BORN WITH TALENT OR GROWING TALENT?

Page

Next Last

shiuli84

@shiuli84

Inactive

Posted: 18 years ago

HEY GUYS!

i have been watching all the episodes so far. there seems to be a war going on in this forum about whom to vote.

my question is who are we to vote- the one who has always been a great dancer or one who learnt how to dance and improved each time?

mona's warm personality and jassi fame is an added bonus point. she won many hearts by doing her jassi role and now her bubbly smile makes people happy.

shveta is a talented dancer and thats what i noticed from day 1. but somewhere along the line she has reached a plateau regarding her improvement. if u notice very closely her own performances u will notice midway there isnt that great a learning curve as mona's. i guess because she is always dancing great she somewhat bored the audience. (i dont mean bore literally.)

also if u see mona she looks very simple but her dancing has shown her passionate and erotic side and thats woken up a lot of audience which was there from day 1 in shveta.

so what do u guys say? tell me what u guys think but please dont pick on each other or use foul language. at the end of the day its just another tv show. we dont get any of the prize money. both finalists have worked hard.

Quote

Frequent Posters

@mermaid_QT

Inactive

Posted: 18 years ago

huh? ????

so the title of the show should be
1) improvement dikhla ja??
2) learning curve dikhla ja??
3)warmth dikhla ja??
4)smile dikhla ja??
5)popularity dikhla ja??

mqt

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

@mermaid_QT

Inactive

Posted: 18 years ago

since the show is zalak dikhla ja..

ofcourse i pick shweta.
being a fan of Mona, i am very happy for her and really bless her for a great future. she has been awesome!! but shweta showed the zhalak 😃

qt

Edited by mermaid_QT - 18 years ago

Quote

Selina Singh

@Selina

Inactive

Posted: 18 years ago

Mona has improved a lot since the show started. But we should look at where both of them stand right now. I think they both are equally deserving of the title!

Quote

anonmember

@anonmember

Inactive

Posted: 18 years ago

Interesting questions. Can't born talent also be growing talent? Shveta is a great dancer but she's also shown improvement since the start.

Quote

Nikita

@Dancingdoll

Sparkler

+ 3

Posted: 18 years ago

Originally posted by: mermaid_QT
huh? ????

so the title of the show should be
1) improvement dikhla ja??
2) learning curve dikhla ja??
3)warmth dikhla ja??
4)smile dikhla ja??
5)popularity dikhla ja??

mqt

hhahahahahah....This is toooooooooooooooooooo good!!!! Cant stop laughing!!!😆

well said!!!! 👏

Quote

insouciance

@insouciance

Inactive

+ 2

Posted: 18 years ago

I had said this iin another post,I find Mona's improvement has been way to overhyped and hyperbolized.....

She scored a 24 in her first performance,then in the second it was a 27,then in the third,a 25 and so one...it kept oscillating between 23 and 29.....her final performance was her weakest,she scored a 20,which is her lowest score....thus its wrong to say that her graph has always been on the rise,because it did plummet in the finals,when she hit that 20 mark,which is her lowest.....

Thus in one performance,it used to be a 28,then in the next a 23......Her graph isnt like Hiten Gauri's,who are terrible dancers,but their scores are always in the rise...in each and every episode,they have scored more than what they did in the previous..they started at 12,then reached 20 via 18 and 19...thus that is a case of CLEAR improvement,as even the scores say so....In Mona's case,one cant say that,as her scores have always been abberant and not always rising ,her score has been fluctuating,She'd improve in one performance,then be back to the 24,then again it'd be 26 etc.....SO saying that her graph was only rising is wrong,as it has been falling too

People choose to overlook SVetha's improvement,she too started at 27,then reached the perfect 30 mark...If Mona's improvement from 24 to 29 can be recognized,I think its but fait to recognize and appreciate shveta for scoring a perfect 30,three times.....EVen that is improvement,marks wise....MAybe not as much as Mona's,but its improvement nevertheless..... ..SO it wouldnt be right to say SHveta never improved,because if Mona has,so has shveta...

THE show is for non dancers,both shveta and mona are non dancers,Mona took time to improve and to reach the 29 mark,Shveta accomplished the same in less time,and she also has been consistent...Once shveta reached the apogee,she has SUSTAINED it,because sustaining too isnt that easy.... Sustaining is as hard as improving,because when one sustains,one has no more scope for improvement,thus the focus is on not to retrogress...When one improves,one is constantly applauded ,but when one is trying to sustain,one is always compared to one's ownself and to One's previous performance...Sustaining isnt as simply as you people think it is,be it the rank in the school,the numero uno position in an industry,or the dancing in a competition😃

Edited by Buffie - 18 years ago

Quote

fm05

@fm05

Sparkler

Posted: 18 years ago

Buffie and Sonayee..wah 👏 👏 👏 Excellent comments 😃

Mona Improved and honed in on her dancing skills.

Shveta is a born dancer with lots of natural talent.

Shveta has been most consistent with the level of her performances and has dazzled the audience.

Mona has been a diamond in the rough, slowly she has been polished into a better dancer but she wasnt exactly terrible to begin with, she has done prior stage shows. However, like Farha has said her steps were repetitive, Toby was not incoporating any new moves into the dances so it i found them less appealing.

Shveta and Longi towrds the end...struggled to keep the originality in their choregraphy, but they wrked hard and each performance has been different.

Mona is grateful to her jaanta for voting for her but she seems less appreciative of Toby whereas Shveta has been humble, and gracious to credit her dance to Longi and thank her fans.

Edited by pardesi-mem - 18 years ago