Is the show really rigged or is it just in our mind - Page 9

Created

Last reply

Replies

97

Views

11.8k

Users

45

Likes

566

Frequent Posters

Bazigar thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#81

Originally posted by: ANNMT.


i think it's ur first year on jdj forum , ye har saal hota hai , aap jinko bol rhey hai vo bhi asey hi ek sensitive fan group se hai , she is also from a sensitive blind fan group jo nastily abuse karte hain logo ko jobless , hater bolte hain n when somebody retaliate in same words , they cry n go to mod to bann that member

aap dua kare ki gc kabhi big boss pe naa aaye , varna inke group ka jalwa apko vnha dekhne milega , 1 week mai rule change kara denge saare by mods 😛


I dont think the thread starter initiated this thread on the basis of any bais because , she tried to cover all seasons and try to have a healthy discussion , May be she like all views on sporting gesture including those who criticise DD that many did not like 😆 . If she is a die hard fan of someone who won show in past then she should not raise this question at all. .Still she already proved her innocent in Shahrukh style .Or should we expect to punch her hand in nana patkar krantiveer movei style and show the blood this is GC fan blood , this is DD fan , now tell me the difference.😆

Weather that is GC, barun sobti, or DD a in every serials die hard fans will always defend their protagonist, never will tolerate any criticize and lastly try to impose their view by believing all should be painted one colour . We can witness fans of Urvashi in BB last year. So GC fan group and DD fan is nothing different. For more proof write in their respective forum -- I dont like such moon walking fake acting , so i dislike this actor - see the reaction may be that batli will not be on your hand..😆

Yes even past idol like urvashi create such havoc then forget about current telly star in bigg boss. 😲 still to face that many old BB members are there who will unite who have difference earlier to face new havoc😆
Edited by ramjaane - 11 years ago
Bazigar thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#82

Originally posted by: ANNMT.


no , i m saying he did not got votes , whenever a person got this kind of vots there r huge news about that n last season was super flop , even this season was better , they had to keep bhaarti for trp , so u can see how that difficult for them , when people won by reginal votes then trp goeshigh
that banner does not proved he got reginal votes , i said i saw isha n drasti's banner also , by ur point drasti is also getting vots from gujraat bcs she also has this kind of banner in her support , so i dont know is this true ki not she is getting reginal votes also , yes she is getting fans votes definitely , but only bcs of one banner i cant belive yaar ki she is getting votes , supports from her state also

that is true bihaar , up voting mai bahot peechey hain compare to north east , punjab n others ..., north east is come on number one in this kind of crazy voting , u can chack , ask any body , this is fact


This regional emotion is there in every where. Thats why starting from politicians to reality all exploit that emotion . Regarding the craziness this is still there everywhere in the initial days of reality shows and after nearly 5 years it faded away from public bcoz everyone understood what crap the star is related and what they will get in this craziness , more it to boredom and repitation. So if earlier it was say contribute to the reason of winning 60% then may be it comes to 20%. In indian Idol 1 infact it was election, people from mumbai and eastern side of india send sms crazily, in mumbai there was a big celebration but now a hardly anyone send sms on the basis of same regional factor there. Regarding north east , channel itself may consciously choose someone as contestant from a unstrapped market like north east and where people also desire to prove something in mainstream.

more then sms , In the rigging of show winner this regional popular opinion sometime considered because channel cant miff many viewers in that specific reason. All fair in ROI return on investment in reality show.

So this craziness faded away to a lot extent that we compare to earlier. Already channels milked it to maximum extent . Still contestant are souting bihar ka laal, ami bengali babu , marthi mulgi, Gujrat ni chokri etc. So it is a falacy to compare the same trend from early past to current one.
Edited by ramjaane - 11 years ago
826374 thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#83

Originally posted by: ramjaane


I dont think the thread starter initiated this thread on the basis of any bais because , she tried to cover all seasons and try to have a healthy discussion , May be she like all views on sporting gesture including those who criticise DD that many did not like 😆 . If she is a die hard fan of someone who won show in past then she should not raise this question at all. .Still she already proved her innocent in Shahrukh style .Or should we expect to punch her hand in nana patkar krantiveer movei style and show the blood this is GC fan blood , this is DD fan , now tell me the difference.😆

well , i never doubted on her intention , galat accusation on me my lord 😆

Weather that is GC, barun sobti, or DD a in every serials die hard fans will always defend their protagonist, never will tolerate any criticize and lastly try to impose their view by believing all should be painted one colour . We can witness fans of Urvashi in BB last year. So GC fan group and DD fan is nothing different. For more proof write in their respective forum -- I dont like such moon walking fake acting , so i dislike this actor - see the reaction may be that batli will not be on your hand..😆

yes , i said the same thing , but u r talking with her that how fans nasty ho jaate hain n logo ko bann karvaate hain , u said this for drasti fans , i cleared it by saying it's not first time last year bhi asa hi hua tha n she is also from that same group , so all fans r like that , even when gc got 19 then they voted for him blindly , he was also not deserving but they voted na , so now when they pick on other fan group for same thing jo khud ye log kar chuke hai , there they shows their double standard , i saw them commenting on other actors by saying " shitty act ," but when people said same thing for gc in season 5 , fans ne vo every topic close kara diya by saing " this is derogatory , people should do discussion in limits " 😳
this season mai bolunga at least bahot freedom hai on forum , last year was suffocating

Yes even past idol like urvashi create such havoc then forget about current telly star in bigg boss. 😲 still to face that many old BB members are there who will unite who have difference earlier to face new havoc😆

no , urvashi fans were not mods , mostly gc fans r mods , n mods does wat they want 😛 aapko pata chal jaayega ...i rest my case 😆

Bazigar thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#84

Yes i can saw the accusation , So what is the point of dragging thread starters past preference which is not related to thread at all repeatedly when the topic is weather show is really rigged or not

Yes i knew with batli now u r happy to say, by happy with ban of many member by saying sab acha hai, hum santi ke doot hai 🤣 , for DD pankha charo taraf freedom hi freedom hai after all DD painting effect.

DIL Ko Behlane ke liye DD pankha yeh khayal accha hai 😆

826374 thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#85

Originally posted by: ramjaane




Yes i can saw the accusation , So what is the point of dragging thread starters past preference which is not related to thread at all repeatedly when the topic is weather show is really rigged or not

Yes i knew with batli now u r happy to say, by happy with ban of many member by saying sab acha hai, hum santi ke doot hai 🤣 , for DD pankha charo taraf freedom hi freedom hai after all DD painting effect.

DIL Ko Behlane ke liye DD pankha yeh khayal accha hai 😆


muje ek bhi word samsajh nhi aaya😳 ,can u pls explain it , r u trying to say i m dd pankha 😲 now this was shocking , r u gc fan , if yes then again i will say that is shocking bcs they also know i m not drasti fan 😆
jo thoda bahot muje samaj aaya apke post se , u r saying i m happy coz pepole got banned , no , i was talking about my bann not ur friends bann

i n many got banned bcs of blind fans
in bold she herself talking about past in her thred , it is about jhalak history , she included ksg , chang n theire fans , voting ,even sony also , that all r past , her complete post is based on past
i chaked my reply again , now i understand y u said i m supporting drasti fan , no i was not i was talking about fan group , the way u said ur opinion about fans

i want to add one more thing , hate mongers pe starting mai muje thoda doubt that but now i know vo bashing karne mai koi bhed bhaav nhi karte 😆 so dont worry aapke friends ke bann se muje koi khushi nhi hui 😆
Edited by ANNMT. - 11 years ago
AngeloScuro thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#86
@Jyo: Lovely topic and lovely discussions by everyone. I don't know what to believe but I used to love the earlier seasons of JDJ not so much now but I only watch it because it entertainment.

My only wish is if they could do this show live ( Live Broadcast) like So You Think You Can Dance or like the Idol shows do.😊 ( edit: they can still bring the prerecorded segment even when they do live shows)😊

Also I watch the Italian version of this show and seems the Indian version has deviated a lot from the way the two presenters are always in the same frame!

Wish a female super presenter who can dazzle the audience comes along next year.

I'm not saying that I do not love the two male presenters😛

Regarding the topic I felt it was a bit rigged and that's why I came to find opinions about it on here(IF)😆😳
Edited by AngeloScuro - 11 years ago
jyoti06 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Master Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 11 years ago
#87
Why every topic has to come down to GC DD and their fan grps ...The topic was to discuss about voting and not about fan grps 🤔

@ANNMT : The topic was made to discuss about JDJ is rigged or scripted or manipulated .. Its better we stick to that topic only and not drag the whole discussion to something else ..

Let at least one topic stay to the subject till the end


jyoti06 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Master Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 11 years ago
#88

Originally posted by: AngeloScuro

@Jyo: Lovely topic and lovely discussions by everyone. I don't know what to believe but I used to love the earlier seasons of JDJ not so much now but I only watch it because it entertainment.

My only wish is if they could do this show live like So You Think You Can Dance or like the Idol shows do.😊

Also I watch the Italian version of this show and seems the Indian version has deviated a lot from the way the two presenters are always in the same frame!

Wish a female super presenter who can dazzle the audience comes along next year.

I'm not saying that I do not love the two male presenters😛

Regarding the topic I felt it was a bit rigged and that's why I came to find opinions about it on here(IF)😆😳



OMGG Angel how r u doing 😃 ... long time ... I m glad to see so many silent peeps finally making their comments 😳... And yeah I know why u will prefer a female presenter 😉😆😳

there is rigging to some extent for sure but the main debate here is whether its rigged in advance itself and so votes dont matter or whether the rigging takes place via mass regional voting 🤔
937152 thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#89

Originally posted by: jyoti06

Plsss one request , lets keep this thread clean and hv a good healthy discussion on voting vs rigging vs popularity vs talent😳.. I dont want any member to b targetted in this post because of some past grudge in some other post ..

Really some valid points
kaushikbasu , AreYaar , Mumbaimantra , ramjaane , tanya and nana101 👍🏼

I feel regional votes do count and does make a change in the pattern of script that a channel writes every year .. they might initially write a script in favour of one particular contestent based on his/her popularity but later on the regional votes do make a difference and this is something unpredictable ..For example I heard this year for Nach baliye Sourav ganguly and his wife r approached .. now if they do nach baliye , I can bet no popular TV couples whether its Kajen or any other real life couple stands a chance despite huge number of fans simply because one West bengal vote bank of Sourav ganguly is enough to make sure he becomes the winner and no channel script too will work in this case ... So in such rare cases , I feel the whole script of of these celebrity dance shows fail ...

Only if the competition includes all telly soap actors or say a telly soap actor and someone who did few films and is talented as a dancer like we had last year with contestents like Isha , Ritvik , Rashmi and Gurmeet ., then colors write their script accordingly and of course u always hv the fans of these stars competing and voting like crazy for whole night and then among these 3 soap actors whoever gets max votes , channel will wrtie a script in that actor's favour 😆😆 .. but if along with daily soap actor , u hv a national hero competing , thats when the regional vote base comes in picture and those regional peeps dont even belong to this internet world , so one will hv no idea from where the votes r coming .. This year I feel in case of Shaan , same regional votes r working since West bengal from what I hv heard is voting crazily for him whereas for drashti its her online fanbase and daily soap fans who r working day and night for her and when it comes to lauren and kids , channel has retained them just to make sure that every week they can say look just like DID we too hv magical dancers in our team😆 ... But in the end I feel it will come down to regional voting (Shaan) vs Daily soap fans voting (Drashti) ... Here the colors script becomes complicated because they cannot play much when a region is involved unlike last year where it was all about daily soap fans voting(ritvik) vs daily soap fans voting(rashmi) vs daily soaps fans voting(gurmeet) .. so it was easy for colors to play their 1st 2nd and 3rd cards easily ...

Phewww I dunno if I m making sense .. but just that I hv noticed whenever regional voting is involved , the scripts do go for a toss 😆



I think more than regional voting, there is politics of TRPs behind it. Baichung is a footballer n sadly football isn't a popular sport in India so vote wise he can not even match upto KSG. But making him win ensured Sony that they do not lose out their valuable viewership from the entire northeastern states. N also it was a politically motivated decision to show that the NE people are very much part of mainstream India.

Now Sourav Ganguly in Nach Baliye is a totally different case. He is an ex-captain of Indian cricket team n we all know that cricket is the biggest religion in India... 😆 So a lot of cricket fanatics may vote for him. Moreover he is only one from WB who made it big in the national team, so all bengalis will again vote for him. His wife being a professional dancer would be an icing on the cake. Here people will think him as a National Hero; but sadly Baichung being a footballer, how much talented he might be, won't be ever considered a national hero.
AngeloScuro thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#90

Originally posted by: jyoti06



OMGG Angel how r u doing 😃 ... long time ... I m glad to see so many silent peeps finally making their comments 😳... And yeah I know why u will prefer a female presenter 😉😆😳

there is rigging to some extent for sure but the main debate here is whether its rigged in advance itself and so votes dont matter or whether the rigging takes place via mass regional voting 🤔



I'm doing good!😃

I can't contribute much here but I'm a fan of the show.😆

Carry on. I want more insight😃

But I think they can't and should not do away with votes. If they do away with the votes (discredit it) then the people should complain to the Ministry of Information and Broadcasting. I don't know if that would help but I hope that could be done.🤔

I'm not Indian so I can't interfere here😳😆
Edited by AngeloScuro - 11 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".