If you could change the judges...?

Page

Next Last

Hetal

@ibelieveinpink

Inactive

+ 5

Posted: 12 years ago

I think it's pretty clear not many people find the judges fair. So if you can change them and pick 3 other judges who would they be?

BTW: I think we all respect Remo, Madhuri and KJo for their contribution to their craft, but it doesn't make them good judges so let's respect everyone's POV even if it's different.

My TOP 3 Picks:

1. Geeta Ma (She's nice and knows how to criticize nicely, oh and she's FAIR😳)

2. Vaibhavi Merchant (I just love her to death...most under-rated judge and choreographer IMO...plus her one-liners are crazy funny😆)

3. Hrithik Roshan (He was super fair on Just Dance IMO and totally eye candy😆)

Quote

Frequent Posters

Serenity_me

@Serenity_me

Rocker

+ 6

Posted: 12 years ago

add saroj ji too. i like her 101 rs ka shagun giving system😆

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

-Pj-

@-Pj-

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 12 years ago

Saroj Khan

Vaibhavi Merchant

mmm

Not sure about the last. I know RS are strange with their judges, they always have one choreographer, a dancer and a director. The director is always asked why they are there and I always thought as they give the audience view. They cannot pick out the main flaws like a choreographer, they won't comment fully on how to do something as they never have but will see the audience and viewing factor as they know how to shoot things.

Quote

Hetal

@ibelieveinpink

Inactive

+ 5

Posted: 12 years ago

@Slov: I saw her on JDJ and she was so unfair but then she went NDTV and post-JDJ her critique is like Simon Cowell clean, cut and to the point. I wish she was more like that doesn't JDJ. She used to phase Bhaichung to no end but he was the master of expressionless.

And yeah I love her classic money give-aways. 🤣

Quote

Rihan05

@Rihan05

Sparkler

Posted: 12 years ago

No changing Madhuri, she is one of the reason for JDJ having good trp!! Sm people just watch the show only to see her😛

Quote

@-SilverAngel-

Stunner

+ 4

Posted: 12 years ago

I would also go for:

1. Either Geeta or Vaibhavi .. (but not both)
2. Terence Lewis (At least I haven't seen him favoring his own dancers/ students as much as Remo does, maybe I'm wrong but that's just my thinking.)
3. Somebody who knows both aspects: Dancing and Acting (for expressions) like Hrithik Roshan or Shahid Kapoor. Both are lookers and fab dancers.

Quote

MissSkeptic

@MissSkeptic

Beginner

Posted: 12 years ago

1. Geeta Ma (She's nice and knows how to criticize nicely, oh and she's FAIR😳) - My sisters and I thought she was biased while watching DID! She seemed to have her favourites... Maybe we were biased...Who knows! 😆

2. Vaibhavi Merchant (I just love her to death...most under-rated judge and choreographer IMO...plus her one-liners are crazy funny😆) - I dunno her nor have I seen her dance/choreograph...

3. Hrithik Roshan (He was super fair on Just Dance IMO and totally eye candy😆) 😲 He was a judge before?!?! There are so many dancing shows in India...the one that I usually follow (though not religiously) is DID!

There was this guy that excel in Ballroom dance and was a judge in DID..I remember thinking he was quite gd as a judge...

Quote

Serenity_me

@Serenity_me

Rocker

+ 6

Posted: 12 years ago

Originally posted by: MocoCoco
@Slov: I saw her on JDJ and she was so unfair but then she went NDTV and post-JDJ her critique is like Simon Cowell clean, cut and to the point. I wish she was more like that doesn't JDJ. She used to phase Bhaichung to no end but he was the master of expressionless.

And yeah I love her classic money give-aways. 🤣

u r right but she was strict in NDTV. but honestly, i dont want to see already seen judges. cant we have some good n new judges who know how to judge dance . judges should be strict just like school teachers😆 n i also like geet ma, she was my fav judge in DID. 😃

Quote

Hetal

@ibelieveinpink

Inactive

+ 5

Posted: 12 years ago

Originally posted by: MissSkeptic
1. Geeta Ma (She's nice and knows how to criticize nicely, oh and she's FAIR😳) - My sisters and I thought she was biased while watching DID! She seemed to have her favourites... Maybe we were biased...Who knows! 😆

Bias works both ways, I thought she was pretty fair. It was Remo who could never hear anything wrong/bad about his crew. I guess that's why they call her "ma" b/c she's very maternal and as that must-protect-my-babies type attitude.😆

2. Vaibhavi Merchant (I just love her to death...most under-rated judge and choreographer IMO...plus her one-liners are crazy funny😆) - I dunno her nor have I seen her dance/choreograph...

She did Kajre Re, Crazy Kiya Re, Dholi Taro, Dola Re, Aaja Nach le, that song b/w hrithik-isha in luck by chance, and so many more...she's extremely under-rated.

3. Hrithik Roshan (He was super fair on Just Dance IMO and totally eye candy😆) 😲 He was a judge before?!?! There are so many dancing shows in India...the one that I usually follow (though not religiously) is DID!

Yeah he did and I actually liked him. He never played favorites, which was nice and he knows the technique of dancing b/c he himself is always interested in learning new styles. Like in Kites.

BTW: you talking about Terrence from DID or Marzi?!

There was this guy that excel in Ballroom dance and was a judge in DID..I remember thinking he was quite gd as a judge...