Sal-Drashti - Performance - Page 4

Created

Last reply

Replies

68

Views

9k

Users

24

Likes

192

Frequent Posters

TheHazard thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#31

Originally posted by: -Stephanie-


First of all.. let me say this.. its really nice to have a good conversation with a person like you! 😳 Cause I see your criticising DD and Salman very decently! 😳 I admire people like you!
And yes.. I do think the choregraphy is falling flat.. But at the beginnng of the season I found it ok! 😳but things are too repetitive nohh! the lifts and such I mean.. and I'm saying this as a DD fan rooting for her to win! 😳 😆

I gotta say Salman is pushing his luck! His choregraphy could either make them or break them! 😳

Ehhh when you say sign if desperation, you gotta be more specific :D heheh! 😆
xxx


Thanks, I'm happy too, because it's rare to have a discussion with a ire hard fans ... 😊

By desperation, I mean you know, you start a competition slowly and gently and gradually pick your tempo. It's a matter of 10/12 weeks. See how lauren punit started and progressed.

The way he started, the concepts he had, all gives me a signal of desperation, those could have come now in the final stages. Like the Egyptian act - That's one such desperate act,you would do, when you are stuck & like to break free from a situation. Like leg licking kind of OTT sensuality, when do you bring it? In a situation like they are now, that kind of act could have brought them back.

But when in a normal situation you do, OTT actions, that only means you are desperate for any decent ideas. Now see now, he has proven that he is out of idea. The kind of choreography he did in last two,OMG, those were like school kids std. Do 2/3 steps and then run to the string, keep hanging aimlessly and then pick a national flag...wow...parents will clap out loud. But is that something you compete with, the kind of dance Lauren Punit did on the same day?? Was it any kind of professional choreography?

That's the only reason, I don't hold DD responsible for it, but Salman. If he had a good choreography and DD would mess it up, I could understand her mistakes. But where is the choreography? If he has to make it easy for Drashti, that doesn't mean he presents a sub standard choreography for that? He has to maintain the standard of the competition.

So that's how, I think, Salman isn't doing a good job with choreography, at all. He actually looks to have run out of ideas.
Edited by Paris4Helen - 12 years ago
tanya94 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#32
even i feel that salmans choreography is not upto the mark...also as far as 22 and 24 marks are conserned...last week i noticed the judges got a bit strict with the mrking...so maybe this week dd has given reasonably good performance and overall scoring of all contestants is on this scale because of the marking
937152 thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#33

You know what, only comparison posts comparing a certain devi with any other person is not allowed- but posts comparing Lauren with the kids or regarding any other contestants is always allowed. And people talk about double standards...😆
TheHazard thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#34

Originally posted by: MumbaiMantra



You know what, only comparison posts comparing a certain devi with any other person is not allowed- but posts comparing Lauren with the kids or regarding any other contestants is always allowed. And people talk about double standards...😆



True... And double standard is also an understatement 😆 I never even knew, that exists 😉
charmz517 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#35
Drashti started pretty strong, but then somewhere she started to drop in her performances. I don't think Salman is "bad" this season, just not as good as last season.. but the realization for me is that, this season he has EXTREMELY strong choreographers (Punit, Cornell, Marischa) pitted against him.. especially Tushar.

Although, Punit has all of a sudden had a extremely huge graph in his choreography and creativity this season, compared to the previous ones, only reason I don't consider him the "strongest" choreographer, is b/c he has someone like Lauren. I am 99% sure she helps with the choreography and creativity aspect, as she is a professional, and more experienced than Punit even (no offense to Punit, but seeing him the previous seasons and then this season.. it's like a new person). 😕
TheHazard thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#36

Originally posted by: charmz517

<font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" color="#6633cc">Drashti started pretty strong, but then somewhere she started to drop in her performances. I don't think Salman is "bad" this season, just not as good as last season.. but the realization for me is that, this season he has EXTREMELY strong choreographers (Punit, Cornell, Marischa) pitted against him.. especially Tushar.</font>


<font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" color="#6633cc">Although, Punit has all of a sudden had a extremely huge graph in his choreography and creativity this season, compared to the previous ones, only reason I don't consider him the "strongest" choreographer, is b/c he has someone like Lauren. I am 99% sure she helps with the choreography and creativity aspect, as she is a professional, and more experienced than Punit even (no offense to Punit, but seeing him the previous seasons and then this season.. it's like a new person).😕</font>



PLEASE DON'T COMPARE PUNIT-SALMAN HERE. THIS TOPIC IS ONLY FOR SALMAN-DRASHTI

If you see, Salman is doing good with Choreography but DD is failing to implement it; that's your opinion and fair enough... 😆

Although, I can see DD's deficiency in Dance, but I didn't see that, Salman had any great choreography that DD failed to implement. For me, Salman is the weak link 😉
937152 thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#37

Originally posted by: Paris4Helen



PLEASE DON'T COMPARE PUNIT-SALMAN HERE. THIS TOPIC IS ONLY FOR SALMAN-DRASHTI

If you see, Salman is doing good with Choreography but DD is failing to implement it; that's your opinion and fair enough... 😆

Although, I can see DD's deficiency in Dance, but I didn't see that, Salman had any great choreography that DD failed to implement. For me, Salman is the weak link 😉


May be Drashti is not giving her 100% or Salman not being creative enough, most likely both...😳 But what stops them from giving their 100% is the assurance of Drashti's vote bank...which ensures she that she does not come in the face off even if she scores a 0...😳
752993 thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#38

Originally posted by: Paris4Helen



PLEASE DON'T COMPARE PUNIT-SALMAN HERE. THIS TOPIC IS ONLY FOR SALMAN-DRASHTI

If you see, Salman is doing good with Choreography but DD is failing to implement it; that's your opinion and fair enough... 😆

Although, I can see DD's deficiency in Dance, but I didn't see that, Salman had any great choreography that DD failed to implement. For me, Salman is the weak link 😉



I wonder if you should report it and call the Mods here for the blatant comparison in an argument, like certain some 😉😆

I swear it's such a silly rule of no comparison. Dude it's a freaking competition, how are people to discuss strengths and weaknesses of each if there comparisons aren't drawn from their acts. Mods and their narrow vision with hints of dictatorship for creating such idiotic rules 🤡

Edit: Made a "boo boo"
Edited by CestMoi - 12 years ago
TheHazard thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#39
@CestMoi: You are absolutely right. How do you actually discuss a contestant, in a competition, without referring his/her competitors? Because standard of a participant is always in relation to others. So they allow comparing everyone else except certain some. Indirectly blocking all discussions about one contestant. 😆

Just imagine if we were to discuss only one contestant in a topic, then either entire forum becomes AT or all those could be done in AT, so there is no discussion outside ATs. 😆
EtherealRati thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 12 years ago
#40
See guys the performances are going down...because her body is giving up . I mean imagine guys...she isn't doing a 4 or 5 but 6 day daily soap...that requirs so much.hardwork ...and it has not been like that she is shooting less for the show or something like...show se gayab for 4 to 5 days...that could have given her time for practice ...time to breath...so she is devoting her time to madhubala...as its her commitment with her production house ...JDJ started ...she was very strong...josh hota hain when you do something new ...seekhne ki chah hoti hain...excitement hoti hain...in those days she managed...and salman gave her difficult steps...a difficult choreography and she did her part the best without any mistakes . Slowly gradually the burden kept on rising...so many new things added...now its 2 2 performance...i feel salman hand on head was an indication to that how will he get time to choreograph two performances...from where the time will come . And now when dhrasti is already exhausted with so much other work...kaise salman usse difficult steps de...if it be more dancing...everything more...more energetic...how will dd be able to do it ...even she is a human being at the end of the day not a superhero...she tries her best . Salman choreographs keeping her side of thing in mind...its kind of mutual .
And now coming to salman...i wasn't impressed when he did the starting ones as well...but surely those were better than the recent ones . She got 30 scores quiet a lot ...and choreography was nice at quiet times ...but not at his level best this season as everyone says . But then he and dd has the biggest disadvantage ...the lack of time which other contestants are not facing . And the only advantage they have is that she is channel's face...and her fan following .

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".