Originally posted by: Shaitan-Haiwan
Are you kidding me?
Madhuri fans actually think she is good at western dance? LMFAO what a joke.
Indian dancing can be argued. But there is no way in hell Madhuri is good at western. She looks like a try-hard aunty when she does western dancing. She got murdered in Dil Toh Pagal Hai and in Dola Re as well. That's why Ash's career took off even higher after Devdas, whereas Madhuri ran away to the states because she had no career.
Maybe her dhak dhak days she was good, because she would pump her chest and make moaning expressions. But defiantly by 1997-1998 she was done. Even Kay Sera Sera is overrated. Sonakshi recently danced with Prabu Deva too, I found her the same as Madhuri. Nothing great.
You would honestly have to be blind to think she is good at western dancing. Lets look at the street dancing that Katrina did in Jab Tak Hai Jaan. The ishq dance, there is no way madhuri could have pulled that off. She has a very aunty type of body language.
Even recently she performed at awards show trying to do western and she looked stupid to me.
key sera sera Vs Dhoom...aish is an average dancer...and as an actress to mat hi bulwao..she is overly limited in her skills..she can play only one role..SLB women...or lets say SLB is an exceptional director to be able to make this woman act...
dancing - def a let down..
the only actress i think who in the same frame as Madz has beaten her hands down..thats Karishma...i was quite surprised when i saw that movie..no other person could have done that..
I also think sri is a decent dancer...
u speak of dola re...observe aish carefully..her dancing is too technical..it doesn't hv a life of its own..she can't add her own charm or variability to it..
and no variability does not mean changing choreography...
its just how you maaro a thumka..the technical aspect is same..but there is always sthg different when 5 people do it..body language..Aish is never a performance u can connect to..
plus when it comes to expressions, it is absolutely difficult to connect with her..
for me very few of her performances are great..infact till date i like her first performance the best..atleast there was innocence..'thoda sa pagla thoda saayana'.. dhoom is decent, SLB..all is fine..indian setting she is ok..
In BW, hardly any actress is a truly gud dancer..maybe anushka in recent times..but i have seen only rab ne bana di jodi..