not on karan's side or rohit's - Page 2

Originally posted by: BlueSoul

@ punjabi#1: I appreaciate ur pov but still there are some points which i disagree... I am glad you disagree with me on some points because that's what makes discussions fun, healthly disagreements.
1. U wrote they dont take risks... i guess u missed the skates performance...i wont add blindfolded performance coz that was the theme round..everyone did that or with elastic bands. Correct me if I am wrong but I remember hearing that skating is something Karan could do will all along. But still, I agree it was an amazing preformance and something unqiue. Now if they would do that more often. Bigger the risks, bigger the rewards. Karan knows he has the fans to keep him in, and if he took some crazy risks, he could get really high marks and sometimes when they don't work low marks, also. But it would make this competition more interesting and it would shut alot of peope up.
2. About Rohit defending his brother...he was actually abusing another actor/participant of the show n blaming him that even he cant dance.. when the question was that Ronit cant dance... This is not called Defendng ur brother. Its actually misbehaving. I never actually watched this, so was just commenting on what people said. I still will say he is defending his brother because that was his intent. Maybe he went overboard and thats wrong but his thought behind it was not.
3. If Karan has great screen presence and ppl are voting for him...its their wish to vote for any celebrity.... he's here to impress by his charm and dancing...some of them vote for his charm while others for dancing... they may not like others performances better than Karan's...Simple.
I never said people are wrong to vote for him. and I never said people only vote for his screen presence, i clearly mentioned that some people vote for his dancing also.


Suddenly i realised that i was'nt a huge fan of karan...but coming to this forum...i have actually becme his fan coz of the bashing done here for him. Whats wrong is wrong and if it happens with any other contestant i'll support them also...I guess im on ur footsteps Ksg_sonia...i hope i dont end up being rude to anybody...this was my pov...and anyone can disagree with me.
But i really like all the others and wish them luck to win...whoever got the talent,charm and luck will win it.

Originally posted by: kash4life

hey you nkow i agree to apoint but thanbks for potraying ur comments in such apositive way seriosuly thats rare here o thank you

Originally posted by: punjabi#1

First of all thanks for agreeing on some points. 😛

Now for your points:
1. I don't watch Jhalak regularly because of work commitments but I am sure that Karan has given some really good performances. You feel that the judges have been unfair in their points because they have a thing against Karan. (could be true or false, no comment). Have the voters been unfair to really good dancers? And no the judges don't give a heck to how much effort he put into becoming popular because everyone on that show is popular in their own right. thats the reason i am cribbing that everyone is popular then why point only karan's popularity........ nobody has a answer to that jst coz his fans are loyal, love him unconditionally thats not the point to bash somebody in such a demeaning way. their remarks were derogatory
2. You said that they have been mean towards karan the whole time and that in his place you would have broken down. All I have to say to that is when someone is constantly pushed down they tend to come up in a big way. ya it happens when u are criticized not insulted. he was bashed not criticized saying pappu cant dance saala is not criticism its bashing and bashing can really make u lose your confidence
3. I wish Karan hadn't kept quiet because sometimes remaining quiet makes a person look guilty. I wish he had fought back and shut them and everyone else up. Since that time has gone, I hope he fights back by giving mindblowing performances. no dear rather i am proud that karan didnt retaliate coz he just cant insult somebody like they were doing. he is short tempered but then knows well how to control it in certain situations
4. As a fan, its nice to see you supporting you celebratie. I wish you and Karan best of luck. hey thats nice thanks for the wonderful comment.... thanks for all the luck.............

-Rimpy

Originally posted by: ksg_sonia

this is the POLITEST discussion EVER on dis jdj forum
lol!
tc all
luv sonia

Originally posted by: punjabi#1

I hope that is a good thing. 😉

-Rimpy

Originally posted by: sakshiluvskaran

rimpy its nice that there is no heated arguement but a healthy discussion. thanks. i hope with all the love from his fans he wins jhalak