i really have enough of madhuri - Page 10

Created

Last reply

Replies

143

Views

17.3k

Users

49

Likes

348

Frequent Posters

ayaan786 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#91

Originally posted by: FingerFetish

Madhuri is a great dancer no doubt. But the only actress that can actually tackle her in dance would definitely have to be Aishwarya Rai. In Devdas, she just about kicked her ass in Dola Re Dola. I don't care if Madhuri was pregnant, she was jumping around and spinning around just as fast. But Aishwarya completely overshadowed her in that performance.

i also cant understand why people are calling aishwariya rai a non dancer

she is one of the finest dancer that our industry had and its not that she is doing very difficult steps but every movement of her has an just an exceptional grace which is so soothing to watch

and i will stay to that aishwariya rai is in dancing and acting wise better than madhuri dixit hands down😃


edit: 32 members wants madhuri to be replaced and 28 wants her to stay

so we are in the majority 😃



Edited by ayaan786 - 12 years ago
Shaitan-Haiwan thumbnail
Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail 13th Anniversary Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 12 years ago
#92
Are you kidding me?
Madhuri fans actually think she is good at western dance? LMFAO what a joke.
Indian dancing can be argued. But there is no way in hell Madhuri is good at western. She looks like a try-hard aunty when she does western dancing. She got murdered in Dil Toh Pagal Hai and in Dola Re as well. That's why Ash's career took off even higher after Devdas, whereas Madhuri ran away to the states because she had no career.
Maybe her dhak dhak days she was good, because she would pump her chest and make moaning expressions. But defiantly by 1997-1998 she was done. Even Kay Sera Sera is overrated. Sonakshi recently danced with Prabu Deva too, I found her the same as Madhuri. Nothing great.
You would honestly have to be blind to think she is good at western dancing. Lets look at the street dancing that Katrina did in Jab Tak Hai Jaan. The ishq dance, there is no way madhuri could have pulled that off. She has a very aunty type of body language.
Even recently she performed at awards show trying to do western and she looked stupid to me.
423728 thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#93

Originally posted by: khamosshhh



But in my POV it was Madhuri who walked away with all the honours. Dance wise dey may have been at par, but from where would u get the expressions that Madhuri does?
[/QUOTE

What honours though? Devdas was Aishwarya Rai's biggest breakthrough. For all I know, based on rewards, recognition and fame - it was Aish that walked away with everything. What expressions? I couldn't see Madhuri during the Dola Re performance. Do you know why? Because Aishwarya Rai COMPLETELY demolished her in that dance. Don't get me wrong, Madhuri is very good with her facial expressions but dancing does not always rely on expressions - you gotta know how to dance as well.

So scrap the expression bit and focus solely on the dance. It was obvious that Aishwarya Rai danced better in that song.

893917 thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#94
Aish aunty should have another kid instead.
I think Mads is just made for this show. If not her, then I would say Sridevi.
ayaan786 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#95

Originally posted by: GoodfellaSnoop

Aish aunty should have another kid instead.

I think Mads is just made for this show. If not her, then I would say Sridevi.

seriously this comment is disgusting why are you getting in her personal life if you noticed we are discussing about acting and dancing skills dont need to get personal

and also one thing same could be said for madhuri so please let it be

enigmatic_zephy thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#96

Originally posted by: Shaitan-Haiwan

Are you kidding me?

Madhuri fans actually think she is good at western dance? LMFAO what a joke.
Indian dancing can be argued. But there is no way in hell Madhuri is good at western. She looks like a try-hard aunty when she does western dancing. She got murdered in Dil Toh Pagal Hai and in Dola Re as well. That's why Ash's career took off even higher after Devdas, whereas Madhuri ran away to the states because she had no career.
Maybe her dhak dhak days she was good, because she would pump her chest and make moaning expressions. But defiantly by 1997-1998 she was done. Even Kay Sera Sera is overrated. Sonakshi recently danced with Prabu Deva too, I found her the same as Madhuri. Nothing great.
You would honestly have to be blind to think she is good at western dancing. Lets look at the street dancing that Katrina did in Jab Tak Hai Jaan. The ishq dance, there is no way madhuri could have pulled that off. She has a very aunty type of body language.
Even recently she performed at awards show trying to do western and she looked stupid to me.


key sera sera Vs Dhoom...aish is an average dancer...and as an actress to mat hi bulwao..she is overly limited in her skills..she can play only one role..SLB women...or lets say SLB is an exceptional director to be able to make this woman act...

dancing - def a let down..

the only actress i think who in the same frame as Madz has beaten her hands down..thats Karishma...i was quite surprised when i saw that movie..no other person could have done that..

I also think sri is a decent dancer...

u speak of dola re...observe aish carefully..her dancing is too technical..it doesn't hv a life of its own..she can't add her own charm or variability to it..

and no variability does not mean changing choreography...

its just how you maaro a thumka..the technical aspect is same..but there is always sthg different when 5 people do it..body language..Aish is never a performance u can connect to..

plus when it comes to expressions, it is absolutely difficult to connect with her..

for me very few of her performances are great..infact till date i like her first performance the best..atleast there was innocence..'thoda sa pagla thoda saayana'.. dhoom is decent, SLB..all is fine..indian setting she is ok..

In BW, hardly any actress is a truly gud dancer..maybe anushka in recent times..but i have seen only rab ne bana di jodi..
enigmatic_zephy thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#97
Q: Exactly what would Aishwarya do in this show..
sit uptight in the middle, give stern looks to everyone...then do the plastic smile and giggle when cue is given...and then maaro the accent (oh well that can be a competition to the firang participants)..

what will she do??

Aish is another diplomatic soul...she wud be boring like hell..atleast madz smiles and comes across as easy going..

Aish wud be like that weird school teacher ..who knows how to suck the fun out of it..

lol..and the biggest question..how wud colors promote Big boss if she is on the show..😆
enigmatic_zephy thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#98

Originally posted by: GoodfellaSnoop

Aish aunty should have another kid instead.

I think Mads is just made for this show. If not her, then I would say Sridevi.


another rishta.com fan..heylo!
jyothi- thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#99

Originally posted by: enigmatic_zephy

Q: Exactly what would Aishwarya do in this show..

sit uptight in the middle, give stern looks to everyone...then do the plastic smile and giggle when cue is given...and then maaro the accent (oh well that can be a competition to the firang participants)..

what will she do??

Aish is another diplomatic soul...she wud be boring like hell..atleast madz smiles and comes across as easy going..

Aish wud be like that weird school teacher ..who knows how to suck the fun out of it..

lol..and the biggest question..how wud colors promote Big boss if she is on the show..😆

Agree with u.
Ash's body is stiff and she is expressionless.She knows only one expression ie constipation wala expression.MD is any day better dancer and her 400 watts smile is enough.MD is kathak trained dancer her mudra is too good.
-Se-Rene- thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago

Originally posted by: jyothi-m

Agree with u.

Ash's body is stiff and she is expressionless.She knows only one expression ie constipation wala expression.MD is any day better dancer and her 400 watts smile is enough.MD is kathak trained dancer her mudra is too good.

I am not sure about Madhuris credibility in western and aerobatics but I can vouch for her excellency in Indian dance. The skill level she achieved all these years of experience and learning she can emote dance with her eyes, smile and attitude. In last season even sarod khan and viabhavi could not match her to her steps.

Aishwarya is technically right in her moves and I just watched dola re again and yes Madhuri was well with her expressions but due to her heavy personality compared to elongated personality of Aishwarya her dance looked pale.

As a subjective matter still Madhuri is best for me.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".