Is it fair? - Page 26

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

chetrohan

@chetrohan

Inactive

Posted: 11 years ago

#251

Kya Kare fair shyad nahi hoga but tino judges ne bola hoga bhai kuch to de do hame judge Karne ke liye verna hum yu hi bathe bathe so jayege. Host bhi asai deye ha ki kya bataye. Bagvan ke naam pe kuch to de do yaar. Muje to hamare itne ache singer (Sukhiji you know) ki badi chinta ho rahi hai. Abb Jo bhai Saab ek form pe dance nahi kar sakate vo fusion Kase karega? Arre Bavana Tera kya hoga?

Bahut hi nainsafi hai Takur. I am thinking kahi colors ne Manish ko iss liye to nahi nikala kyo ki vo MD pe Bahut Marta tha?. If that's the case we audience are asking for forgiveness. Hum use samjayange. Per use vapas bulao. Kapil ko bhi samjayange. Please don't make fun of anyone but please... Please it's hard to watch this show😭 We like it because it's dance show. Please hamari aavaj suno. 🥱

Edited by chetrohan - 11 years ago

Quote

Cutiepie_Rani

@Cutiepie_Rani

Trailblazer

+ 4

Posted: 11 years ago

#252

I think a lot of you are misunderstanding me and I really want to clear those misunderstandings.

I've read through all the pages. First most I want to clear that I think Shakti is a very talented person. She's a great dancer and she's good at what she does. I am not against her at all. So people who think I am, you're wrong. I have stated in my very first post that I am a Shakti fan. It's another matter that I didn't see her deserving to win DID with the top 4 contestants. But no one can take her talent away from her. She's one hell of a dancer.

Second-most, some of you may have gotten the wrong impression from my initial post or maybe I didn't convey it properly. It's not about being a trained dancer. Many contestants are trained in a certain forte. I consider Shakti more on the professional dancer side. I can see her as a choreographer. Yes this show is dancing with the stars and Shakti is very well a star. Every dancer has room for improvement. But for the non-dancing celebs on the show it is a very fair disadvantage. I like what Remo sir said to Shakti and Tushaar. How they have to inch it up to get a 10 out of him. It'll be somewhat easier for other contestants to get 9 and 10s, but for Shakti and Tushaar the bar will be raised.

The format of the show should change. Either all the contestants should be somewhat trained in a particular form or they all should come from a non-dancing background. And then it will be the journey of massive improvement from a non dancer to a dancer.

We all know the politics that go behind these reality shows. I doubt Shakti will win. Though if she does, I'll be happy for her because I AM HER FAN!

I also want to say to those who 'worship' Shakti...its one thing to be a fan, but its another to not accept any criticism against her. As I mentioned before each individual has their flaw. She does too. Please learn to accept criticism against your favorite. No one's perfect.

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

LoveAnny

@LoveAnny

Voyager

Posted: 11 years ago

#253

It is not fair but its nothing new. One thing, other participants can never match her level of dancing. Bitter truth. She dances like dream. So now the question is why she is here? Its for exposure, if you want to remain in telly world and grab attention these platforms are perfect for that. And i see nothing wrong in that. Believe me, people would not watch the show to see participants falling, rising etc etc. They want to see some good performance and that's why these professionals are here. Can anyone do ballet except Shakti? The answer is No. Can anyone do contemporary? No! So someone is needed to raise the standard. And frankly the people who has some knowledge of dance, they would not waste their time watching such reality show. JDJ is not a pure platform of dance, dramabazi, nautanki are main content of the show.

Quote

jayita_arsha

@jayita_arsha

Beginner

Posted: 11 years ago

#254

Itz d shows format to having a train dancer in it so itz nt atall wrong shes a grt dancer n DID n Jhalak r two different format shws...n coming t train dancers mouni,andy r compltly train n even sree too knws it pretty well,kiku aka palak also coz he recently did NB..n kritika also did a reality dance shw earlier calld zara nach k dekha whr mouni won one seasons best dancer so every1 knws her danceing ability n shes well knwn fr it,so vry few in this is nondancers so itz nt atall unfair all r gd in dance so thr will b a healty compition hopefully...luv shakti mohan shes compltly belongs thr...

Quote

StolenKiss.

@StolenKiss.

Dazzler

+ 4

Posted: 11 years ago

#255

I am nt the person who will feel offended with criticism and I mean it. I am neither supporting Shakti because she is my favourite.

When did Jhalak start being completely about Dancing. Doesn't popularity count too?

If Shakti has an advantage of being a dancer then so does others.

Shakti have to struggle to get marks becoz d judges have raised the bar for her while the non-dancers trying n doing is enough😳

I still believe being a dancer in Jhalak has both pros n cons so how can we judge it as fair or unfair?

And moreover the non-dancers or the ones you term as non-dancers have advantage..

Karan is taking dance training since the time he accepted Jhalak Offer.

Sophie, Mouni, Purab, Sreesanth n Andy r trained dancers but none have problem with them why?

Becoz they r nt as popular as Shakti? or as talented as her to win anything?

Kritika, Puja n Sukhvinder are the only non-dancers out there purely.

Jhalak doesnt depend on complete dancing..

if its so then it would be unfair becoz Shakti is the BEST dancer out there.

BUT..

Jhalak is about dancing + Votes.

Karan Tacker, Purab, Andy, Kritika r top channel faces n Ashish too...

This is an advantage to them but why is it not pointed out?

Shakti unlike the previous season dancers has got a fan following a bit more than them which is leading to insecurity among the viewers.

I still stick to it.

It would have been unfair if its only dance that makes Jhalak winner but its not dance alone here so u cant really judge if its fair or unfair.

Quote

lilac_dreams

@lilac_dreams

Explorer

Posted: 11 years ago

#256

I think its fair.

My POV is as below:

What many ppl are forgetting is that trained/professional dancers are judged also accordingly by the judges (Specially Remo). They are judged more accurately in terms of technicalities and dance.

For Eg. Remo gave 9 to Palak, as well as Shakti. Now we all know that both in no way deserve equal marks. But Remo judged them according to their dancing calibre.

So in this way, if contestant are going to be judged according to their dancing calibre, where is the question of competition among themselves??

The only criteria where they will have to compete is Votes, which acutally has nothing to do with dancing at all as ppl votes for their Favs irrespective of what marks they have got or how good/bad was their dance!!!

So in the end it does not actually matter whether there are trained dancers in the show or not!!!

Quote

Sreeja Nair

@sreeja_rox

Sparkler

+ 5

Posted: 11 years ago

#257

About being fair and unfair...i guess the show has alway's been like this.

Last season both Lauren and Mukti were trained dancer's though after joining JDJ Mukti had suddenly declared herself to be an untrained dancer.

Whatever be the reason,the point is their have been trained dancer's participating in the past too and the same goes with Shakti in this season.

However unfair it may look but the channel doesn't look at what should be fair among the contestant's does it?? All they look at is how the heat stay's on in this show helping the show to grow up more.

Apart from the famous judges and famous contestants,controversies play a very important role for the rise of the show.

And keeping a trained dancer along with untrained one's does create a controversy like this one :):):):):):)

All said and done,all we can do is wish for a fair game which look's near to impossible in the near future.

PEACE

Edited by sreeja_rox - 11 years ago

Quote

DhoniAddict

@BeingBlunt

Achiever

+ 33

Posted: 11 years ago

#258

^^LOL. You are asking a fair game from colors? 😆
When has colors listened to viewers demands? 🥱
All they want is TRP and controversies create TRP.
Many members who are regular like me know this fact and watch only for some mindblowing dance performances and nothing else. 😆

Edited by sscomp32 - 11 years ago

Quote

kritilovesvj

@kritilovesvj

Voyager

+ 2

Posted: 11 years ago

#259

its totally unfair to other contestant obv she will get good mks bcos she is a trained dancer. shakthi shud be an choreographer no offense to shakthi fan its only my pov

Quote

-KissMyAss-

@-KissMyAss-

Inactive

+ 2

Posted: 11 years ago

#260

No it's NOT fair ! I don't know why she's here, she already won DID which is a huge achievement, she's doing a dance show on channel V everyone knows that she's a brilliant dancer, so she has NOTHING to prove to anyone in JDJ, she has a huge adventage on other non dancers this is absolutely unfair. She'll get 30 every week, it's boring

Quote

1 ... 24 25 26 27 28 ... 35

Is it fair? - Page 26

Related Topics

Explore Topics