry to say but apart from Sana noone else has learnt much of western forms in this show..Drashti is at the exact same position where she was at the start of the show..no growth nothing..all she did all these weeks is lifts and more lifts..I am not bringing her in this topic cos u are her fan but because u said that non dancers are learning western forms in one week..sorry but Drashti and Shaan arent..and kids are repititive..so if these guys an score 30/30 for repetitive perfomances, Lauren can for sure score 28 for her effort and Punit's choreography

Originally posted by: KrishnaKalpana

I am not saying that Drashti or Shaan are doing perfect western forms,because I am no one to comment. I have seen this western dances in indian shows only. So I donno how exactly it should be. And I feel they are getting the scores not ( 30) based on their act adn no one gets the comments like awesome/awestruct or something like Lauren got for this bharatnatyam act. I am an Indian have seen many bharatnatyam dance performance even learned it in my child hood. So felt really bad when on national telivision the judges going gaga over a performance which was no were near to Bharatnatyam.

Thanks that you atleast agreed there were some flaws. I also agree that the kids always show more lifts than dance, and I think yesterday it was pointed out.