The Baichung Bias...Judges = unfair!

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

Mango Bhai!

@Lord-Mangeshwar

Rocker

Posted: 16 years ago

#31

I do think that Mr Baichung B is doing a great job... I'd say that he's come a very long way 😊

But of course, the judging is absolutely awful this year... in fact, I think that it's the worst judging that JDJ has ever had to put up with in any season.

I do remember that Karan Bhai had marks cut due to the lack of lip syncing... but as pointed out by many members, Mr Baichung B doesn't do much lip syncing either, and in the wildcard round, Mr Ram Kapoor didn't either - and yet there was no penalty!

There is no clear cut and consistent marking scheme, and it seems that the judges don't have any idea what they are looking for 😕

This week's scoring seems quite bad also... of course, Karan Bhai DID score well, but he got 27 for something which probably deserved pull marks (a never seen before concept, which was supposedly performed flawlessly).

It makes me wonder, what Karan Bhai needs to do in order to get the full 30... will he have to levitate or fly? 😳

I do not think that anyone can blame Mr Baichung B in any way - by dancing the best he can, he's simply doing his part... but it's the judges that aren't doing their part.

God bless.

Quote

RadioM

@RadioM

Voyager

Posted: 16 years ago

#32

Originally posted by: Lord-Mangeshwar

It makes me wonder, what Karan Bhai needs to do in order to get the full 30... will he have to levitate or fly? 😳

God bless.

lol KSG need not fly or levitate to get 30. What I have stressed upon, I reiterate, it is not the judges who should be blamed for so-called unfair judgment because to me judges seem to be the mediators of channel and show authority's decisions. I guess that is what they are paid for to show up and convey the message to us of those sitting behind the curtain and coordinating things to gain TRPs and financial gains!

You may disagree but I feel that KSG is voting-population's favorite. Channel knows it pretty well. He is also a big factor in gaining TRPs. Scores that would just keep him safe are given to him. If at some point of time, it is observed that his existence in JDJ3 needs higher score, I am sure he will be given a perfect 30. In addition to that, I believe that he may be one of the channel's favorite to win the title this year. Therefore, channel wants to show him as a slow progressor towards perfection. They don't want to give him perfect 30 already and ruin all the fun!! I could have explained my point of view better if I had more time. I hope you got the idea!

Thanks!

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

sjain

@sjain

Trailblazer

+ 4

Posted: 16 years ago

#33

every time rona dhona during performance is little boring ........once in a while its fine !!!!!!...........judes ko sirf ek emotional kahani sunao ...aur phir dekho dil khol ke marks milenge!!!!!🥱

Edited by sjain - 16 years ago

Quote

ridhima (OMG,it really is, haha i wouldnt lie)

@babii.girl

Sparkler

+ 4

Posted: 16 years ago

#34

TOTALLY!!!!..

everythingg the judges criticize that the contestants dont do/ or do..

even though Baichung does the same, its never take in consideration while giving marks, its more "ommgg who cares if Baichung totally screws up, and doesnt do the moves properly, becuz hes so "cute".. lets give him thirty..uhhhhh in that case, why dont i just judge.. will make it difference?

Quote

ridhima (OMG,it really is, haha i wouldnt lie)

@babii.girl

Sparkler

+ 4

Posted: 16 years ago

#35

Originally posted by: riti04

Judges are not unfair with baichung, baichug is really a more good performer then karan.

for those who still think that baichug gets marks coz hez fav of judges then ok. go and ask ur fav to become fav of judges and then he'll also get good marks and if he cannot become their fav then sorry noone can help you in this.

Baichug rockxx

Watch his "tauba mein pyar karke" performance again.. i showed all my friends, and omggg all of them just couldnt stop laughing.. i think its sweet taht ur supporting him,and saying hes a goodperformer.. and if he really is.. i would LOVE to see baichung do a dance that karan has done..

Quote

llll

@-Aleeza-

Inactive

Posted: 16 years ago

#36

In our eyes he's the best and he's improved alot. He's already built his place in every ones heart and no one can take that away. Also Judges know that he will never get the highest votes so might as well give him 30 so no good contestant can go out cuz of some next popular contestant.

And he deserves 30 for his performances it's not only because he's special.

Quote

rozita333

@rozita333

Inactive

Posted: 16 years ago

#37

if karan would have got 30 in that performance you all would have said wow he deserved more than 30...but when baichung gets 30...you all cry like a baby...the judges are bias and all that shit... i think you all know that judges give the marks not only for dancing but for coreography as well...karan's coreographer nicole is shit...try to admit that...i haven't seen any of the karan's performances that touched me...and i say it from my heart that if baichung gets as much time as karan for rehearsals he will kick the shit out of him easily on dancing...

Quote

rozita333

@rozita333

Inactive

Posted: 16 years ago

#38

what the f**k??? do you believe in that voting system...even if baichung gets the highest votes and karan gets the lowest they won't tell you the truth...if there was a truth in voting how did gauhar come back with the highest vote...people are gonna vote any way for their favourites...but now i believe that many of the people are changing their votes from karan to baichung coz many people i know esp. my friends who supported karan in the beginning now started liking baichung and are willing to vote for him any time...vote for baichung!!!

Quote

rozita333

@rozita333

Inactive

Posted: 16 years ago

#39

what i say is that karan and other dancers were good from the beginning...though they improve it would not be seen effectively by the judges coz they were good from the beginning whereas baichung started out weak and took every suggestion the judges told him and really impressed them by improving a lot in his dance...so this improvement was much bigger than other contestants for the judges so they gave him the marks for that...other contestants always take the comments from the judges negatively and try to fight for that rather than showing the judges that they really took advice from them...dance is not a thing that can be judged by every people...everyone have their own opinion but it's complicated to judge...even if karan do 1000 lifts and his coreography is not good he can't get marks...and if you do simple easy steps and the coreography is good you can get higher marks...

Quote

LIKEDMG

@LIKEDMG

Sparkler

Posted: 16 years ago

#40

Baichung really dances too good than I expect...bfore I like him as a footballer but he rocks the dance floor also..to me Baichung and Hard Kaur are surprise package ..they r the dark horses..rocks in JDJ...till now I dont see any unfair judgement..this is my opinion...I luv his hard working and dedication..bcoz it is really tough to dance in a competetion where he have to show his dancing talent not football..I really appreciate him...👏...and if I m in India I ll vote the person who deserve it...

Quote

1 2 3 4 5

The Baichung Bias...Judges = unfair! - Page 4

Related Topics

Explore Topics