Did Negi Deserve 30?? - Page 2

Originally posted by: jyoti06

Well I think Negi deserved 30 today 😃 ..I m not a fan of Negi but I feel his choreography was really excellent today 👏 😳

Dancing doesn't mean that always u will hv to put in difficult steps to get full marks 😊 ..Sometimes even simple clean steps can do the trick 😉 ...and Negi's dance was simple,different and very clean 😃 ..and in Jugalbandi the two people always do different dance steps..If one does Indian then the other one does western 😳 ..So thats why there was no such interaction because that is actually the format of the dance 😊

But I agree with u Ronit was superb today 👏 ..I really loved his hard work and dedication 😃 ..As far as Mika goes...NO COMMENTS 😃

I absolutely agree with everything you say! Negi is not my usual favorite and I usually think that the judges over-rate him for his efforts, but this time, his performance was thoroughly entertaining. I had a smile on my face throughout his dance. I agree difficult steps and lifts do not always make a dance good. Sometimes just some smart choreography and right interpretation of the song with cute expressions can do wonders.

I thought that today's judgement was the fairest of all. Sudha was not over-rated, by scores at least (as she usually is ... Although I have to say her chemistry with Uma is crackling) and even Prachi's dance did not have the woman enticing the man, seductiveness of a Rumba, so she deserves the points she got. I think it was the choreography that went bad for Prachi. Jay was given points for his energy and zest. Sandhya totally deserved the points she got. Was a true Rumba with the much needed oomph that Sudha and Prachi lacked.

Only one "shikaayat" .... Ronit's scores. Despite all the injury, the performance came out to be so clean and extremely sensual. Their chemistry was electrifying and Ronit's care for his partner came through the dance and the end result was a romantic sensual performance. Should have gotten a tad bit higher marks for that, maybe as much as Jay's would have been satisfying for me. Ronit's dedication was soo apparent, and if they were giving points for effort to Sudha and Negi, why not Ronit this time?

Rest was fair.

well i think Negi ji and his partner danced well..very uniquely choreographed..but in my opinion 30 was too much..i thought 27 maybe.. 😉

I not a big fan of Negi but i think he deserved 30... 👏 👏 👏. agreed that the dance was simple but the idea was brilliant and he was really good. Also he is not from this glamour world, even then he is putting so much effort which is appreciable and probably thats why shamaik got so excited about after their performance.
Also Ronit and Jay deserved more points than what they got. 😕

I think he deserved a 30. Prachi deserved the score she got, infact she should have got a lower score as they were supposed to do rumba but she was doing waltz, a different dance altogether. Same goes for Sudha, she deserved a lower score as she was not doing rumba either. Negi Ji was thoroughly entertaining. I mean for an ordinary man to dance so well. When you dance like a puppet, you have to emote too and he was so good. He deserved the 30.

no...he surely didnt deserve that 30!
judges r being too lenient w/ him just cause hes old

i agree on this one, Negi didn't deserve 30..i think judges are too nice to him , it's really not fair!

i think what jyoti said is right
negi was entertaining yes and simple steps do work
but i m not happy with mika markin
though ronit also deserved bit more for all the efforts
jay performance i enjoyed too

those marks were unfair..other teams get booted but negi gets credit for not tht gr8 work...he was good not sayin bad or anythin..but not a 30..i was shocked at tht 30...

he was more so a 25-26ish

I wud say 30 is a bit too high. But on the other hand Negi did deserve to be on the top today. So maybe 27 or sumthing like that. So was Sandhya.

he performed good
but 30 is too much