Created

Last reply

Replies

67

Views

6.6k

Users

24

Frequent Posters

S_Sara thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#51
Jiya jale left me SPEECHLESS too. The synchronisation between those two was so gd!n i really thought himanshu proved tht he was worthy of winning the title (as choreographer of course)

i know ppl keep mentioning the so called 'copying' aspect of her performances but ive just compared the two videos for the kisna act n yes the concept is the same but himanshu's choreography is COMPLETELY DIFFERENT. so in my eyes they're excused.

Also like ive said before i wish i could get the point across tht the mirror reflection and gate prop is really common in dance, the use of those in an act does NOT equal copying. It is just like say the use of ropes or chairs, these are mere props, ANYONE should be able to use them without being held under the gun of Cheating. <sigh> <sigh> <sigh>

Tanea thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#52
yes we Gauhar fans take criticism sensibly and dont jump to conclusions unless and until proved... we dont go all crazy and hyper..! cux we are sensible and mature people who realize true talent
Tanea thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#53

Originally posted by: Perfangel5655

I loved loved loved loved loved loved loved jiya jale!!!! it was amazing!!!!!!! I am so fida over the jiya jale act. I can't say enough nice things about it. It was so good. The beginning solo she rocked it. "Rocking" is the only right word to describe it.

U r so rite , Gauhar's a true "rockstar"!

1 thing i dont get, why Juhi still gave her 8 when she herself said that no one has performed like this during the whole show😕

S_Sara thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#54

Originally posted by: Tanea

U r so rite , Gauhar's a true "rockstar"!

1 thing i dont get, why Juhi still gave her 8 when she herself said that no one has performed like this during the whole show😕



yeh i mentioned this earlier too, perhaps on pg 6...wht was the point of saying tht if u werent gonna give her the marks to go with the compliment?? it is SUCH a contradiction.

I've said this earlier...it felt like the judges were deliberately tying gauhar n baichung. cant put my finger on the reason but was baichung's bhangra anywhere near the level of gauhar's kisna performance??the way in the end where she kept rolling himanshu forward n thn he rolled bk when she was reeling him in...all of tht took way more THOUGHT n ORIGINALITY than the bhangra. yet similar marks... 😕 😕

my disclaimer - im not bashing baichung, i like him too...just a comparison based on my opinion, please dont come after me with any dandas or chapals etc 😆 😆


EDIT - PS: thnx tanea for making this topic n giving us GK fans a place to discuss her performance! 😃
Edited by S_Sara - 16 years ago
Tanea thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#55

Originally posted by: S_Sara



yeh i mentioned this earlier too, perhaps on pg 6...wht was the point of saying tht if u werent gonna give her the marks to go with the compliment?? it is SUCH a contradiction.

I've said this earlier...it felt like the judges were deliberately tying gauhar n baichung. cant put my finger on the reason but was baichung's bhangra anywhere near the level of gauhar's kisna performance??the way in the end where she kept rolling himanshu forward n thn he rolled bk when she was reeling him in...all of tht took way more THOUGHT n ORIGINALITY than the bhangra. yet similar marks... 😕 😕

my disclaimer - im not bashing baichung, i like him too...just a comparison based on my opinion, please dont come after me with any dandas or chapals etc 😆 😆


EDIT - PS: thnx tanea for making this topic n giving us GK fans a place to discuss her performance! 😃

I m really happy that we have people like u here in JDJ forum, who praise real talent, and give honest opinions without bashing or fighting:)

I like BB myself but even i feel Gauhar was better than BB in the last episode and definitely deserved better marks:)

and today i saw Gauhar's "Marjawan" act, which happened in old episodes, but its so neat and beautiful that i fell in love with the amazing song again :)

friends_rock thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 16 years ago
#56
VOTE FOR GAUHARRRRRRRRRRRRRR lolz i still cant take that jiya jale out of my head soooo goood!
BWSweetu thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#57

Originally posted by: Tanea

U r so rite , Gauhar's a true "rockstar"!

1 thing i dont get, why Juhi still gave her 8 when she herself said that no one has performed like this during the whole show😕

In my view,

there is diff. b/t better performance and different performance... juhi liked the performance..nobody has done it before.. but it wasn't the best..I think judges make gud decisions every time😊

Tanea thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#58

yea but still it had more potential than bhangra steps, i m nt saying Bb's bhangra wasnt good, it really was, but GK's Kisna's act was really different and sooooo well performed :)

how ever, i can never say like that judges are jealous of any contestant unlike some other celebrity fans, if u know wat i mean:)

desichick92 thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#59

Originally posted by: Tanea

lol... yea today's show was really good


yeah may be u should call karan .... nt pappu pls use proper words!!!!

BWSweetu thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#60

Originally posted by: Tanea

yea but still it had more potential than bhangra steps, i m nt saying Bb's bhangra wasnt good, it really was, but GK's Kisna's act was really different and sooooo well performed :)

how ever, i can never say like that judges are jealous of any contestant unlike some other celebrity fans, if u know wat i mean:)



yeah at first I thought da same that gauhar was better than BB in kisna act.. but then I realize that it could be because gauhar 's act looked so gud and BB's act didn't looked nice to eyes and smtime its depends on how the camera is moving ..da person sitting there in da studio can easily judge that

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".