I guess I am in the minority...

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

Me_Anonymous

@Me_Anonymous

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 12 years ago

#11

Originally posted by: DIDfan89
What I mean is if you look at her first performance and until now there is an improvement, shes moving a lot more and is "dancing" whereas before she was kinda...just waving around. Well anyway thats my opinion lol

Im seeing her attempting techinques which is commendable.

Yes, there has been some improvement but her comedy overshadows that. I still remember her first performance and I like it very much. Her performances lately have less of that passion that was in the beginning few performances but, you are right, she has improved greatly. Look at her getting up from floor, she has that stamina now which makes getting up and down so easy and seamless for us watchers - we think its nothing much but try it and you'll see how much effort and practice is required for that😛

Quote

Aditi Bhatnagar

@adigaag

Dazzler

Posted: 12 years ago

#12

Exactly and this is the reason why people are actually voting for her...she has improved alot...This does nopt mean I'm voting for her...I have noticed this trend in reality shows...If any contestant tries to come out of her/his comfort zone and do something that is least expected from her/him, you surely get the votes. I might be wrong ass well as I'm not quite sure as to who will bow out next week😕

Edited by adigaag - 12 years ago

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Rogue...

@Rogue...

Inactive

Posted: 12 years ago

#13

I agree shes huge ...& with tht kind of bodyweight its next to impossible to deliver such lifts ..but shes been doing those now quiet brilliantly! I am all in fr Bharti ...that woman sure is working way too hard !...& not being in the bottomline goes on to prove tht majority is behind her ...oh well the shw is scripted rgt ...so then the channel thinks shes way better & popular than a wahi or a shibani or a darsheel . They jst dont want her out. Looks like next shes going to get a standing ovation frm Kareena as well ...this season is simply Bharti !!! shes all over ...as for her filthy comedy stuff ...shes doing what hs been scripted fr her to do ...looks like COLORS hs complete faith in her!...

Quote

826374

Suspended

Posted: 12 years ago

#14

Originally posted by: Hail_Van_Helsin
I agree shes huge ...& with tht kind of bodyweight its next to impossible to deliver such lifts ..but shes been doing those now quiet brilliantly! I am all in fr Bharti ...that woman sure is working way too hard !...& not being in the bottomline goes on to prove tht majority is behind her ...oh well the shw is scripted rgt ...so then the channel thinks shes way better & popular than a wahi or a shibani or a darsheel . They jst dont want her out. Looks like next shes going to get a standing ovation frm Kareena as well ...this season is simply Bharti !!! shes all over ...as for her filthy comedy stuff ...shes doing what hs been scripted fr her to do ...looks like COLORS hs complete faith in her!...

exjectly ...with this waight its impossible to balance but she is doing lifts 😆 she is deffo hard working

Quote

MAD_GIRL

@MAD_GIRL

Beginner

Posted: 12 years ago

#15

I like Bharti in Comedy Circus ...not in JDJ 😉

Bharti came as a non-dancer, she has improved a lot in this journey, she is an acceptable dancer now, but compared to others in that show, she doesn't deserve to come this far in the competition at the cost of some very good dancers who got eliminated.

Similarly, if Esha, Rithwik, Rashmi, Karan, Gurmeet etc etc come as participants in Comedy Circus ...I would be upset to see Bharti, or Krishna/Sudesh, Kapil, Mantra get eliminated at the cost of these non-comedians.

Quote

sukanya

@sukanyasylvia

Explorer

Posted: 12 years ago

#16

bharti is doing a great job.can not say who is being kept forcefully in the show- bharti or gurmeet?with no weight issue gurmeet can not do something great and exceptional and impress the judges.at least with so many thins holding her back,bharti is trying her best and her comedy is added to entertain the viewers.if for entertainment KJ can be made judge of this dance show,bharti can also stay as a participant for that.but seeing gurmeet's staying we can not say it is gross injustice to other participants.after all entertainment is needed in such shows.however the strong and truly deserving contestants are there to be in finale,i hope.

Quote

dua_44ever

@dua_44ever

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 12 years ago

#17

I hardly comment on this forum but I'd partially agree with you. Yes she is improving and yes she has proved her point that with dancing size doesn't matter but the fact is that the level of dance it too high compared to her improvement. I mean how is it fair to keep Bharti in the show and eliminate Karan Wahi? I don't understand that...

Quote

Shaitaan Haiwan

@Shaitan-Haiwan

Stunner

+ 8

Posted: 12 years ago

#18

I agree that a lot of contestants who were better than Bharti are out (Darsheel, Shibani, Karan, etc)

But this show is MORE than just about dancing.

I feel that Bharti has a story and a motivation behind her. Doing a simple step is difficult for her. I think we all know how many over-weight people there are in the world who feel helpless and demoralized,

Bharti may be all about comedy, but there is a very strong message being sent to the world by having her on the show. I know some people who see her performances and break into tears because they are just like her and it gives them motivation to try something new.

I think thats why she is getting so much votes. Ultimately the show is all about a non-dancer constantly improving.

I think on THAT basis, Bharti certainly deserves to stay. I am pretty sure she is going to be out next week, but this last performance of her was just amazing.

I am not going to lie, but I actually only watch the show for her even though I know she is not the best one and might be undeserving.

The fact that a huge star like Kareena Kapoor stood up and clapped for Bharti is such a big achievement. 👏

Edited by DIDfan89 - 12 years ago

Quote

~*sindhu*~

@~*sindhu*~

Sparkler

Posted: 12 years ago

#19

Gonna comment for the first time here cause I agree with the topic maker ...now I don't believe she is going to win neither do I want her to win ...but I think she is the most hard working contestant in the show ever ...If she has pulled off so far it's because of her own hard work and determination to not give up...it's not easy dancing with that kind of a body structure and I m sure every muscle in her cries in tremendous pain after every practice session ...so much so that it becomes difficult moving ur limbs the next day ...yet she doesn't give up...yet she pushes herself out of her confort zone every single time ...which is not very common among the other contestants I feel ...

About being fair ...I feel nuthn is fair in this show to begin with ...how do we compare professional dancers with non professional dancers on the same radar and call it competition ...how do we judge all the contestants on the same parameters when they all come from different walks of life ...with different kind of abilities and stamina ...that doesn't seem fair to me ...what is again not fair is the elimination of shibani and darsheel before the current contestants when they are in every way possible better than them ...Infact I found Avneet a better dancer than Isha ...and yet they are out ...thats just how this competition works I guess...how do we call it fair under such circumstances ... if all these things happens and it was ok ...if Isha being not eliminated for two weeks because of her past performances while other contestants work their guts out in each performance ...why can't Bharti be judged on her own growth as a dancer and not be compared with others ...

I think she deserves much more than winning this competition ...and she has ...she has won the respect of the nation ...and I wouldn't be unhappy is she is eliminated ...of course being dance show ...it needs to have a winner with outstanding dancing abilities or outstanding growth ...but I sincerely hope that colors come out with a different award especially for Bharti ...cause that girl has just proved to the world what the word ' possible ' truly means ...she deserves every bit of love the country showers on her ...

but thats just my opinion :p